Local News Sourcing and Corroboration
Editorial & Assessment

Local News Sourcing and Corroboration

Skip to main content
Table of Contents
< All Topics
Print

Local News Sourcing and Corroboration

Last updated: November 15, 2026

Instructions

You find what local outlets reported about an event and decide how many independent sources the reporting amounts to. The output is a coverage log: every hit, its outlet, its owner group, its origin, its registry status, and a corroboration verdict. This skill never publishes.

Use a different skill when:

  • checking a claim inside the reporting (a number, a quote, a date): fact-checking;
  • scoring the sourcing of a Citizen Analyst document: source-credibility-scoring (this skill’s coverage log feeds its source-mix dimension);
  • rating an outlet’s credibility in general, or building a credibility list: news-credibility-scoring;
  • deciding whether a photo or video in a report is authentic: media-verification-specialist;
  • investigating the officers or agency behind the event: law-enforcement-accountability-investigation.

Ground every factual claim about an outlet or a method through scripts/ca_research.py and cite it. Never state an outlet’s owner, licence or status from memory: read the registry entry’s notes, then the record they name.


1. Find the coverage

Route How What it gives you
GDELT DOC 2.0 scripts/ca_research.py api api.gdelt_doc "" --extra sourcecountry=us --extra timespan=7d --agent . One outlet: add --extra domain= Leads only. Every finding carries lead_only: true and a snippet starting “LEAD ONLY”. GDELT indexes what outlets published; a hit says an outlet ran a story, not that it is true
Registry-scoped search scripts/ca_research.py search " " --domains , --agent . Pick the domains from gui/config/sources-registry.yaml entries tagged local-news and the state Articles from known outlets. Each one’s registry status decides what it counts as (Section 2)
Outlet RSS scripts/ca_research.py extract /feed/ --agent The newest items. Use it where a homepage challenges scripts (the States Newsroom outlets do); never work around a challenge
Open the article scripts/ca_research.py extract --agent The byline, dateline and credit line you need for Section 3. If a page comes back as unreadable bytes, do not cite from it: re-extract it later or find another copy, and say which you used

GDELT, as the client and GDELT’s own launch post describe it:

  • The host allows one request per 5 seconds per address. The client refuses a second call inside its window rather than waiting, and a 429 means another process on the same address spent the slot. Do not retry in a loop. A cached repeat costs nothing.
  • domain: is a suffix match: GDELT’s example is domain:un.org also returning catholicsun.org. Check each hit’s domain field.
  • sourcecountry takes a country name without spaces or its two-letter FIPS code.
  • The DOC API searches a rolling window of about three months. For anything older, use search and the outlet’s own archive.
  • The GEO 2.0 endpoint is dead; the client never calls it.
  • Copies of one wire story under several outlets’ headlines are collapsed by the client. That is the first syndication check, not the last (Section 3).

Not available for this skill: Media Cloud’s state collections (the account and its terms are an open decision for Peter), and Google News RSS (no stated terms). See Section 5.

News deserts. The Medill State of Local News 2026 map counts 238 counties with no local news outlet and 1,478 with only one. In those counties, finding nothing is not evidence that nothing happened. Say “no local outlet covers this county”, and go to the state networks and the public record (court dockets, agency releases, council minutes).


2. Classify each hit: source, lead or flag

What the hit is Counts as Why
A registry entry with enabled: true Source, at its FRS An editor confirmed its FRS and bias
A registry entry with enabled: false (its note starts “Proposed … editor to confirm”) Lead A proposed outlet is not trusted until the editor enables it on Ops → Sources. Its FRS is a placeholder, and the corroboration code already skips it
A domain not in the registry Lead Unregistered domains never count as corroboration
A site in the Metric Media or Local Government Information Services (LGIS) networks Flag, never corroboration See below
A GDELT hit Lead Open the article; then classify the outlet by the rows above

Pink-slime networks.

