Federal Aviation Administration — Agency Damage Assessment
Last updated: November 17, 2026
Institution: Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), a bureau of the Department of Transportation (DOT). Level: bureau. The parent, department-of-transportation, has no profile in this knowledge base; the slug is recorded as a string only. Status: Scored, coverage 80 percent. Workforce from the OPM primary record by occupational series and pay plan; leadership from dated captures of the FAA’s own key-officials page; funding from the FAA budget justification, the agency financial report and OMB apportionments; legal record from the Fourth Circuit’s opinion. Evidence cutoff: 2026-11-17 (ada_as_of). OPM through the 202609 snapshot, retrieved 2026-11-17 (E1, E36); OMB apportionment for DOT/FAA, FY2024 to FY2026, retrieved 2026-11-17 (E33); USAspending retrieved 2026-10-09 (E3). Damage index: 24 of 100. Band: Strained. Confidence: Medium. Recoverability: 1 (H1); binding constraint leadership.
Agency at a Glance
| Item | Detail | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Mission | Not retrieved this pass in the agency’s own words. Its statutory work is air traffic control and airspace management, aviation safety regulation and certification, airport grants and commercial space launch licensing (functions table below) | Statute citations below (not re-verified) |
| Statutory basis | 49 U.S.C. § 106 establishes the FAA as an administration in DOT, headed by an Administrator appointed with the advice and consent of the Senate for a five-year term. Citation from standing knowledge, not opened this pass | 49 U.S.C. § 106 (not opened) |
| Parent / level | Bureau of the Department of Transportation | E4 |
| Pre-2025 headcount | 46,461 people in the OPM December 2024 snapshot (46,366 in January 2025); OPM unit TD:TD03. People on the payroll, not FTE. OPM publishes monthly snapshots, so there is no 2025-01-19 count; December 2024 is the last snapshot wholly before the administration | E1 |
| Pre-2025 budget | $20,083.3 million enacted for FY2024 (Operations $12,729.6M; Facilities and Equipment $3,191.3M; Research, Engineering and Development $280.0M; Airport Improvement Program obligation limitation $3,350M plus a $532.4M general-fund supplement), computed from the FAA’s ten-year tables. CRS counts $25,081M with the IIJA advance appropriation | E44 |
| Current headcount | 44,549 people (OPM, September 2026): net minus 1,912, minus 4.1 percent against December 2024. Gross: 8,197 separations and 6,471 accessions, January 2025 to September 2026 | E1 |
| Air traffic controllers | OPM series 2152 (all air traffic control positions): 18,730 (December 2024) to 19,772 (September 2026), plus 5.6 percent (computed, E36). FAA facility on-board count: 13,774 (September 2024) to 14,223 (end FY2025). GAO counts 13,164 at end FY2025, about 6 percent fewer than FY2015; the FAA and GAO figures for the same definition differ and are not reconciled | E36; E41; E23 |
| Tier-1 positions (declared, 10) | Administrator; Deputy Administrator; Chief Operating Officer of the Air Traffic Organization; Associate Administrators for Aviation Safety, Airports, Commercial Space Transportation, and Security and Hazardous Materials Safety; Chief Counsel; Assistant Administrator for Finance and Management (the chief financial officer); Assistant Administrator for NextGen. Checked against the FAA’s own key-officials page of 2024-12-20. The stub’s list carried a chief information officer; that page lists none, so it was replaced by the Security and Hazardous Materials Safety line of business, which the page lists | E35; methodology §6 D2 |
| Pre-existing conditions | Controller shortages at critical facilities predate 2025: DOT OIG found in 2023 that 20 of 26 critical facilities were below 85 percent of FAA’s desired staffing (as GAO relays it). The FAA has granted staffing-related relief at Reagan National, JFK and LaGuardia since 2023 and projects the New York TRACON will not reach 70 percent of its target until after 2027. The NTSB found the conditions for the January 2025 Potomac collision “were in place long before the night of Jan. 29”. A 2024 GAO review found 51 of the FAA’s 138 air traffic control systems unsustainable (as DOT relays GAO-24-107001). The routers on the telecommunications network involved in the 2026-11-13 ground stop “were purchased in 2001” and “were obsolete in 2006”, the Secretary said. These set the baseline; they are not 2025 damage | E23; E50; E17; E18; E51 |
Statutory functions
Working list. Citations are from standing knowledge and were not re-verified in this pass.
| ID | Function | Citation | Capability tag | FY2024 baseline measure | Status now |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| F1 | Air traffic control and airspace management | 49 U.S.C. § 40103(b) (not re-verified) | public_service_delivery |
13,774 controllers on board, 10,730 certified (September 2024, E41) | performed. Controllers on board 14,223 at end FY2025 (certified 10,693, about flat); trainee hiring the most since 2008 in FY2025 and a record in FY2026 (E41, E58). Newark operations capped since May 2025 and extended to 2027-10-30 for Philadelphia TRACON Area C staffing, a pre-existing shortfall (E19, E50) |
| F2 | Aviation safety regulation, certification and oversight | 49 U.S.C. § 44701 (not re-verified) | inspection_enforcement |
Aviation safety inspectors about 4,184 at end FY2024 (derived from the FAA plan, E41 via the research record) | performed. OPM aviation safety series 1825: 4,238 to 4,156, minus 1.9 percent (E36). Engineering series down 12.0 percent (D1) |
| F3 | Air navigation facilities, maintenance and aeronautical information (charts, procedures) | 49 U.S.C. § 44502 (not re-verified) | public_service_delivery |
The aeronautical chart and digital product set as published on the 56-day cycle (not otherwise measured) | degraded. Aeronautical Information Services discontinued four charting products with a final publication date of 2025-06-12 (VFR Class B Enhancement Graphics, U.S. and Alaska VFR Wall Planning charts, U.S. IFR/VFR Low Altitude Planning Charts) and took the Chart Users’ Guide off the 56-day cycle (E62). The navigational information series that prepares charts and procedures fell 21.8 percent, two-thirds of its departures through deferred resignation, with fewer than 10 hires (E36); transportation specialists (series 2101) rose 6.0 percent. Core chart and procedure cycle timeliness was not measured. The 2026-11-13 nationwide ground stop on the contractor-owned telecommunications network has no determined root cause and is not attributed here (E51) |
| F4 | Airport Improvement Program grants | 49 U.S.C. ch. 471 (not re-verified) | grant_administration |
AIP $3,350M limitation plus $532.4M general fund (FY2024, E44) | performed. AIP limitation $4,000M in FY2025 and FY2026; IIJA airport grants 64 percent and terminal grants 96 percent obligated to 2025-09-30 (E43, E44) |
| F5 | Commercial space launch and reentry licensing | 51 U.S.C. ch. 509 (not re-verified) | regulatory_review |
Record 148 licensed operations in FY2024 (E42) | performed. 204 launch and reentry operations in FY2025, the highest annual total on record (E42). The office’s Associate Administrator post has been vacant since 2025 (D2) |
Basis for Inclusion
Agency Damage Gate (§1): admitted for scoring by editorial instruction (2026-11-17), Peter’s decision to complete and score this profile. Each §1 indicator on the record is qualified, so the gate as written is not independently met:
- Judicial or oversight finding (D8), qualified: on 2025-03-13 the District of Maryland ordered the reinstatement of probationary employees terminated as part of mass terminations at agencies including DOT, and on 2025-04-01 granted a preliminary injunction; the FAA reinstated the employees PASS represents (E9, E40). In sworn declarations filed in that case, DOT’s Assistant Secretary for Administration, Anne Byrd, stated that DOT terminated about 788 probationary employees department-wide between 2025-02-14 and 2025-02-24, and that it told the 775 of them covered by the order on 2025-03-17 that their terminations were rescinded (E80, E81); the Merit Systems Protection Board later recited that account (E66). Both rulings were preliminary. The Fourth Circuit stayed the injunction on 2025-04-09 and on 2025-09-08 vacated it with directions to dismiss, holding that the plaintiff states lacked standing (E40). No court found the terminations unlawful or the function impaired, which is what §1 asks; the record says “challenged”.
- Measured capacity loss (D1), qualified: agency-wide net change (minus 4.1 percent) is inside the ±5 percent band. Between December 2024 and September 2026 the FAA executive pay plan fell 29.2 percent, attorneys 30.5 percent and aeronautical-information staff 21.8 percent, most through deferred resignation (E36). The pre-2025 range for these groups was not collected, so whether this is “beyond the institution’s own pre-2025 range” is a judgment.
- Statutory function impaired (D3), qualified: Aeronautical Information Services discontinued four charting products in 2025 (E62); whether that is impairment or a product rationalization is not stated on the record.
- Direct interference (D4), qualified: a DOGE team and SpaceX engineers visited the FAA’s Air Traffic Control System Command Center on 2025-02-17 (E86, E5). Three SpaceX engineers, Brady Glantz, Theodore Malaska and Thomas Kiernan, were appointed as unpaid special government employees under DOT ethics waivers dated that day (Documented, E67); a fourth SpaceX engineer, Samuel Smeal, is named by Wired, ProPublica and the Washington Post but has no waiver in the record (Credibly reported, E68, E11, E72). The four held FAA titles and system access until about 2025-06-02 (E72); no documented direction of a statutory decision was found, so this indicator is noted, not relied on.
- Targeted removal (D2), qualified: Tier-1 posts were vacant or acting for long periods, but no removal is documented; the departing heads left through voluntary programs (D2).
Baseline: conditions on 2025-01-19 per dimension (below). The FAA’s most visible 2025–2026 problems (controller shortages, aging telecommunications at the Newark-area facility and on the national network, helicopter route design around Reagan National) are pre-existing conditions on the record cited above, and are kept out of the damage delta.
Stated rationale of the administration:
- On the probationary firings, Secretary Duffy: “At FAA, we cut 352 people out of 50 … sorry, 46,000 people. That’s 0.8 percent of the workforce. These were probationary workers,” and “we kept all the critical safety positions, and we actually hired more positions into critical safety, like air traffic controllers” (The Hill, E6). Earlier, on X: “Less than 400 were let go, and they were all probationary … Zero air traffic controllers and critical safety personnel were let go” (as quoted by CNBC, E5).
