Public Meeting Monitoring
Last updated: November 15, 2026
Instructions
You follow the meetings where local and state decisions are made in public: city councils, county boards and commissions, school boards, canvassing boards, state legislative committees and federal advisory committees. You find each meeting, get its record, transcribe it, and check everything you would quote or count against the source video and the minutes. The output is a meeting note per meeting (Section 4) and, at each election, a certification watch table (Section 5). This skill never publishes.
The core rule: never quote an AI summary without the timestamped clip. An AI summary, a machine transcript or a vendor’s highlight is a tip. A quote, a vote or a statement of what a body decided goes into a draft only with the video link and the start and end time where it happens, checked by a person who watched that clip. Section 4 says how.
Composes:
hearing-prep-and-analysis: the transcript-annotation method (segment by topic, map assertions to exhibits, flag clusters) and the answer taxonomy, applied to a local board instead of a committee. This skill is its local-board counterpart.election-law-and-administration: canvass, certification, observation and challenges, for the county-certification watch (Section 5).government-oversight-mechanisms: the standing accountability machinery behind a meeting, and federal advisory committees (Section 6).document-research-specialist: transcription and OCR, subject to its own caveat that cloud transcription is for public-record audio only (Section 3).
Use a different skill when:
- the meeting is a congressional hearing:
hearing-prep-and-analysis, or thehearing-watch-agent. That agent cannot be reused as-is for a local board: its pre-hearing stage reads Congress.gov’s committee schedule and builds a memo around a committee and its witnesses, and a council or county board has neither; - watching an agency web page for edits or deletions: Citizen Analyst’s page-change monitoring method (this skill borrows its watch-list and capture mechanics for an agenda page);
- deciding whether you may scrape a site at all:
scraping-ethics-and-methods; - a state’s open-meetings and public-records law (notice, closed sessions, minutes on request):
foia-and-sunshine-laws; - a number said at the meeting:
numbers-and-statistics-integrity.
Ground every factual claim about a tool, a law or a past meeting through scripts/ca_research.py and cite it. Never state a deadline or a legal duty from memory.
1. Find the meetings
| Route | What it gives | How | What it does not give |
|---|---|---|---|
Legistar (api.legistar, on main) |
For a city or county that uses Legistar: its meetings (events), its legislation (matters) and its committees (bodies) |
scripts/ca_research.py api api.legistar "" --extra client=; kind=matters searches matter titles; kind=bodies lists committees. is the first label of the city’s address. Measured 2026-11-14 (seattle, “City Council”): five meetings newest first, the next scheduled ones on top, each with its date, time, agenda and minutes status and a link to the meeting page |
Not every place uses Legistar. A slug Legistar does not know is refused, naming it. The body filter is a substring match (Seattle’s “City Council” also returned a “Notice of Possible Quorum” body). Five results per call. Some cities need a token (LEGISTAR_TOKEN, absent by default). The Web API states no licence or terms; the client records that as an open question for the approving editor |
| The body’s own site | Calendar, agenda, packet, minutes, video | Read it in a browser, or search it: scripts/ca_research.py search " agenda" --domains |
Nothing is standard: each clerk posts differently |
LocalView (api.localview, branch jr-p6-4, not yet merged) |
Past meetings on YouTube: title, meeting date, predicted place, government type, and the auto-caption text | Offline: a person downloads the Dataverse files once; scripts/ca_research.py api api.localview " |
Lead only (lead_only=True on every finding). It runs about six months behind by design and cannot give the next meeting date. Its captions are YouTube’s auto-captions and its place is the team’s prediction. A finding points you at a video to watch |
| City Bureau Documenters | Notes and live-posts by paid, trained residents from public meetings in 23 active cities (7 more in hibernation, documenters.org, 2026-11-14) | Read in a browser, cite with attribution (Section 7) | Not a feed for us: the site’s terms forbid automated access or monitoring without City Bureau’s permission. Notes are a person’s account, not the minutes |
| Federal advisory committees | Meetings announced in the Federal Register | A notice must be published at least 7 calendar days before the meeting, with the agenda summary and whether it is open or closed (41 CFR § 102-3.150(a), read 2026-11-14) | Section 6 |
Not used, and why (JR P6.4):
- CivicBand (civic.band, minutes and agendas from 1,235 municipalities): blocked by its terms (“All rights reserved”) and an Anubis bot wall on its data routes, and its robots.txt disallows its databases to AI agents and scrapers. A reporter may read it in a browser and then get the record from the body itself.
- City Scrapers (City Bureau, code MIT): City Bureau’s hosted meeting feeds state no data terms, so we do not read them. Running the MIT spiders ourselves, per city, is a recorded future option, not built.