  • The Tow Center (2019) found at least 450 sites in 21 networks run by five corporate entities, all tied to Brian Timpone: Metric Media, Locality Labs, Franklin Archer, The Record Inc. and LGIS. They distribute thousands of algorithmically generated articles. By 2021 Metric Media alone ran more than 1,200 local news sites.
  • Tell-tales the Tow Center used: a Locality Labs, LLC privacy policy or terms of service, a shared analytics identifier, and town-named mastheads with no local newsroom.
  • NewsGuard counted 1,265 such sites in June 2024, more than the 1,213 daily newspapers left in the US. It tracks partisan-backed networks on the left and the right, naming Metric Media, LGIS, Courier Newsroom, The American Independent and States Newsroom.
  • A flagged site may be a lead to an underlying record: follow it to the record and cite that. It never counts toward the number of sources.
  • Most States Newsroom outlets are in the registry as proposed (disabled) entries, so they are leads until the editor’s pass; a few, Stateline among them, are already enabled. Check each entry’s enabled. NewsGuard’s listing is a fact for the editor’s pass, not a verdict this skill makes. Either way, a States Newsroom story and its republications are one source (Section 3).

3. Independence: count owners and origins, not mastheads

Two reports corroborate each other only if each newsroom got the fact itself: its own reporter, interview, document or presence. Group the hits; each group is one source.

Same group Example How to spot it
One owner Two Sinclair stations; two Nexstar stations, including one licensed to Mission Broadcasting but operated by Nexstar The registry note’s owner claim and its FCC public-file check. Sinclair describes itself as owning, operating “and/or provid[ing] services to” its stations. Count the operator, not only the licensee
Syndication An AP story under a member paper’s masthead; a States Newsroom story republished by partners or News From The States The credit line. AP is a not-for-profit cooperative whose members are US newspapers and broadcasters. States Newsroom’s republishing guidelines require the original newsroom’s credit and a link back to the original story
Must-run A Sinclair segment aired across its stations Centrally produced segments the stations are required to air. They are not local reporting at all
Rewrite A TV station’s web story built on the local paper’s scoop “As first reported by”, a partnership credit, the same quotes in the same order. The source is the original
Pink slime Any Metric Media or LGIS site Section 2. Excluded, not grouped

What the code counts (scripts/lib/corroboration.py as of CA PR #449, JR P4.2). independent_sources() and assess():

  • count only items source_credibility.tag_items matched to the registry (an exact or subdomain host match);
  • skip entries with enabled: false;
  • fold a registry alias into its primary through alias_of, so thecity.nyc and thecityreporter.nyc are one source;
  • treat two items as one source when their registry entries share an owner_group (the owner or operator, e.g. sinclair, nexstar, states-newsroom), when they come from the same host (www. stripped) and the entry has no group, or when their headlines share their first eight normalised words. These links are transitive: every connected set counts once, represented by its highest-FRS item. assess() reports owner_groups beside independent_domains;
  • set the ceiling: a primary-official source alone gives Documented; two or more independent sources with a top FRS of at least 80 give Documented; one gives Credibly Reported; none gives Alleged.

The code sees ownership only where the registry records it. owner_group is set only where an entry’s notes cite the owner. Partners and affiliates carry no group, and most enabled outlets have none yet. Two things the code cannot catch:

  • a partner’s republication under a rewritten headline;
  • a rewrite by an outlet with a different owner. The items that reach assess() carry no body text or credit line.

So treat its count as a ceiling. Apply this section by hand, and write the owner group and the origin of every source in the coverage log. Where an entry has no owner_group, its owner is free text in notes. Read that note, and where it says a claim was not re-confirmed, check the FCC public file before you rely on it.


4. The workflow, in order

  1. Pin the event. What, where (city and county), when. Name only public officials. Anyone else named in a local report (a person detained, a witness, a rank-and-file officer) goes through patriot-private-citizen-inclusion-gate before you write their name down.
  2. Search by the Section 1 routes. Log every hit with its URL, outlet, date and route.
  3. Open each article. Record the byline, dateline, credit line and any “first reported by”.
  4. Classify each hit (Section 2) and group them by owner and origin (Section 3).
  5. Count independent groups that contain an enabled registry source.
  • Two or more: the report is corroborated. That is still reporting, not an established fact; check the claims with fact-checking.
  • One: single-sourced. Say so.
  • None: say what you found and where you looked.
  1. Find the record behind the story. A court filing, an agency release or the council minutes outranks any number of outlets, and on its own justifies Documented.
  2. Media. Verify any photo or video you will rely on with media-verification-specialist, and archive each cited article (Wayback capture, hash) as that skill describes.
  3. Hand off. The coverage log goes to source-credibility-scoring for the document’s DCS and to the editor. A proposed outlet that kept coming up is a candidate for the editor’s Ops → Sources pass.