- On the deferred resignation program, according to Government Executive, Secretary Duffy said it was “not a scalpel” but would leave the department with employees who are “hungry to do the work”, and that he was willing to unwind cuts as necessary; the acting Administrator told a town hall “we will be leaner in a year, in two years” (E39). Controllers and systems technicians were not eligible for the program (E39; the FAA’s own workforce plans say the same of controllers, E41, and of systems technicians, E73).
- The acting Administrator told staff: “In alignment with the Administration’s goal to make government more efficient, we regrettably had to let go some of our probationary employees last week,” and “the agency has retained employees who perform safety critical functions” (email quoted by Politico, E10). The same email says DOGE and teams of “special government employees” will work to “keep the airspace open and safe” (E10). On 2025-03-27 the acting Administrator told a Senate subcommittee: “There were no DOGE employees in that decision” (on Starlink), and of the SpaceX special government employees, “They came in to observe our operations and provided expertise along the lines of software and computer systems” (hearing print S. Hrg. 119-130, E82; E71); on 2025-04-25 an FAA spokesperson said “DOGE is not spearheading anything at the FAA, nor are there any DOGE employees at FAA” (E70).
- On the January 2026 reorganization, which the department calls “the largest in the agency’s history”: it “will not result in reductions in force” (E47).
- On the November 2025 flight cuts, Secretary Duffy: “This isn’t about politics – it’s about assessing the data and alleviating building risk in the system as controllers continue to work without pay” (FAA release, E21).
- Claimed savings: none located for FAA. The administration describes a controller hiring campaign (“supercharge”, February 2025, per DOT OIG, E24), record trainee hiring (2,235 in FY2026, E58) and the Brand New Air Traffic Control System funded with $12.52 billion (E44, E46) as improvements; they are recorded under Rule 3.
Timeline of Actions
| Date | Action | Instrument | Acting role (name only on a Documented record) | Evidence tier | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024-12-12 | Administrator Mike Whitaker tells employees by letter that he will step down on 2025-01-20 (before the administration took office) | Announced departure | Administrator | Documented (FAA statement) | E52 |
| 2025-01-20 | Whitaker leaves, a little over one year into a five-year term; the Deputy Administrator’s post also changes hands | Departure at transition | Administrator | Documented | E52; E35 |
| 2025-01-30 | A presidential memo names Chris Rocheleau, a 22-year FAA veteran, acting Administrator (CBS calls him the fourth acting Administrator since 2018); the Administrator post had no named occupant from 2025-01-20. By 2025-03-19 the FAA lists him as acting Administrator and the Chief Counsel as acting Deputy | Acting designation | President | Credibly reported (CBS); Documented (FAA page, March) | E63; E14; E35 |
| 2025-01-29 | Midair collision over the Potomac near Reagan National; 67 killed. The NTSB attributes it to FAA route placement, failure to act on recommendations and overreliance on visual separation, among other causes; it makes no finding on hiring policy (see 2026-01-27) | Accident (context) | n/a | Documented (NTSB) | E17; E18 |
| 2025-02-05 (about) | The Secretary posts that he has “enlisted the brightest minds, including SpaceX engineers” to upgrade air traffic control | Outside engineers | Secretary of Transportation | Credibly reported (snippets of the post) | E54 |
| 2025-02-14 | Probationary employees fired, effective 2025-02-14; the notices were emailed between midnight and 2:00 a.m. on 2025-02-15, according to a sworn declaration by the president of an FAA union local (AFSCME Local 1653), which counts at least 45 of its members among them. Secretary Duffy puts the FAA number at 352 (fewer than 400). PASS says 132 to 133 were its members. DOT-wide, about 788 probationers were terminated between 2025-02-14 and 2025-02-24 (DOT declaration) | Probationary terminations | DOT / FAA | Claimed (the Secretary’s 352); Credibly reported (union counts); Documented (DOT-wide count, sworn) | E5; E6; E8; E9; E80; E87 |
| 2025-02-17 | After the Secretary’s announcement late on 2025-02-16, a DOGE team of SpaceX engineers visits the FAA’s Air Traffic Control System Command Center in Warrenton, Virginia, on Monday 2025-02-17, three days after the probationary terminations; the acting Administrator’s 2025-02-19 email says DOGE will expand its footprint | DOGE team; special government employees | Secretary of Transportation (announcement); Acting Administrator (email) | Credibly reported (Reuters, confirmed by Politico, CNBC and Axios) | E86; E5; E10 |
| 2025-02-17 | The same day, DOT’s Designated Agency Ethics Official signs 18 U.S.C. § 208(b)(1) conflict-of-interest waivers for Glantz, Malaska and Kiernan, each a SpaceX engineer appointed as an unpaid special government employee for four days, reporting to the acting Administrator, to review FAA technology including air traffic control systems; they bar decisions on SpaceX funding or contracts and access to commercial space office systems. Smeal, the fourth SpaceX engineer named by Wired, ProPublica and the Washington Post, has no waiver in the record (Credibly reported) | Special government employee appointments; ethics waivers | DOT Designated Agency Ethics Official | Documented (waivers) | E67; E92; E68 |
| 2025-02-21 | A continuation of Malaska’s waiver extends his service “for the duration of your temporary appointment” because the FAA “has identified a plan to address improvements in its air traffic control systems”; no continuation for Glantz or Kiernan is in the record | Waiver continuation | DOT Designated Agency Ethics Official | Documented | E67; E92 |
| 2025-02-24 | The DOGE leader posts that “The Verizon system is not working and so is putting air travelers at serious risk”; the FAA says it is considering Starlink for weather information, and posts that it is testing one Starlink terminal at Atlantic City and two at non-safety-critical sites in Alaska | Public demand (pressure); equipment test | n/a | Credibly reported (post quoted in a Senate letter, snippet; FAA post as reported by CNN, snippet) | E31; E78 |
| 2025-03-13 | District of Maryland TRO orders reinstatement of probationary employees at defendant agencies including DOT; the Fourth Circuit denies a stay on 2025-03-21 | Court order | Court | Documented | E40 |
| 2025-03 | FAA reinstates the probationary employees PASS represents, with back pay from 2025-02-15 and return to duty on 2025-03-20 | Reinstatement | FAA | Credibly reported (union statement) | E9 |
| 2025-03-17 | Bryan Bedford nominated as Administrator | Nomination | President | Credibly reported | E15 |
| 2025-03-17 | DOT tells the 775 “Affected Probationary Employees” covered by the Maryland order, department-wide, that their terminations are rescinded, with back pay from 2025-02-15 and a return to active duty on 2025-03-20; the other 13 of about 788 terminated were outside the order (two performance-based terminations, eight rescinded before the order, two resignations, one deferred resignation). No FAA split | Rescission of terminations | DOT (Assistant Secretary for Administration Anne Byrd, sworn declaration, ECF 52-1) | Documented | E80 |
| 2025-03-24 | Status date of DOT’s second declaration (filed 2025-03-25, ECF 103-1): all 775 were contacted and returned to active duty on 2025-03-20; 92 had resigned and the other 683 were on duty or on voluntary leave. DOT-wide; the FAA’s share of the 775 and of the 92 is not in the record. The MSPB recited this declaration in its 2026-10-29 order | Rescission of terminations | DOT (Anne Byrd, sworn declaration) | Documented | E81; E66 |
| 2025-03-27 | At the Senate Aviation Subcommittee hearing on the NTSB’s preliminary report, the acting Administrator says: “We had three special government employees from SpaceX. We are only in contact with one at this point”; they “did not plug into any of the equipment” and “came in to observe our operations”; on Starlink, “There were no DOGE employees in that decision”. The hearing print holds no question to him on the probationary terminations | Testimony | Acting Administrator | Documented (hearing print, S. Hrg. 119-130); the statements are the administration’s claims | E82; E71 |
| 2025-04-01 / 2025-04-09 | District court grants a preliminary injunction; the Fourth Circuit stays it pending appeal | Court orders | Courts | Documented | E40 |
| 2025-04-09 | The head of the Air Traffic Organization is reported to be retiring early as part of DOT’s second round of buyouts | Deferred resignation / early retirement | ATO Chief Operating Officer | Credibly reported (CBS, citing an FAA statement) | E37 |
| 2025-04-28 | The head of the commercial space office is reported to be leaving through a deferred resignation program | Deferred resignation | Associate Administrator, Commercial Space Transportation | Credibly reported (SpaceNews) | E38 |
| 2025-04-28 to 2025-06-06 | Philadelphia TRACON outages; interim and final orders capping Newark operations | Outage (context); operating order | FAA | Documented | E19 |
| 2025-05-14 | At a Senate Commerce hearing, three FAA deputies cannot give senators the number of their staff who took the buyout or were fired as probationers; asked whether they analysed the cuts’ effect on safety, the Office of Airports witness says “Yes. We have done an internal analysis”, the Air Traffic Organization witness says “No, sir. We have not done an internal analysis”, and the Aviation Safety witness says “we do not have final data” | Testimony | FAA deputy associate administrators; ATO deputy chief operating officer | Documented (hearing print, S. Hrg. 119-144) | E83 |
| 2025-05-15 | More than 2,700 FAA employees have signed up for DOT’s deferred resignation program; controllers and systems technicians are ineligible | Deferred resignation | DOT | Credibly reported (Government Executive) | E39 |