Before a meeting you care about, note the agenda posting time and the body’s notice rule under the state’s open-meetings law (foia-and-sunshine-laws). A late-posted or vague agenda item is itself a fact worth recording.
2. Get the record
Collect, for each meeting, in this order of authority:
- Approved minutes: the body’s official record of what it decided. Check whether the minutes you hold are approved or a draft; Legistar’s meeting row shows a minutes status. Cite the minutes for a vote or a motion.
- The video, with its URL: the record of what was said. Capture the meeting page before you cite it (
make capture, R2archive-before-cite). - The agenda and packet: what was proposed, and the staff reports and contracts behind it.
- An official transcript, if the body publishes one. Council transcripts can be accurate but arrive days or weeks late and carry no video times (citymeetings.nyc’s builder, on New York’s Legistar transcripts).
Everything else, AI summaries, vendor highlights, Documenters notes, LocalView captions and your own transcript, is a way into the record, not the record.
3. Transcribe
Public-meeting audio is public-record audio. R5 (.cursor/rules/transcription-confidentiality.mdc, rule 2) allows a cloud transcription service for it: “the audio is already public, and nothing in it is ours to protect”. document-research-specialist §2 lists the tools.
Citizen Analyst’s own tool is local: make transcribe AUDIO= (CA PR #457, branch jr-p5-3). It runs faster-whisper on this machine, offline, with outbound sockets refused, and writes and with each segment’s start and end seconds and the input’s sha256. It needs pip install -r requirements-transcribe.txt and, once, make transcribe-model. It has no speaker labels.
Which applies when:
- Use
make transcribe TAG=publicby default, once it is installed: nothing leaves the machine, and the segment times map to the video when the audio was taken from that video from its start (record any offset). - A cloud service is allowed for a public meeting’s audio when the local tool is not installed or a meeting is too long for the machine, under the reporter’s or the newsroom’s account and terms.
- It is source audio, not public-record audio, when someone gave you a recording of a closed session, a recording made on their own phone that could identify them, or anything recorded outside the public meeting. Then R5 rule 1 applies:
make transcribe TAG=source, local only. When in doubt, it is source audio.
A machine transcript is labelled (machine-readable; verify) wherever it is quoted in notes (document-research-specialist).
4. Verify against the source video: the clip rule
AI tools for public meetings are useful for finding things and unreliable for stating them:
- A Civic Sunlight newsletter told Concord, New Hampshire readers that the council had approved funding for two projects. The Concord Monitor noted that neither was true: one had only been discussed, and the other had been funded years before (CJR, 15 May 2025).
- Chalkbeat’s tool “struggled to accurately identify individual speakers”, and its managing editor for local news calls the summaries “a tip”: “you need to check it out” (Nieman Lab, 13 March 2025).
For every quote, vote or decision you would write down:
- Find it in the video and note the URL and the start and end time. A quote without a clip is not used.
- Watch the clip. Transcribe the words yourself from it, exactly. Fix the machine transcript; never the other way round.
- Name the speaker from the video: the chair’s recognition, the nameplate, the roll call or the sign-in sheet. Never from a diarization label or a summary.
- Check a vote against the minutes: the motion’s wording, who moved it, the tally and each member’s vote. If the minutes are not approved yet, say so, and check again when they are.
- Check a number said aloud against the packet or its source (
numbers-and-statistics-integrity).
The meeting note (one per meeting): body, date, meeting type, agenda link and posting time, minutes link and status, video link; then a table of items with columns: item, what happened, the clip (URL with start and end times), the minutes reference, and verified by and on. Then apply hearing-prep-and-analysis §3: segment by topic, map each assertion to a document, flag clusters of non-answers, and record commitments (“staff will report back”) in a commitments ledger with a due date.
Public commenters are private people. A resident who speaks at public comment is on the record but is not a public official. Before naming one in a draft beyond the meeting record, and always for a minor, apply patriot-private-citizen-inclusion-gate, and prefer to reach them as a source rather than quoting the clip alone.
5. The county-certification watch
No live county-certification tracker exists that could be verified (review 2026-11-11, §14.4). Since the 2020 election, local officials have refused or delayed what the Brennan Center calls their “mandatory duty to certify” (June 2025). In July 2024 the Washoe County, Nevada, commission voted 3 to 2 against certifying primary recount results. The Secretary of State filed a mandamus petition in the state supreme court; the commission then certified 4 to 1, and the court dismissed the petition as moot (Brennan Center, citing Aguilar v. Washoe County Board of County Commissioners, No. 88965). So at each election we build our own watch:
- Scope. List the counties in scope: those a published document covers, plus any where a board member has said they may not certify (a lead to confirm from the record, not an assumption).
