Retribution Responsibility Tracer
Last updated: September 15, 2026
Process skill. Given a scored retribution event (from retribution-assessment-framework), attribute it to the officials in its responsibility chain — and do so under the charter’s load-bearing naming rule. This is the highest-defamation-risk step in the whole tracker; treat every name as an accusation that must survive hostile scrutiny.
The naming rule (non-negotiable)
A person’s name enters
responsible[]as the actor of a role ONLY after passing the Documented evidence tier. Below Documented, store the role only —responsibility: "inferred", noname— and never render an inferred person as the actor anywhere.
- The office/agency may always be named (
agency) even when no individual is — institutional responsibility is not a personal accusation. - Marquee anchors (Comey, Letitia James, Jack Smith, targeted law firms, targeted universities) must be verified to Documented before any responsible name is committed.
Roles to trace
role |
Who to look for | Best evidence |
|---|---|---|
orderer |
Who directed the act | EO signature block; on-record directive; named reporting |
approver |
Who signed off / ratified | Agency memo; official statement |
signatory |
Who signed the legal instrument (DOJ subpoenas, indictments, filings) | Court docket / signature block (primary_official) |
notifier |
Who delivered the termination / notice | Termination email or letter; named reporting |
executor |
Who carried out the mechanics | Agency action record |
spokesperson |
Who publicly justified / coordinated | Briefing transcript; on-record statement |
Method
- Start from the instrument. A signed instrument (indictment, EO, subpoena, termination letter) usually contains its signatory — go to the primary record first (PACER/court docket, Federal Register, agency FOIA release). That is the fastest route to a Documented signatory.
- DOJ signatory tracing (prosecutions/subpoenas): identify who signed the indictment or subpoena on the docket. A signature block is
primary_officialand supports naming at Documented tier (e.g. the signer of the Comey indictment). - Corroborate orderers/approvers with multi-outlet reporting. Reporting that names an orderer is
credibly_reported— enough to name the role, but the individual stays inferred unless the naming is itself tied to a primary record or on-record admission. - Assign each party
evidence_tier(documented / credibly_reported / alleged),source+source_url+source_tier,confidence, and setresponsibility:
documented→ includename(+profile_slugif a profile exists)inferred→ omitname; recordrole+agencyonly.
- Default to inferred when uncertain. If you cannot tie an individual to a primary record, do not name them. A role-only row is always safe; a wrong name is a defamation exposure.
Evidence tiers (from patriot-accountability-profile-standards.mdc)
documented— primary record, court filing, signed order, on-record admission, or judicial finding → required to name.credibly_reported— multi-outlet reputable reporting → name the role, not the person.alleged— single-source / contested → tracking only,confidence: low, never named.
Output
Populate the event’s responsible[] with schema-valid parties. When a documented official has (or warrants) an accountability profile, set profile_slug and, where scored, dms_ref. Officials without a profile flow into docs/retribution-profile-backlog.md.
Composes with
retribution-assessment-framework · patriot-retribution-tracker · legal-research-specialist · judicial-decision-analytics-specialist · public-records-research-specialist · corporate-intelligence-investigator · malice-evaluator