| 2025-04-25 | Rolling Stone, citing three unnamed sources, reports that DOGE staff directed FAA funds to a telecommunications project called “Project Lift” and had employees sign non-disclosure agreements; an FAA spokesperson says there are no DOGE employees at the FAA and that the project “was conceived and is managed by federal employees” | Reported direction (claim, denied) | n/a | Claimed (anonymous sources; FAA denial beside it) | E70 |
| 2025-05-30 | Aeronautical Information Services announces it will discontinue five charting products, final publication 2025-06-12; on 2025-08-13 it keeps the Chart Users’ Guide but takes it off the 56-day cycle. No reason is stated | Product discontinuation | FAA (AJV-A) | Documented (charting notices) | E62 |
| 2025-06-02 (week of) | FAA leadership revokes the SpaceX staff’s access to FAA buildings (including the Warrenton command center and the Oklahoma City academy) and their credentials and accounts on FAA internal systems; Glantz, Malaska, Kiernan and Smeal no longer carry the title “senior adviser to the administrator”. What they did with that access is not documented | Access revoked | FAA leadership | Credibly reported (records seen by the Washington Post; syndicated copy read) | E72 |
| 2025-06-11 | Bedford’s confirmation hearing; in written answers he says he “would review the analysis” FAA officials had promised the committee on the effects of the workforce cuts and deferred resignations on safety and, subject to factors he lists, is “committed to ensuring appropriate transparency” | Confirmation record | Nominee | Documented (hearing print, S. Hrg. 119-254) | E84 |
| 2025-07-04 | P.L. 119-21 appropriates $12.52 billion for air traffic control improvements, available to 2029-09-30, and rescinds $233.9 million of unobligated Inflation Reduction Act research balances | Statute | Congress | Documented | E44 |
| 2025-07-09 | Senate confirms Bedford, 53 to 43; the FAA lists him as Administrator from 2025-07-10 | Confirmation | Senate | Credibly reported (vote); Documented (FAA date) | E16; E64 |
| 2025-07-15 | Bedford writes lawmakers that the FAA is not aware of any SpaceX effort to assume the L3Harris or Verizon telecommunications contracts and has not considered replacing the awardees | Letter | Administrator | Credibly reported (Reuters, letter seen) | E53 |
| 2025-07-21 | Twelve senators write the Administrator that the analysis of the cuts’ effect on safety promised at the 2025-05-14 hearing has not been provided, and ask for the Office of Airports’ analysis | Congressional letter (request) | Senators | Documented (the letter); no reply found | E85 |
| 2025-09 | 1,158 FAA separations take effect in the month, the largest monthly total in the OPM record (deferred resignations ended on 2025-09-30); 36 of them on the executive pay plan | Deferred resignation | DOT / FAA | Documented (OPM, computed) | E36 |
| 2025-09-08 | Fourth Circuit vacates the Maryland injunction for lack of state standing, with directions to dismiss | Appellate ruling | Court | Documented | E40 |
| 2025-10-01 to 2025-11-12 | 43-day lapse in appropriations; controllers work unpaid | Appropriations lapse (congressional) | n/a | Documented (GAO, CRS) | E23 |
| 2025-11-06 to 2025-11-19 | Emergency order cutting airline flights at 40 airports from 2025-11-07 while controllers worked unpaid. The airline cuts ended 2025-11-17; a replacement order kept general-aviation limits until all measures were cancelled 2025-11-19 | Emergency orders | Secretary; Administrator | Documented | E21; E22; E65 |
| 2025-12-17 | GAO-26-107320: FAA lacks performance goals for controller recruiting, hiring and training | GAO report | GAO | Documented | E23 |
| 2025-12-31 | The Office of NextGen concludes its mission “pursuant to the FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024” | Statute (2024 Act) | n/a | Documented (FAA report) | E48 |
| 2026-01-26 | Reorganization announced: an agency-wide safety management office, an Airspace Modernization Office and finance, IT and HR consolidated under a Chief Administrative Officer; “will not result in reductions in force” | Reorganization | Secretary; Administrator | Documented | E47 |
| 2026-01-27 | NTSB board adopts 74 findings and 50 recommendations on the Potomac collision | NTSB finding (pre-existing conditions) | NTSB | Documented | E17; E18 |
| 2026-02-03 | FY2026 appropriations enacted (P.L. 119-75); FAA Operations $13,710M | Statute | Congress | Documented | E44; E45 |
| 2026-03-24 / 2026-06-24 | DOT OIG: contract-tower staffing shortages remain; FAA still faces on-the-job training challenges | IG reports | DOT OIG | Documented | E26; E59 |
| 2026-06-23 | Newark operating limits extended through 2027-10-30 as Area C staffing “will not increase significantly” | Operating order | FAA | Documented | E50 |
| 2026-07-30 | According to AeroCorner, the Deputy Administrator tells employees he is leaving for a private-sector post; by 2026-10-22 the FAA lists an acting Deputy | Departure | Deputy Administrator | Documented (vacancy, FAA page); date single-source | E35 |
| 2026-10-16 | FAA and the controllers’ union announce a 2.8 percent pay increase tied to scheduling and staffing reforms, effective 2026-10-18 and retroactive to the start of the year; payment is not documented | Pay agreement (announced) | Secretary; Administrator | Documented (announcement) | E49 |
| 2026-10-22 | FAA key officials: the commercial space, airspace modernization and chief administrative officer posts are vacant; the Deputy Administrator is acting | Vacancies | FAA | Documented | E35 |
| 2026-10-29 | The MSPB, on reopening, again denies a regulation-review request filed for terminated DOT probationers: the petitioner lacks standing because DOT rescinded the termination and paid back pay | Board order | MSPB | Documented | E66 |
| 2026-11-13 | Nationwide ground stop of 4 hours 23 minutes after a router on the contractor-owned FAA telecommunications network flooded it; root cause undetermined; the FAA says it was not a cyberattack and not related to the SMART tool | Outage (context) | FAA; contractor | Documented (FAA) | E51; E29 |
Personnel Ledger
Rules: methodology §8. The machine ledger (ada_personnel_ledger.json) does not exist yet, so the IDs below have no matching JSON rows. No motive is stated for any action; impact is labelled inferred unless an agency, court or IG states it. Departures through the deferred resignation program or early retirement are voluntary mechanisms and are not described as firings.
A. Separations and removals (named)
| Ledger ID | Name | Role | Grade band | Action type | Date | Source | Tier | Legal status | Functional impact (capability lost) | Capability tag and effect |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ADA-federal-aviation-administration-001 | Mike Whitaker | FAA Administrator (Tier-1; five-year statutory term) | political_appointee | resigned_other (announced 2024-12-12, before the administration took office; effective 2025-01-20) | 2025-01-20 | E52; E14; E15 | Documented | unchallenged | The post had no confirmed occupant for 170 days (2025-01-20 to confirmation on 2025-07-09, computed; the FAA lists Bedford from 2025-07-10). A 2025-01-30 presidential memo named Chris Rocheleau acting Administrator (E63). Effect inferred | agency_leadership, restored on confirmation 2025-07-09 |
| ADA-federal-aviation-administration-011 | Timothy L. Arel | Chief Operating Officer, Air Traffic Organization (Tier-1) | ses (four decades at the agency, per CBS) | early_retirement (through DOT’s second buyout round; “had planned to retire at the end of 2025”, the FAA told CBS) | announced 2025-04-09; gone by 2025-08-20 (FAA page) | E37; E35 | Credibly reported (mechanism); Documented (vacancy) | unchallenged | The ATO had an acting chief operating officer from at least 2025-08-20 to at least 2026-01-26 (at least 159 days, computed); a permanent COO is listed by 2026-04-14. Effect inferred | public_service_delivery, restored |
| ADA-federal-aviation-administration-012 | Kelvin B. Coleman | Associate Administrator, Commercial Space Transportation (Tier-1) | ses | deferred_resignation | reported 2025-04-28; post vacant by 2025-08-20 | E38; E35 | Credibly reported (mechanism); Documented (vacancy) | unchallenged | The commercial space office has had no Associate Administrator for at least 428 days on the FAA’s own page (2025-08-20 to 2026-10-22, computed), 454 days if still vacant at the cutoff. Licensing output rose to a record in FY2025 (E42), so no function loss is shown. Effect inferred | regulatory_review, at_risk (inferred) |
| ADA-federal-aviation-administration-013 | Chris Rocheleau | Deputy Administrator (Tier-1); acting Administrator 2025-01 to 2025-07 | senior (appointment type not documented) | resigned_other (left for a private-sector post, according to AeroCorner) | 2026-07-30 (single source); acting Deputy listed by 2026-10-22 | E35 | Documented (vacancy); date single-source | unchallenged | Deputy post held by an acting official for about 110 days at the cutoff (computed from the reported date). Effect inferred | agency_leadership, at_risk (inferred) |
Context, not ledger rows: Bryan Bedford (bryan-bedford-profile) was confirmed on 2025-07-09; the FAA lists him as Administrator from 2025-07-10 (E16, E64). Secretary Sean Duffy (Sean Duffy – Secretary of Transportation) is the department head, not an FAA Tier-1 position. The other Tier-1 changes (Aviation Safety, Airports, Security and Hazardous Materials Safety, Chief Counsel, Finance and Management, NextGen) are tabulated in D2 from the FAA’s own page; their departure mechanisms are not documented, so they are not ledger rows.
B. Aggregate counts (unnamed)
OPM’s separations file records personnel actions by effective month and OPM’s own category, January 2025 to September 2026, for unit TD:TD03 (E1). “Termination (expired appointment or other)” mixes expired appointments with probationary and for-cause terminations and must not be read as “fired”. The deferred-resignation flag is OPM’s drp_indicator field. Gross is not net. Occupational-series stocks also move when staff are reassigned between series, so a stock change is not a count of separations. Cells under 10 are reported as “fewer than 10”.