- Who certifies, and by when. For each state, establish from
election-law-and-administrationwhich body canvasses and certifies at the county level, then read the deadline in the statute itself:
- Use NCSL’s “Election Certification Deadlines” brief (updated 14 October 2026) and “Canvass Deadlines” summary only as a finder: they give the statute citation. The summary itself notes that in six states the language for completing the state canvass is “vague, open to interpretation, or not specified”.
- Read the statute on the state legislature’s site through
scripts/ca_research.py extract, and record the citation, the text and the date read. Never take a deadline from NCSL, a news story or memory. - Worked example, read 2026-11-14: Nevada’s NRS 293.387 says the board of county commissioners “shall meet and canvass the returns. The canvass must be completed on or before the 10th day following the election”, and that the certified abstract is made “by an order made and entered in the minutes of its proceedings”.
- Watch the agendas.
- Where the county uses Legistar:
--extra kind=matterswith “canvass” and then “certif” as the search term, and--extra kind=eventswith the board’s name for the meeting dates. - Where it does not, or as well: a changedetection.io watch on the board’s agenda page. Each watch needs a KB subject slug, an editor’s approval (
approved_by,approved_on), a host on the egress allowlist and a check interval no faster than 6 hours. It has no keyword filter: every change to the page alerts, and triage reads the diff for a canvass or certification item. Capture and triage follow the page-change monitoring method: snapshot and hash each change into the evidence store, then read the diff before anything is reported.
- Record each county in the watch table: county, certifying body, statutory deadline (citation, date read), meeting date, agenda item, outcome (certified, delayed, voted against, recessed), vote tally, the minutes that record it, the video clip, and the next step under state law.
- When a board delays or votes against, report the vote, each member’s stated reason from the clip, the deadline, and what the statute or a court says happens next. Do not call a delay unlawful unless a court or the state’s chief election official has said so, and cite them. An indictment, such as the 2023 indictments of two Cochise County, Arizona, supervisors over the 2022 canvass (Votebeat), is an allegation, not a finding.
Votebeat’s reporting is reading for context and for leads, not data.
6. State legislatures and federal advisory committees
- State legislative committees post agendas and video on the legislature’s own site. The method is Sections 2 to 4. For prep before a high-stakes committee hearing,
hearing-prep-and-analysis§1 applies with the state committee in place of the congressional one. - Federal advisory committees (FACA) announce meetings in the Federal Register at least 7 calendar days ahead, stating whether the meeting is open or closed and, if closed, which Government in the Sunshine Act exemption applies (41 CFR § 102-3.150(a)).
government-oversight-mechanismsmaps the agency, its inspector general and GAO behind a committee’s subject. The Federal Register and eCFR sites refuse scripted page reads; use their APIs or a mirror such as Cornell LII.
7. Licences, services and conduct
- Documenters notes are CC BY 4.0. documenters.org (read 2026-11-14): “All Documenters content is published and may be freely used under the Attribution 4.0 International Creative Commons license”. Credit “Documenters.org”, the Documenter and the local partner, with a link, and never imply City Bureau’s endorsement. Its terms forbid “any robot, spider or other automatic device” to monitor or copy the site without permission: read it in a browser; no scraper and no changedetection watch on it.
- Legistar: no licence or terms stated on the Web API pages; what it returns is what the clerk already publishes. Open question for the approving editor (
legistar.pydocstring). - LocalView: CC0 1.0 for what the authors own. The captions are YouTube’s machine text of governments’ videos: quote a short excerpt only, and link the video.
- CivicBand and City Bureau’s hosted feeds: not used (Section 1).
- changedetection.io: Apache License 2.0, run as a pinned container.
- Services a reporter may use on their own account, under their own terms, not Citizen Analyst infrastructure:
- SeeGov, a nonprofit founded in 2023 whose “Backstage” access offers searchable transcripts, moment-by-moment summaries and clips from unaltered source video (paid newsroom plans; free for hyperlocal newsrooms with limited funds);
- Civic Sunlight, emailed AI summaries with links to timestamps and keyword alerts;
- LocalLens, the vendor Chalkbeat uses across about 80 school districts;
- citymeetings.nyc, New York City Council meetings with AI-drafted chapters reviewed by its builder and sentence-level video timestamps.
Their output is a lead; the clip rule applies to every line of it. Peter’s licence rule applies to anything used as data: no non-commercial-only or research-only data.
- Conduct (R6
scraping-conduct): honour robots.txt and terms, throttle, never watch behind a login.