5. Licences (Peter’s rule)

  • Cite and link; never reuse text. States Newsroom outlets publish under CC BY-ND or BY-NC-ND (the registry notes record which). Quote briefly with attribution, and link to the original.
  • GDELT’s terms require any use of its data to cite the GDELT Project with a link. The client’s snippets say “via GDELT Project”; keep that credit in what you write.
  • A data source whose licence is non-commercial or research-only, or that states no terms, is not used (Peter, 2026-11-14). That is why Media Cloud waits on its terms and Google News RSS is not a route. Name the source to the editor instead.
  • RSS gives a headline and a link to follow, not text to reuse.

Sources

Read through scripts/ca_research.py on 2026-11-14.

  • Priyanjana Bengani, “Hundreds of ‘pink slime’ local news outlets are distributing algorithmic stories and conservative talking points”, Tow Center / CJR, 18 Dec 2019, https://www.cjr.org/tow_center_reports/hundreds-of-pink-slime-local-news-outlets-are-distributing-algorithmic-stories-conservative-talking-points.php.
  • Priyanjana Bengani, “The Metric Media network runs more than 1,200 local news sites”, Tow Center / CJR, 14 Oct 2021, https://www.cjr.org/tow_center_reports/metric-media-lobbyists-funding.php.
  • NewsGuard, “Sad Milestone: Fake Local News Sites Now Outnumber Real Local Newspaper Sites in U.S.”, 11 Jun 2024, https://www.newsguardtech.com/press/sad-milestone-fake-local-news-sites-now-outnumber-real-local-newspaper-sites-in-u-s; The Guardian, 20 Jun 2024, https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/article/2024/jun/20/fake-news-websites-us-election.
  • Los Angeles Times, “Backlash grows over Sinclair Broadcast Group’s ‘must-run’ conservative content on local TV stations”, 5 Apr 2018, https://www.latimes.com/business/hollywood/la-fi-ct-sinclair-promo-20180405-story.html; Sinclair, company boilerplate (“owns, operates and/or provides services to 185 television stations in 86 markets”), https://sbgi.net/sinclair-expands-multicast-network-footprint-in-top-ten-u-s-dmas.
  • States Newsroom, Republishing guidelines, https://statesnewsroom.com/republishing-guidelines.
  • The Associated Press, congressional testimony, 2015 (“a not-for-profit news cooperative. Its members are U.S. newspapers and broadcasters”), https://www.ap.org/media-center/press-releases/2015/ensuring-an-informed-citizenry-examining-the-administrations-efforts-to-improve-open-government.
  • GDELT Project, “GDELT DOC 2.0 API Debuts!”, https://blog.gdeltproject.org/gdelt-doc-2-0-api-debuts (operators, the three-month window); Terms of Use, https://www.gdeltproject.org/about.html (quoted in scripts/lib/osint_api/gdelt_doc.py).
  • Medill Local News Initiative, The State of Local News 2026, https://localnewsinitiative.northwestern.edu/projects/state-of-local-news/explore and https://localnewsinitiative.northwestern.edu/projects/state-of-local-news/2026/report.
  • Citizen Analyst code and data: scripts/lib/corroboration.py, scripts/lib/source_credibility.py, gui/services/source_registry_service.py (aliases), gui/config/sources-registry.yaml.

Cross-references

  • fact-checking: the claims inside a corroborated report.
  • source-credibility-scoring: the document’s DCS; the coverage log feeds its source mix.
  • media-verification-specialist: photos, video and archiving.
  • news-credibility-scoring: an outlet’s credibility in general.
  • patriot-private-citizen-inclusion-gate: before naming anyone in a local report who is not a public official.
  • law-enforcement-accountability-investigation: the officers and agency behind an enforcement event.
  • Citizen Analyst’s story-discovery method: leads from our own data, GDELT included. Its output is leads, never claims.

Safety

  • Live operations. Never publish the location or timing of an enforcement operation in progress, even when a local outlet has.
  • Leads are not sources. A GDELT hit, an unregistered site and a proposed outlet point to reporting; none of them is counted as corroboration.
  • Pink slime is never a source, even when it agrees with the record.
  • One owner, one source. Never present syndicated or co-owned coverage as independent confirmation.
  • Silence is not a finding. In a news desert, no coverage is a fact about the press, not about the event.
  • Symmetry. The same independence test applies whichever way a report cuts.
Was this article helpful?
0 out of 5 stars
5 Stars 0%
4 Stars 0%
3 Stars 0%
2 Stars 0%
1 Stars 0%
5
Please Share Your Feedback
How Can We Improve This Article?