| Ledger ID | Unit | Grade band | Occupational series | Mechanism | Count | Period | Gross or net | Source | Tier |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ADA-federal-aviation-administration-002 | FAA, agency-wide | probationary | Not split; the union names aviation safety assistants, maintenance mechanics and aeronautical information specialists among them | Probationary termination | 352 (Secretary Duffy, 2025-02-24); “fewer than 400”. Union counts are subsets: PASS’s 132 to 133 members, and at least 45 members of AFSCME Local 1653, a different bargaining unit, by its president’s sworn declaration (E87) | 2025-02-14 (notices emailed between midnight and 2:00 a.m. on 2025-02-15, E87) | Gross. Legal status and reversal, from DOT’s sworn declarations: the District of Maryland’s TRO of 2025-03-13 ordered reinstatement at defendant agencies including DOT (E40). DOT’s Assistant Secretary for Administration and Chief Human Capital Officer, Anne Byrd (in that post since 2025-02-25), filed two declarations in the case. The first (ECF 52-1, dated 2025-03-17) states that DOT terminated about 788 probationary employees between 2025-02-14 and 2025-02-24; that 775 of them were “Affected Probationary Employees” under the TRO, all told on 2025-03-17 that their terminations were rescinded, with back pay from 2025-02-15 and a return to active duty on 2025-03-20; and that the other 13 were two performance-based terminations, eight rescinded before the TRO, two resignations and one deferred resignation (E80). The second (ECF 103-1, filed 2025-03-25) states that all 775 were returned to duty on 2025-03-20 and that as of 2025-03-24, 92 had resigned and 683 were on duty or on voluntary leave (E81). “All 775” is therefore all but 13 of about 788, and every figure is DOT-wide: neither declaration splits out FAA. The FAA returned the 132 PASS-represented employees to duty on 2025-03-20 with back pay (E9). The Fourth Circuit stayed the later injunction on 2025-04-09 and on 2025-09-08 vacated it with directions to dismiss for lack of state standing (E40). Later disposition: on 2026-10-29 the MSPB, reciting DOT’s declaration, denied a regulation-review request concerning DOT’s terminations because DOT had rescinded them and paid back pay (E66). No re-firing was found (unverified absence). The FAA’s share of the 788, the 775 and the 92 is not in any DOT filing read, so nothing is netted at the FAA level (Rule 6-a) | E5; E6; E7; E8; E9; E40; E80; E81; E66; E87 | Claimed (the 352: the Secretary’s own figure, not an agency record); Credibly reported (PASS’s subset); Documented (AFSCME Local 1653’s count of at least 45, a union count in a sworn declaration; DOT-wide counts, sworn declarations) |
| ADA-federal-aviation-administration-003 | FAA (OPM TD:TD03) | All appointment types | All | Deferred resignation (OPM flag, any separation category) | 2,017. Beside it, according to Politico (one anonymous source, DOT data as of 2025-07-07), 2,080 FAA employees, 4.5 percent of 46,288, accepted deferred resignation, with separation in September 2025 (E74). The OPM flag stays the Documented count; Politico’s figure counts acceptances, not separations | 2025-01 to 2026-09 | Gross, voluntary | E1; E36; E74 | Documented (OPM flag); Credibly reported (Politico figure) |
| ADA-federal-aviation-administration-004 | FAA (OPM TD:TD03) | All appointment types | All | Retirement: voluntary 2,701; other 146; early-out 6 (merged, cell under 10) | 2,853 | 2025-01 to 2026-09 | Gross, voluntary or ordinary | E1 | Documented |
| ADA-federal-aviation-administration-005 | FAA (OPM TD:TD03) | All appointment types | All | Quits other than deferred resignation | 1,502 | 2025-01 to 2026-09 | Gross, voluntary | E1 | Documented |
| ADA-federal-aviation-administration-006 | FAA (OPM TD:TD03) | All appointment types | All | Termination, expired appointment or other (961 of them in air traffic control, where Academy and training failures fall) | 1,238 | 2025-01 to 2026-09 | Gross, mixed | E1; E36 | Documented |
| ADA-federal-aviation-administration-007 | FAA (OPM TD:TD03) | All appointment types | All | Other separations 428; transfers out 159. No separation coded as a reduction in force | 587 | 2025-01 to 2026-09 | Gross | E1 | Documented |
| ADA-federal-aviation-administration-008 | FAA (OPM TD:TD03) | All appointment types | All | Accessions (hires and transfers in) | 6,471 | 2025-01 to 2026-09 | Gross | E1 | Documented |
| ADA-federal-aviation-administration-009 | FAA air traffic controllers | career_staff | 2152 Air traffic control | Stock | 18,730 to 19,772 (plus 1,042, plus 5.6 percent); 2,770 separations (fewer than 10 flagged deferred resignation) against 3,950 accessions | 2024-12 to 2026-09 | Net (stock) | E36 | Documented (computed) |
| ADA-federal-aviation-administration-010 | Philadelphia TRACON Area C (Newark traffic) | career_staff | Air traffic control | Certified controllers on board after the April 2025 outages | 22 certified controllers and 5 certified supervisors, with 22 in training (June 2025) | 2025-06 | Stock | E19 | Documented (FAA statement) |
| ADA-federal-aviation-administration-014 | FAA aviation safety and engineering | career_staff | 1825 Aviation safety; 0800-series engineering (excluding 0802 technicians) | Stock | 1825: 4,238 to 4,156 (minus 1.9 percent; 748 separations, 10 flagged deferred resignation, 676 accessions). Engineering: 3,847 to 3,385 (minus 462, minus 12.0 percent) | 2024-12 to 2026-09 | Net (stock) | E36 | Documented (computed) |
| ADA-federal-aviation-administration-015 | FAA transportation specialists (systems technicians and related) | career_staff | 2101 Transportation specialist | Stock | 5,528 to 5,861 (plus 333, plus 6.0 percent). The FAA’s own systems-specialist (ATSS) workforce plan of 2026-05-15 states that “No ATSSs were terminated as probationary employees, and ATSSs were not eligible for the Deferred Resignation Program” (E73), so neither mechanism reduced the ATSS part of the series; the plan does not say the same of the series’ other occupations | 2024-12 to 2026-09 | Net (stock) | E36; E73 | Documented (computed); Documented (FAA plan) |
| ADA-federal-aviation-administration-016 | FAA aeronautical information | career_staff | 1361 Navigational information | Stock; separations mostly deferred resignation | 464 to 363 (minus 101, minus 21.8 percent); 107 separations, 71 flagged deferred resignation; fewer than 10 accessions | 2024-12 to 2026-09 | Net (stock) | E36 | Documented (computed) |
| ADA-federal-aviation-administration-017 | FAA support, management and legal staff | career_staff | 0343 management and program analysis (2,313 to 1,720, minus 25.6 percent); 0301 miscellaneous administration (1,215 to 823, minus 32.3 percent); 2210 IT management (1,487 to 1,169, minus 21.4 percent); 0340 program management (816 to 639, minus 21.7 percent); 0905 attorneys (243 to 169, minus 30.5 percent) | Stock; deferred resignation the largest single mechanism in 0343, 0301 and 0905 | All series outside air traffic control, 2101, 1825 and engineering: 14,118 to 11,375 (minus 2,743, minus 19.4 percent) | 2024-12 to 2026-09 | Net (stock) | E36 | Documented (computed) |
| ADA-federal-aviation-administration-018 | FAA executives | ses (FAA Executive Compensation Plan, pay plan EV) | All | Stock and flows | 195 to 138 (minus 57, minus 29.2 percent); 83 separations, 45 of them flagged deferred resignation (voluntary retirement 51, early-out retirement 21, other mechanisms 11); fewer than 10 accessions | 2024-12 to 2026-09 | Net (stock); gross (flows) | E36; E34 | Documented (computed) |
C. Conduct findings
None located. No named person has a finding, adjudicated or appealed status on an official record. The Maryland orders (E40) ran against agencies, not individuals. A senators’ letter alleging that a senior official had not divested airline shares as an ethics agreement required is a complaint, not a finding; it is recorded by role in Research Leads (E55).
D. Ledger roll-up
| Measure | Value | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Gross separations by mechanism | OPM, 2025-01 to 2026-09: 8,197 in all. Flagged deferred resignation 2,017 (24.6 percent, computed); retirements 2,853; other quits 1,502; expired appointment or other termination 1,238; other separations and transfers out 587; reductions in force 0. Accessions 6,471 | Gross, not net. Voluntary mechanisms are reported as such and never as firings (§12 item 3). OPM’s SES flag reads 0 for this unit because it keys on the position-occupied field, which is “excepted service” on every FAA row; executives were counted instead from pay plan EV in the raw files (E36, IT-4055) |
| Net change versus baseline | OPM headcount (people): 46,461 (December 2024) to 44,549 (September 2026), minus 1,912 or 4.1 percent. Core mission series (2152, 2101, 1825, engineering) 32,343 to 33,174, plus 2.6 percent; all other series 14,118 to 11,375, minus 19.4 percent | Primary record (E1, E36). Accessions minus separations (minus 1,726) does not equal the headcount change, as OPM’s caveats expect |
| Tier-1 positions vacant or acting over 180 days, at the cutoff | 1 of 10 (Commercial Space Transportation). Over the period, 3 of 10 were established at over 180 days (Commercial Space; Security and Hazardous Materials Safety; Finance and Management); two of those were filled by the cutoff | Feeds D2 (net of reversal, Rule 6-a) |
| Non-ordinary Tier-1 exits | 0 established. Two Tier-1 holders left through voluntary buyout programs (rows 011, 012); no removal, forced resignation or protest resignation is documented | Feeds D2 |
| Probationary firings and reversal | 352 fired at FAA (Secretary’s figure, Claimed); 132 PASS-represented employees returned 2025-03-20 (E9). DOT-wide, about 788 terminated 2025-02-14 to 2025-02-24; the 775 covered by the TRO rescinded 2025-03-17 and returned 2025-03-20; 92 of them had resigned by 2025-03-24 (Byrd declarations, E80, E81) | Rule 6-a: the reversal is established at the DOT level only; nothing is netted for FAA until the FAA share of the 788, the 775 and the 92 is on the record |
| Capabilities lost or degraded | Aeronautical information (F3): degraded, four charting products discontinued in 2025 (E62) and staff down 21.8 percent (row 016). Commercial space leadership: at risk, inferred (row 012) | Feeds D3 |
Damage Assessment
| Dimension | Weight | Score | Confidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| D1 Workforce and expertise | 17 | 1 | Medium |
| D2 Leadership and politicization | 11 | 2 | Medium |
| D3 Mission and statutory function | 17 | 1 | Low |
| D4 Independence and legal authority | 13 | 1 | Medium |
| D5 Data and information integrity | 10 | unscored | |
| D6 Funding, grants and contracts | 14 | 0 | Medium |
| D7 Public-facing service | 10 | unscored | |
| D8 Legal compliance | 8 | 1 | Medium |
| Damage index (0 to 100) | 100 | 24, Strained | Medium (coverage 80 percent) |
| D9 Recoverability (second axis) | not weighted | 1 (H1) | Low |
Composite arithmetic (§7): the sum of weight times score over the six scored dimensions is 17 + 22 + 17 + 13 + 0 + 8 = 77; 77 / 4 = 19.25; over the scored weight of 80, 19.25 / 80 × 100 = 24.06, rounded 24, Strained. Coverage 80 / 100 = 80 percent. Confidence Medium (Rule 5: at least 70 percent of weight scored, no dimension at 3 or 4, cutoff within 180 days; High needs 90 percent coverage).