Sources
Read through scripts/ca_research.py on 2026-11-14 unless marked otherwise.
- Documenters.org, “Creative Commons License”, https://www.documenters.org/creative-commons; “Terms of Use” (last modified 1 October 2026), https://www.documenters.org/terms-of-service; “About”, https://www.documenters.org/about.
- City Bureau, “AI Is Increasingly Shaping Local Journalism. How Do We Keep People at the Center?”, 24 June 2025, https://www.citybureau.org/notebook/2025/6/24/ai-is-increasingly-shaping-local-journalism-how-do-we-keep-people-at-the-center.
- Andrew Deck, “Local newsrooms are using AI to listen in on public meetings”, Nieman Lab, 13 March 2025, https://www.niemanlab.org/2025/03/local-newsrooms-are-using-ai-to-listen-in-on-public-meetings (read from an archived copy).
- Roberto Ferdman, “The Rise of AI Local News”, Columbia Journalism Review, 15 May 2025, https://www.cjr.org/analysis/ai-local-news-civic-sunlight-maine.php.
- Vikram Oberoi, “How citymeetings.nyc uses AI to make it easy to navigate city council meetings”, https://vikramoberoi.com/posts/how-citymeetings-nyc-uses-ai-to-make-it-easy-to-navigate-city-council-meetings.
- SeeGov, “About”, https://seegov.org/about; Civic Sunlight, https://civicsunlight.ai.
- Lauren Miller Karalunas, “Election Certification”, Brennan Center for Justice, 17 June 2025, https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/policy-solutions/election-certification.
- Jen Fifield, “Two Cochise County supervisors indicted for refusing to certify midterm election”, Votebeat, 29 November 2023, https://www.votebeat.org/arizona/2023/11/29/arizona-cochise-county-supervisors-indicted-refusing-certify-2022-election; Votebeat, “2024 Election Certification”, https://www.votebeat.org/2024-election-certification.
- NCSL, “Election Certification Deadlines” (updated 14 October 2026), https://www.ncsl.org/elections-and-campaigns/election-certification-deadlines; “Canvass Deadlines” (updated 9 July 2025), https://www.ncsl.org/elections-and-campaigns/canvass-deadlines.
- Nevada Revised Statutes chapter 293, NRS 293.387, https://www.leg.state.nv.us/nrs/nrs-293.html.
- 41 CFR § 102-3.150, https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/41/102-3.150 (eCFR itself refused the scripted read).
- City Bureau,
city-scrapers(MIT), https://github.com/City-Bureau/city-scrapers. - Citizen Analyst code:
scripts/lib/osint_api/legistar.py(main);scripts/lib/osint_api/localview.py(branchjr-p6-4);deploy/linux/changedetection/andscripts/lib/changedetection.py(PR #458);scripts/ca_transcribe.pyandscripts/lib/transcribe.py(PR #457);.cursor/rules/transcription-confidentiality.mdc(R5, branchjr-p9-5),archive-before-cite.mdc(R2) andscraping-conduct.mdc(R6). The CivicBand and City Scrapers findings are JR P6.4’s.
Cross-references
hearing-prep-and-analysis: transcript annotation, the answer taxonomy and the commitments ledger.election-law-and-administration: canvass, certification, observation and challenges.government-oversight-mechanisms: the oversight machinery behind a meeting’s subject; federal advisory committees.document-research-specialist: transcription and OCR tools, and the public-record-audio-only caveat.- Citizen Analyst’s page-change monitoring method: the watch list, capture and triage for an agenda page.
foia-and-sunshine-laws: notice rules, closed sessions, and asking for minutes or a recording (requests are drafted for a human to file).secure-source-communication: when a recording is source audio.patriot-private-citizen-inclusion-gate: before naming a public commenter.numbers-and-statistics-integrity: a figure said at a meeting.- Citizen Analyst’s story-discovery method: a meeting lead becoming a story.
Safety
- Never quote an AI summary without the timestamped clip, watched by a person.
- Votes come from the minutes, not from a summary or a transcript; say when the minutes are still a draft.
- Never state a certification deadline from memory: the statute, its citation, the date you read it.
- A delay is not a crime and an indictment is not a finding. Report the vote, the reasons given and what the law or a court says next.
- When in doubt, it is source audio: transcribe it locally with
TAG=source. - Public commenters are private people: the inclusion gate before naming one, always for a minor.
- Not legal advice. What a statute requires of a board, whether a delay is lawful, and what an open-meetings law allows are questions for the statute, a court or counsel; this skill tells you where to read them.
- Symmetry. The same standard whichever party controls the board and whichever way the story cuts.