Each subsection states the baseline, the evidence with its tier, the score against the anchors in methodology §6, the administration’s stated rationale and any documented improvement.
D1 — Workforce and expertise capacity
Score: 1. Confidence: Medium. Baseline: OPM headcount of 46,461 people in the December 2024 snapshot (E1). The trailing five-year separation rate (Rule 2) is not available: the OPM files used begin in December 2024. Evidence:
- Net (Documented, E1): 46,461 (2024-12), 46,366 (2025-01), 46,108 (2025-06), 46,251 (2025-09), 44,856 (2025-12), 44,410 (2026-03), 44,564 (2026-08), 44,549 (2026-09). Net minus 1,912 people, minus 4.1 percent: inside anchor 0’s ±5 percent band. The largest step, September to December 2025, follows 1,158 separations effective in September 2025 when deferred resignations ended (E36).
- Gross by mechanism (Ledger B): 8,197 separations, 2,017 of them flagged deferred resignation and 2,853 retirements; none coded as a reduction in force. The February 2025 probationary terminations (352 by the Secretary’s count, E6) are not separable in OPM’s mixed “termination” category; at least 132 were reinstated in March 2025 (E9). DOT’s sworn declarations state that it terminated about 788 probationers department-wide between 2025-02-14 and 2025-02-24, rescinded the 775 terminations covered by the Maryland TRO on 2025-03-17, and that 92 of those 775 had resigned by 2025-03-24 (E80, E81; recited by the MSPB, E66). Neither declaration gives an FAA figure, so nothing is netted for FAA (Rule 6-a).
- Mission-critical occupations (Documented, computed from the OPM raw files, E36). Congress requires workforce plans for controllers, aviation safety inspectors and engineers (E60), so those are treated as mission-critical, with the 2101 systems specialists. Air traffic control (2152) rose 5.6 percent; transportation specialists (2101) rose 6.0 percent; aviation safety (1825) fell 1.9 percent; engineering fell 12.0 percent (aerospace 6.5, general 8.6, electronics 13.2). No mission-critical series fell 25 percent, so anchor 2’s occupational test is not met. The FAA’s own systems-specialist workforce plan (2026-05-15) states that no ATSS was terminated as a probationary employee and that ATSSs were not eligible for deferred resignation (Documented, E73), which supports reading the 2101 rise as untouched by either mechanism for those staff. The same plan reports pre-existing strain it does not attribute to any 2025 action: shifts unstaffed at 67 facilities, an average of 115 overtime hours per ATSS in FY2025, and about 2,400 hires planned through FY2030 (E73).
- Targeted losses outside the core (Documented, computed, E36): all other series fell 19.4 percent; management and program analysis 25.6 percent, miscellaneous administration 32.3 percent, attorneys 30.5 percent, IT management 21.4 percent, program management 21.7 percent. The executive pay plan (EV) fell from 195 to 138, minus 29.2 percent, with 83 separations of which 45 were flagged deferred resignation (E36). This is the senior-career loss the D1 metrics name. Almost all of these departures are retirements, quits or deferred resignations, voluntary mechanisms reported as such (Rule D1-b).
- Controllers, by the FAA’s own definition (Documented, E41): facility on-board 13,774 (September 2024) to 14,223 (end FY2025); certified professional controllers about flat (10,730 to 10,693); FY2025 hires 2,028 against losses of 1,460. GAO’s count for the same definition, 13,164 at end FY2025, about 6 percent below FY2015, is not reconciled with the FAA’s (E23).
Reading: net change is inside anchor 0, the core safety series grew or held, and the loss is concentrated in support, management, legal and executive ranks. Anchor 1 (“targeted loss confined to one non-core unit”) is the nearest level: the loss is spread over several non-core series rather than one unit, but none of it reaches a mission-critical series. Scored 1. The aeronautical-information loss (series 1361, minus 21.8 percent) is scored under D3, its primary dimension (Rule 4), and is not used here. Stated rationale / improvements: see Basis for Inclusion (Secretary Duffy, E5, E6, E39; the acting Administrator, E10, E39). The controller hiring campaign (record 2,235 trainees in FY2026, E58), the retention bonus for retirement-eligible controllers (E41), the reinstatement of the PASS-represented probationers (E9) and DOT’s department-wide rescission of the 775 terminations covered by the Maryland order (E80, E81) are documented improvements or reversals. Evidence still needed: the trailing separation rate (OPM files before December 2024, or FedScope); the FAA-only split of DOT’s 788 terminations and 775 rescissions (returned to duty, on voluntary leave, resigned); the 92 resignations are DOT-wide. The Maryland docket does not hold the split (E80, E81, and the 2025-04-08 compliance report, which has no DOT declaration, E93): ask DOT or FAA for the personnel-action list, look for DOT’s 2025-04-01 letter to Sen. Markey (cited in E85, not retrieved), or look in an MSPB or OSC record. Also the FAA’s own analysis of the cuts’ effect on safety: the Office of Airports told senators on 2025-05-14 that it had one and the Air Traffic Organization that it had not (E83), and none had been provided by 2025-07-21 (E85).
D2 — Leadership decapitation and politicization
Score: 2 (see Reading). Confidence: Medium. Baseline: the 10-position Tier-1 list in Agency at a Glance, as the FAA’s key-officials page showed it on 2024-12-20 (E35). The historical non-ordinary-exit rate was not collected. Evidence (Documented, FAA key-officials page, captures by “last updated” date, E35):
| Tier-1 post | 2024-12-20 | 2025-03-19 | 2025-08-20 | 2026-01-26 | 2026-04-14 | 2026-06-23 | 2026-10-22 | Vacant or acting over 180 days? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Administrator | Whitaker | Rocheleau (acting) | Bedford | Bedford | Bedford | Bedford | Bedford | No: 170 days, filled |
| Deputy Administrator | Thomson | McKenna (acting) | Rocheleau | Rocheleau | Rocheleau | Rocheleau | McKenna (acting) | Not established: about 110 days at the cutoff |
| COO, Air Traffic Organization | Arel | Arel | McIntosh (acting) | McIntosh (acting) | McIntosh | McIntosh | McIntosh | At least 159 days during the period; filled by 2026-04-14 |
| Aviation Safety | Boulter | Baker (acting) | Amereihn (acting) | Amereihn | Amereihn | Locke | Locke | At least 154 days during the period; filled by 2026-01-26 |
| Airports | Griffin | Vacant | Vacant | Edwards | Edwards | Edwards | Kelly (listed as non-career) | At least 154 days during the period; filled by 2026-01-26 |
| Commercial Space Transportation | Coleman | Coleman | Vacant | Vacant | Vacant | Vacant | Vacant | Yes: at least 428 days documented (to 2026-10-22) |
| Security and Hazardous Materials Safety | Sikorskyj | Supko (acting) | Supko (acting) | Supko (acting) | Supko (acting) | Supko | Supko | Yes during the period (at least 391 days); filled by 2026-06-23 |
| Chief Counsel | Peter (acting) | McKenna | McKenna | McKenna | McKenna | McKenna | DeVore (listed as non-career) | No (acting at baseline, filled by 2025-03-19) |
| Finance and Management (CFO) | House | Tash (acting) | Torpey (acting) | Torpey (acting) | Vacant | Vacant | Merged into the Administration and Finance Office; its Chief Administrative Officer post vacant | Yes during the period (at least 461 days to 2026-06-23); a Chief Administrative Officer sat over the function from at least 2026-01-26 to 2026-06-23; that post is vacant at the cutoff for under 180 days |
| NextGen | Fontaine | Fontaine | Fontaine | Fontaine | Fontaine | Fontaine | Office ended by statute 2025-12-31 (E48); successor Airspace Modernization post vacant | Not established |
- Vacancy spells across the period (scored, per Peter’s ruling of 2026-11-17): 3 of 10 posts were established at over 180 days vacant or acting (Commercial Space Transportation, at least 428 days; Security and Hazardous Materials Safety, at least 391 days; Finance and Management, at least 461 days), 30 percent. Three more (Air Traffic Organization, Aviation Safety, Airports) had acting or vacant spells of at least 154 to 159 days whose start or end dates fall between captures; if two of them exceeded 180 days the share would reach 50 percent (anchor 3).
- At the cutoff (recorded): 1 of 10 is established as vacant over 180 days (Commercial Space Transportation). Three more are vacant or acting for periods not established at 180 days (Deputy, the Chief Administrative Officer successor to Finance and Management, the Airspace Modernization successor to NextGen). Security and Finance-function spells were closed by the cutoff or, for finance, covered for part of 2026 by a Chief Administrative Officer.
- Non-ordinary exits: none documented. The ATO and commercial space heads left through DOT’s voluntary buyout programs (E37, E38). Whitaker’s departure was announced on 2024-12-12, before the administration took office (E52); a syndicated headline attributing it to pressure from the DOGE leader is single-source and stays in Research Leads.
- Politicization: the October 2026 page lists the Airports Associate Administrator and the Chief Counsel under “Non-Career Leadership” (E35). Whether the Airports post was career-held at baseline is not documented here (the 2024 page does not mark appointment type), so no career-to-political conversion is established.
- The Office of NextGen ended on 2025-12-31 “pursuant to the FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024” (E48): valid legislation enacted before the administration, so the post’s end is not damage.
Reading: Peter ruled on 2026-11-17 that D2 counts vacancy spells across the period, not the state at the cutoff (recorded as decision D8 in docs/faa-series-2026-11/README.md). On that reading 30 percent of Tier-1 posts had a vacant or acting spell over 180 days, which meets anchor 2 (“25% or more … vacant/acting over 180 days”) on a Documented fact (the FAA’s own page, E35). No non-ordinary exit and no removal of a statutorily protected official is documented, so anchor 3 is not reached. Read at the cutoff instead, 1 of 10 would score 1; that reading is recorded, not scored. Stated rationale / improvements: none located for the vacancies. The Senate-confirmed Administrator (confirmed 2025-07-09; the FAA lists him from 2025-07-10), and permanent heads named for the Air Traffic Organization, Aviation Safety, Airports and Security by mid-2026, are restorations (E16, E35). Evidence still needed: exact start and end dates for the acting spells (FAA announcements, Federal Register delegations); appointment type of each Tier-1 holder at baseline; when the Chief Administrative Officer and Airspace Modernization posts fell vacant.
D3 — Mission and statutory-function delivery
Score: 1. Confidence: Low. Baseline: the function table F1 to F5 with the FY2024 measures it lists. Evidence:
- F1 air traffic control (Documented): controller on-board count and hiring up (E41, E58); the Newark cap (E19, E50) and the New York-area staffing relief (E50) rest on staffing shortfalls the FAA dates to before 2025. The NTSB’s Potomac findings describe failures of route design and safety management that predate 2025, and the report contains no finding, cause or recommendation about hiring policy; it found the Reagan National tower below its target staffing but with adequate staff on duty that night, and the combined positions “not the result of insufficient staffing” (E18). These are pre-existing conditions and are not credited.
- F2 safety oversight (Documented): inspector series down 1.9 percent (E36); emergency airworthiness directives grounding the MD-11 fleet were issued within four days of the 2025-11-04 Louisville crash of UPS flight 2976, which caused 14 fatal injuries under the NTSB’s 30-day definition (one more person died 51 days later) (research record). Enforcement capacity is about level.
- F3 air navigation facilities and aeronautical information (Documented output fact; cause not stated): Aeronautical Information Services’ charting notice of 2025-05-30 discontinued five products with a final publication date of 2025-06-12: the Aeronautical Chart Users’ Guide, VFR Class B Enhancement Graphics, the U.S. and Alaska VFR Wall Planning charts and the U.S. IFR/VFR Low Altitude Planning Charts. A second notice of 2025-08-13 kept the Users’ Guide but took it off the regular 56-day charting schedule, with revisions “on an as-needed basis” (E62). Neither notice states a reason. Over the same period the navigational information series that prepares charts, procedures and flight paths fell from 464 to 363 (minus 21.8 percent), with 71 of 107 departures flagged deferred resignation and fewer than 10 hires (E36). The core products (sectional, en route and terminal procedure charts) and their cycle timeliness were not measured; no missed cycle was found. The 2026-11-13 ground stop disrupted the network F3 maintains, but its root cause is undetermined and no record ties it to a 2025 action (E51); it is context.
- F3, mechanism of the staff loss (Documented; does not change the score): DOT OIG reports that the FAA introduced Public Safety and Mission Support position categories in 2025 “to identify positions that would be exempt from the Deferred Resignation Program”, and that the FAA has no uniform agency-wide definition of “safety-critical” (AV2026035, E60). The navigational information series was not among the exempt positions: 71 of its 107 departures were flagged deferred resignation (E36). Aeronautical information specialists were among the PASS-represented probationers fired in February 2025 (E8), but those terminations were reversed (E9; DOT-wide, E80, E81), so the 1361 decline traces to deferred resignation and low hiring, not to the February firings. No document states a reason for the 2025 chart discontinuations (E62).
- F4 airport grants and F5 commercial space (Documented): funding and output at or above baseline (E42, E43, E44).
- No missed statutory deadline was found; DOT OIG reports the FAA completed the workforce plans mandated by law (E60).
Reading: anchor 1 is “a function degraded with no missed statutory deadline”. Rule 6-d asks for evidence, not inference: the score rests on a Documented output fact, the 2025 discontinuation of four charting products and the move of a fifth off the 56-day cycle (E62), set beside the documented 21.8 percent fall in the staff who produce them (E36). That is a degraded aeronautical-information function with no missed deadline: anchor 1. What remains inferred is the cause (the notices give none, and a product rationalization would not be damage under §1) and the size of the effect on the core charts, hence Low confidence. If the discontinuations are read as rationalization rather than degradation, F3 has no output measure, anchor 0 cannot be affirmed either, and D3 is unscored under Rule 6-d; coverage then falls to 63 percent and no composite may be published. Primary dimension for the series 1361 loss (Rule 4); it is not counted in D1. Stated rationale / improvements: the Brand New Air Traffic Control System, $12.52 billion in P.L. 119-21, with 70 percent of copper telecommunications lines replaced by the FAA’s count (E44, E46, E51); the unified safety management office created in 2026 (E47). Evidence still needed: the reason for the 2025 product discontinuations; core chart and procedure cycle timeliness (Aeronautical Information Services) for FY2024 and FY2026; certification backlog; inspections performed; the root-cause analysis of the 2026-11-13 ground stop.
D4 — Independence and legal-authority erosion
Score: 1 (higher of the two sub-scores). Confidence: Medium. Baseline: the statutory chain on 2025-01-19: an Administrator with a five-year term inside DOT (49 U.S.C. § 106, not re-verified). The FAA is not an independent agency; direction by the Secretary or the President is inside its chain. De facto interference (sub-score 1): a DOGE team and SpaceX engineers serving as special government employees arrived at FAA in February 2025, brought in by the Secretary’s own account (Credibly reported, E10, E12, E54). The sequence: probationary termination notices went out late on 2025-02-14 and in the early hours of 2025-02-15 (E87); the Secretary announced the SpaceX visit late on Sunday 2025-02-16; the team visited the Air Traffic Control System Command Center in Warrenton, Virginia, on Monday 2025-02-17, the date Reuters gives, confirmed by Politico, CNBC and Axios (Credibly reported, E86, E5); the waivers below are dated the same day. The dated record of their presence:
- Appointment (Documented, E67). DOT’s Designated Agency Ethics Official signed 18 U.S.C. § 208(b)(1) conflict-of-interest waivers dated 2025-02-17 for Glantz, Malaska and Kiernan, each a SpaceX engineer appointed as an unpaid special government employee for four days, reporting to the acting Administrator, to “conduct a review of FAA technology including … air traffic control systems”, and “expected to access confidential information regarding the FAA’s Air Traffic Control systems and other systems”. The waivers bar decisions on federal funding or contracts for SpaceX and access to the commercial space office’s systems. DOT did not formally consult the Office of Government Ethics, citing “the exigency”; it notified OGE staff. A continuation dated 2025-02-21 kept Malaska on “for the duration of your temporary appointment” because the FAA “has identified a plan to address improvements in its air traffic control systems”; no continuation for Glantz or Kiernan is in the record, and Politico, reading the waivers from DOT’s ethics office, reported only Malaska’s extension (E92). Smeal, the fourth SpaceX engineer named by Wired, ProPublica and the Washington Post, has no waiver in the record; that he was named is Credibly reported, and whether he served as a special government employee is not documented (E68, E11, E72).
- Titles and access (Credibly reported). The four, Glantz, Malaska, Kiernan and Smeal, held FAA email addresses and the title “senior adviser to the administrator” (E11, E68, E72). In the week of 2025-06-02 FAA leadership revoked their building access and their credentials and accounts on FAA internal systems, according to records seen by the Washington Post (E72). How their service ran past four days is not reconciled in the record, and what they did with the access is not documented.
- The administration’s account under testimony (Documented record; Claimed content). At the Senate Aviation Subcommittee hearing of 2025-03-27, the acting Administrator answered Sen. Markey: “We had three special government employees from SpaceX. We are only in contact with one at this point. I would make it very clear they did not do any air traffic – they did not plug into any of the equipment. They came in to observe our operations and provided expertise along the lines of software and computer systems.” On Starlink: “There were no DOGE employees in that decision. Starlink is being tested at a number of our facilities, only tested and not plugged into any air traffic systems.” Asked whether any of them was involved in deploying more terminals: “No, sir.” (S. Hrg. 119-130, E82; reported the same day by Reuters, E71.) Discrepancy: his “three” matches the three waiver holders, while Wired, ProPublica and the Washington Post name four people who held FAA titles until about 2025-06-02; Smeal’s status is unknown, and “only in contact with one” in March sits against the Post’s account that all four held titles and accounts into June (E72).
- Starlink (Credibly reported). The FAA posted on 2025-02-24 that it was testing one Starlink terminal at Atlantic City and two at non-safety-critical sites in Alaska (as reported by CNN, snippet, E78). According to Bloomberg, citing two unnamed sources, Theodore Malaska arrived at FAA headquarters with a directive from the DOGE leader to start deploying thousands of Starlink terminals (E69; single outlet, a claim). The acting Administrator’s 2025-03-27 testimony above denies DOGE involvement in the decision (E82).
- “Project Lift” (Claimed). According to Rolling Stone (2025-04-25, three unnamed sources), DOGE staff directed FAA funds to a telecommunications project called “Project Lift” and employees were made to sign non-disclosure agreements. An FAA spokesperson said “DOGE is not spearheading anything at the FAA, nor are there any DOGE employees at FAA”, that the project “was conceived and is managed by federal employees”, and that employees routinely sign such agreements (E70).
FAA licenses SpaceX launches, the conflict senators raised in 2025 (E31, E75, E76). The DOGE leader publicly called the Verizon telecommunications system a risk to travelers (his post as quoted in a senators’ letter, Credibly reported, E31). The Administrator’s letter of 2025-07-15 says the FAA has not considered replacing the awardees with SpaceX and would not use satellite service as the sole communications for safety-critical services (E53). No decision directed by DOGE or SpaceX personnel is documented: the Starlink directive and Project Lift rest on anonymous sources and are denied by the FAA, and the waivers bar SpaceX funding and contract decisions. This is documented presence and pressure without a documented act: anchor 1. If either anonymous-sourced claim were documented, this reading would need review. De jure change (sub-score 0): none found. The January 2026 reorganization changed structure, not legal authority (E47). Stated rationale / improvements: the acting Administrator’s email describes the DOGE teams as there to “keep the airspace open and safe” (E10); the waivers describe “the review required by the President” (E67). The acting Administrator’s 2025-03-27 testimony and the FAA spokesperson’s 2025-04-25 denial are above (E82, E71, E70). SpaceX said it supplied Starlink kits free (research record). FAA leadership ended the SpaceX staff’s access in June 2025 (E72). Evidence still needed: the presence and dates are now on the record (above); still missing is what the special government employees accessed or did on FAA systems. No FOIA production on it has been found: the FAA’s Electronic Reading Room (archived copy of 2026-11-13) lists no item on DOGE, Starlink, special government employees or the 2025 probationary terminations, and DOT’s FOIA library could not be retrieved (E91); American Oversight sued DOT and more than 20 other agencies on 2025-07-16 for DOGE-team records, with no production reported (E89). Correction: an earlier version of this section named “the POGO and CREW FOIA dockets” as FAA leads. No FAA-specific FOIA suit by either group was located: the Project on Government Oversight’s suit against the President and the U.S. DOGE Service (D.D.C. 1:25-cv-00527-JEB, filed 2025-02-21) concerns DOGE’s own records, not FAA’s (E88), and the CREW DOGE suits found name other agencies, not DOT or FAA (E90). Also missing: Smeal’s waiver or appointment record, and the authority for any of the four serving beyond four days; and any IG or GAO review of the Starlink arrangement (a request to the IG is on file, E77; no response found).
D5 — Data, information and statistical integrity
Score: unscored (null). Confidence: none. Baseline: FAA’s aeronautical information products, safety datasets and published statistics as they stood on 2025-01-19 (not inventoried). Evidence: one search found no report of FAA datasets or pages removed or altered. Several statutory and flagship products continued (controller and safety workforce plans, E41, E60; the commercial space forecast, E42), but that is not an inventory. Under Rule 6-d a search that found nothing is null, not 0. The aeronautical-information staffing loss is scored under D3. Anchor a future score tests: anchor 0 needs a dated inventory showing each series and page live; anchor 1, isolated pages or datasets removed and restored. Evidence still needed: a dated inventory of FAA data products (charts, NOTAM system, accident and incident data, Air Traffic by the Numbers, runway incursion data) against 2025-01-19.
D6 — Funding, grants and contracts
Score: 0. Confidence: Medium. Baseline: FY2024 enacted appropriation, $20,083.3 million across the four annual accounts and the AIP general-fund supplement (E44). Evidence (Documented):
- Enacted, same basis (E44, computed): FY2025 $20,989.0 million (plus 4.5 percent, full-year continuing resolution); FY2026 $22,208.7 million excluding an IIJA transfer (plus 10.6 percent, P.L. 119-75). Operations rose from $12,729.6 million to $13,710 million. P.L. 119-21 added $12.52 billion for air traffic control improvements in FY2025, available to 2029-09-30; the FAA’s FY2025 financial report puts FY2025 enacted funding at $38.5 billion, up 53.5 percent (E43).
- Apportionment (E33): budget authority up 8.8 percent like-for-like FY2024 to FY2026; the hold-type footnotes are spend-plan conditions, not withholding by themselves.
- Withheld, terminated or cancelled: none found that remains at the cutoff. The $2.4 billion Verizon contract was not cancelled (E53). A 3.8 percent controller raise enacted in April 2026 was paid in part until the FAA found the efficiency improvements the statute required; according to CBS, 2.8 points were held pending that finding (E49), and the FAA announced the 2.8 percent increase on 2026-10-16, retroactive to the start of the year (E49). Announced 2026-10-16; payment is not documented, so under Rule 6-a the release has not yet happened. Either way the conditioned amount (part of a $140 million set-aside) is under 1 percent of funds and the condition was statutory, so the score is unaffected.
- Not counted: the $233.9 million rescission of Inflation Reduction Act research balances was enacted by Congress (P.L. 119-21), a valid-legislation outcome; the FY2026 request’s 41 percent cut to research, engineering and development was a plan Congress did not enact (Rule 6-b’s logic for plans). Slow obligation of the $12.52 billion (about $1.8 billion of about $9.0 billion of Phase 1 programs obligated by March 2026, GAO) is pace, not withholding (E46).
Reading: the share of programmatic funds withheld, terminated or cancelled is under 5 percent on primary records showing funding at or above baseline: anchor 0, on affirmative evidence (Rule 6-d). Stated rationale / improvements: Congress provided the $12.52 billion, which the Administrator called “a strong $12.5 billion down payment” (FAA release 2025-12-04, research record); the Administrator and the Secretary have put the further need at $20 billion to $50 billion at different times (research record). Evidence still needed: account-level obligations FY2024 to FY2026; outlays of the $12.52 billion; AIP grant terminations, if any.
D7 — Public-facing service and downstream impact
Score: unscored (null). Confidence: none. Baseline: calendar 2024: on-time arrival 78.10 percent, cancellations 1.4 percent of flights (DOT Air Travel Consumer Report, research record). Evidence: the DOT’s December 2025 report, which carries the 2025 full-year figures, could not be retrieved (bot wall). The 2025 national figures found (on-time about 76.3 to 76.4 percent; cancellations about 1.53 percent) come from an advocacy group’s analysis (U.S. PIRG Education Fund, E61) and a commercial aggregator, below the source floor for a score. The share of delays attributed to the National Aviation System, the FAA’s own part of the metric, was not obtained for 2024 or 2025. The November 2025 emergency order cut flights at 40 airports during an appropriations lapse (E21) and Newark has been capped since May 2025 (E19, E50); neither is tied on the record to the FAA’s 2025 institutional changes. Under Rule 6-d the dimension is null. Anchor a future score tests: anchor 1 is a measured degradation under 25 percent against FY2024; attribution to the institution’s changes needs the National Aviation System delay share. Evidence still needed: BTS calendar-2025 on-time, cancellation and National Aviation System delay shares, from the primary.
D8 — Legal compliance record
Score: 1. Confidence: Medium. Adjudicated findings (Documented, E40): in the Maryland case (State of Maryland v. United States Department of Agriculture, D. Md. 1:25-cv-00748), in which DOT and its Secretary were defendants, the district court issued a temporary restraining order on 2025-03-13 ordering reinstatement of probationary employees terminated in mass terminations, and a preliminary injunction on 2025-04-01 limited to the plaintiff states; the Fourth Circuit stayed the injunction on 2025-04-09 and on 2025-09-08 vacated it with directions to dismiss, holding that the states lacked standing. The FAA complied by reinstating the employees PASS represents (E9), and DOT’s sworn compliance declarations state that it rescinded, on 2025-03-17, the 775 department-wide terminations the TRO covered (of about 788 effected between 2025-02-14 and 2025-02-24) and returned those employees to duty on 2025-03-20, 92 of whom had resigned by 2025-03-24 (Anne Byrd, ECF 52-1 and 103-1, E80, E81); no FAA split is given. These are adverse preliminary rulings: anchor 1. On 2026-10-29 the MSPB, reciting DOT’s declaration, denied a regulation-review request concerning DOT’s terminations for lack of standing, because DOT had rescinded them and paid back pay (E66); that is a later disposition, not a finding against the agency, and does not change the score. The appeal turned on standing; no court reached the merits of the terminations, so the record says “challenged”, not “unlawful”. No GAO Impoundment Control Act, OSC or contempt finding concerning FAA was found. Stated rationale: the government argued on appeal that the district court lacked jurisdiction and the states lacked standing; the Fourth Circuit agreed on standing (E40). The FAA complied with the orders while they stood (E9). Reading note: methodology D8 counts a ruling stayed on appeal; it does not say how to treat a ruling vacated for lack of standing. Peter ruled on 2026-11-17 that D8 stays 1; the methodology gap is filed as IT-4069. If the vacatur were read as removing the ruling, D8 would be 0 (see Recoverability).
Recoverability (D9, second axis)
Score: 1 (H1). Confidence: Low. Binding constraint: leadership (D2), the only dimension scored 2 or higher. Its remedy is filling Tier-1 posts through the normal process, which is administrative (H1); the commercial space and airspace modernization posts are the ones still vacant. The workforce losses scored 1 under D1 and D3 (executives, attorneys, aeronautical information) would take one to four years to rebuild (H2, reversal pointers below), but under §6 a dimension scored 1 does not bind; the audit notes this as evidence on the D9 convention. Recovery readiness (GAO High-Risk criteria, adapted; narrative only): leadership commitment, a Senate-confirmed Administrator since July 2025, a Secretary-level hiring campaign and a reorganization program (E16, E24, E47); capacity, controller trainee hiring the most since 2008 in FY2025 and a record in FY2026, while the Academy is short of instructors and on-the-job training goals are missed (E58, E24, E59); action plan, the 2026–2028 controller plan with a new staffing target and the modernization program, which GAO says lacks a lifecycle cost estimate and an integrated master schedule (E41, E46); monitoring, active GAO and DOT OIG work and 50 open NTSB recommendations (E23, E24, E26, E46, E59, E17); demonstrated progress, controllers on board up in FY2025 by the FAA’s count while GAO’s count remains below 2015 (E41, E23).
Sensitivity (§7). Equal weights over the six scored dimensions: mean score 6 / 6 = 1.0, composite 25, Strained. Capacity-heavy (D1, D3, D6 doubled: weights 34, 11, 34, 13, 28, 8 = 128): 34 + 22 + 34 + 13 + 0 + 8 = 111; 111 / 4 = 27.75 / 128 = 21.7, 22, Strained. Band stable under both sets, so not band-sensitive by the §7 test. Single readings over the standard weights: D2 read at the cutoff (1) gives 21; D4 at 0 gives 20; D8 at 0 gives 22; D6 at 1 gives 28, all Strained; D1 at 0 or D3 at 0 gives 19, Minimal. If D3 is read as unscored under Rule 6-d (no output measure affirmed), the scored weight is 63, below the 70 percent floor, and no composite may be published. The two unscored dimensions (weight 20) could move the composite from 19.25 (both 0) to 39.25 (both 4), unrounded.
Legal Disclaimer
The Agency Damage Assessment is an analytical framework applying defined criteria to the documented condition of one federal institution. It scores the institution, not a person. Scores, bands and recoverability grades are evaluative conclusions, not statements of criminal guilt or civil liability, and no score constitutes a finding that any official acted unlawfully. The factual predicates are cited to primary sources; the evaluative conclusions are protected expression (Milkovich v. Lorain Journal Co.). New York Times Co. v. Sullivan and its progeny apply to any reference in this assessment to the public conduct of public officials.
Instruments of Harm
| Instrument | Detail | Date | Tier | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| DOGE team | DOGE personnel and SpaceX engineers as special government employees at FAA and its air traffic facilities; first visit to the Air Traffic Control System Command Center on 2025-02-17, three days after the probationary terminations; announced to staff by the acting Administrator on 2025-02-19. Glantz, Malaska and Kiernan, SpaceX engineers serving as unpaid special government employees, were appointed under DOT ethics waivers dated 2025-02-17 (Malaska’s continued 2025-02-21); Smeal, a fourth SpaceX engineer, is named by Wired, ProPublica and the Washington Post (Credibly reported) but has no waiver in the record. The four held “senior adviser to the administrator” titles and FAA accounts until FAA leadership revoked their access in the week of 2025-06-02. The acting Administrator testified on 2025-03-27 to three such employees, “only in contact with one” (E82). What they did with the access is not documented; no decision directed by them is documented. Actor profiles: DOGE — Department of Government Efficiency Policy Tracker, Elon Musk — Political Accountability Profile (the DMA scores the person, not this profile) | 2025-02 to 2025-06 | Documented (waivers; testimony as the administration’s account); Credibly reported (visit date, Smeal, titles, access, revocation) | E10; E11; E12; E54; E67; E68; E72; E82; E86 |
| Executive order or memo | None FAA-specific with a documented effect on the institution located. The 2025-01-21 presidential memorandum “Keeping Americans Safe in Aviation” addresses FAA hiring standards (as quoted by FactCheck.org); the NTSB’s final report makes no finding on hiring policy | 2025-01-21 | Credibly reported (memo quoted by FactCheck.org) | Research record; E18 |
| Probationary terminations / deferred resignation | 352 probationary terminations at FAA by the Secretary’s count (Claimed; at least 132 reinstated). DOT-wide, by DOT’s sworn declarations: about 788 terminated 2025-02-14 to 2025-02-24, the 775 covered by the Maryland TRO rescinded 2025-03-17 and returned 2025-03-20, 92 of them resigned by 2025-03-24 (E80, E81); the FAA share is not recorded. 2,017 separations flagged deferred resignation in the OPM record, voluntary, concentrated in support, management, legal and executive ranks; controllers and systems technicians were ineligible | 2025-02; 2025-04 to 2026-09 | Claimed (the 352); Credibly reported; Documented (DOT-wide counts, OPM) | E6; E9; E80; E81; E66; E1; E36; E39; E73 |
| Grant or contract terminations | None found. A reported plan to move the $2.4 billion Verizon communications contract to Starlink did not proceed, per the Administrator’s 2025-07-15 letter | 2025-02 to 07 | Credibly reported | E13; E53 |
| Tools and data access | Starlink terminals tested at FAA facilities; the Administrator describes “a few dozen” tested through the L3Harris network program | 2025 | Credibly reported | E12; E31; E53 |
| Reorganization or relocation | The 2026-01-26 reorganization (safety management office, Airspace Modernization Office, administrative functions consolidated), stated not to involve reductions in force; the Office of NextGen ended by statute on 2025-12-31 | 2025-12 to 2026-01 | Documented | E47; E48 |
Litigation
Source: CourtListener, run 2026-11-16 through scripts/ca_research.py (three requests: a caption search, the docket record 69714275 and a RECAP search returning 112 dockets, 20 read by caption) and 2026-11-17 (one opinion search, no results); the Fourth Circuit’s opinion was read in full on 2026-11-17 (E40). None of the 20 dockets read is an FAA-specific challenge to a 2025 action against the agency. An FAA-specific case is therefore unverified, not absent. The Just Security and Lawfare trackers were not checked. On 2026-11-17 the FAA series research (g5-doge2) read DOT’s two compliance declarations in the Maryland case and the defendants’ 2025-04-08 compliance report through RECAP copies (E80, E81, E93), and one plaintiff declaration in the AFGE case (E87).
| Case | Court and docket | Filed | Claim | Latest ruling | Status | Scored under |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| State of Maryland v. United States Department of Agriculture | D. Md., 1:25-cv-00748 (Judge James K. Bredar); 4th Cir. No. 25-1248 | 2025-03-06 | Mass terminations of probationary employees at 21 agencies, DOT among them, without reduction-in-force procedures or notice to states | TRO 2025-03-13; preliminary injunction 2025-04-01; stayed 2025-04-09; vacated with directions to dismiss 2025-09-08 (states lacked standing); docket terminated 2025-10-31. DOT’s compliance, by sworn declarations of its Assistant Secretary for Administration, Anne Byrd: about 788 terminated 2025-02-14 to 2025-02-24; 775 “Affected Probationary Employees” told of rescission 2025-03-17 and returned to duty 2025-03-20; 92 resigned by 2025-03-24; the other 13 itemised (ECF 52-1, 2025-03-17, E80; ECF 103-1, 2025-03-25, E81). No FAA split; no DOT declaration in the 2025-04-08 compliance report (E93) | Final: vacated on standing; merits not reached | D8 (flagged); D1 context |
| American Federation of Government Employees, AFL-CIO v. United States Office of Personnel Management | N.D. Cal., 3:25-cv-01780 | 2025-02-19 | Government-wide probationary firings directed by OPM | The N.D. Cal. reinstatement order covered Veterans Affairs, Agriculture, Defense, Energy, Interior and Treasury, not DOT, according to the FAA series research’s reading of Federal News Network and the Clearinghouse summary (E79). The plaintiffs’ TRO papers include a sworn declaration by the president of AFSCME Local 1653, an FAA union local, on the notices and at least 45 terminated members (ECF 18-17, E87); no DOT or FAA declaration appears in the first page of entries read (unverified absence) | Did not cover DOT (Credibly reported) | none |
| Regulation-review request, terminated DOT probationers | MSPB, CB-1205-25-0027-R-1 (one of ten per-agency dockets for 55 terminated probationers) | 2025 (docket year) | Board review of OPM’s probationary-termination directions under its regulation-review authority; the petition’s full claim is not set out in the order read | Denied 2026-06-18; reopened at OSC’s request and denied again 2026-10-29: the petitioner lacks standing because DOT rescinded the termination and paid back pay | Final | none (D8 context) |
Reversal Pointers
Routes, not predictions or legal opinions. Remedy classes: STAT statutory, REG regulatory, REHIRE reinstatement or rehiring, FUND funding restoration, DATA data restoration, OIG oversight, LIT litigation. Horizons: H1 up to 12 months, H2 1 to 4 years, H3 4 to 10 years, H4 over 10 years or possibly permanent. TRC track: A prosecution, B institutional reform, C truth-telling and record.
| Dimension | Remedy class | Reversal pointer (what would restore it) | Preserve now | Horizon | TRC track |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| D1 Workforce (1) | REHIRE, FUND | Rebuild the executive cadre, the Chief Counsel’s attorney staff and the administrative and program-management series through hiring; complete the FAA-level outcome record for the probationers (the FAA share of DOT’s about 788 terminations, 775 rescissions and 92 resignations, E80, E81); keep funding the controller and technician pipelines and Academy instructors | The OPM raw files and the occupational-series tally (E36), snapshots 202412 to 202609; deferred-resignation approval lists by series; the February 2025 termination notices and March 2025 reinstatement records by person; Academy enrollment and failure data | H2 (senior and legal expertise 1 to 4 years; controllers 2 to 6 years to certify, E23) | B |
| D2 Leadership (2) | STAT, OIG | Fill the commercial space and airspace modernization posts through the normal process; keep the Administrator’s five-year term in force | The dated key-officials captures (E35); acting-designation orders and delegations for 2025–2026; the reorganization’s position descriptions | H1 | B |
| D3 Mission (1) | REHIRE, FUND, OIG | Restore aeronautical-information staffing and, where users need them, the discontinued planning charts; act on the NTSB’s 50 recommendations; publish the ground-stop root-cause analysis | Chart and procedure production data FY2024 to now; the ground-stop root-cause report and network logs; the NTSB report and FAA responses; Newark orders and outage logs | H2 | B |
| D4 Independence (1) | OIG | An IG or GAO review of DOGE and SpaceX special-government-employee access at FAA and of the Starlink testing (an advocacy group asked the DOT IG for one on 2025-03-13, E77; no response found) | Special-government-employee appointment papers, the 2025-02-17 waivers for Glantz, Malaska and Kiernan and Malaska’s 2025-02-21 continuation (E67) and any waiver or appointment record for Smeal, ethics agreements and recusals; system-access logs and the June 2025 revocation records (E72); Starlink testing records; FOIA productions | H1 (record) | B, C |
| D5 Data (unscored) | DATA | Not determined | Dated, hashed captures of FAA aeronautical, safety and statistics pages and datasets as an inventory against 2025-01-19 | H1 | C |
| D6 Funding (0) | none needed | No funding harm to reverse; preserve the record of the $12.52 billion’s obligation and outlay | OMB apportionment iterations and footnotes for DOT/FAA; obligation and outlay data for P.L. 119-21 funds; the pay-raise determination under P.L. 119-86 |
n/a | B |
| D7 Public service (unscored) | REG, FUND | Not determined | BTS on-time, cancellation and National Aviation System delay data for 2024 onward; the November 2025 emergency orders and their data basis | H2 | C |
| D8 Compliance (1) | LIT | None pending; the Maryland case is closed | The Maryland and Fourth Circuit dockets and the FAA’s compliance records for March 2025 | H1 | B |
Research Leads
Alleged, single-source or unconfirmed. These never move a score and name no individual.
- Scope note (settled 2026-11-17, IT-4039): the “aviation safety advisory committee” whose members were dismissed in January 2025 is DHS’s Aviation Security Advisory Committee, which advises TSA, not FAA (LA Times, New Republic, E30). It is not recorded against FAA; the lead now sits in department-of-homeland-security’s Research Leads.
- The former Administrator’s departure: one syndicated report is headlined that he quit after the DOGE leader told him to resign (E32, headline and snippet only). The FAA’s own record dates his announcement to 2024-12-12, before the administration took office (E52). Confirm or retire the lead.
- Ethics of a senior FAA official: three senators wrote in February 2026 that a senior FAA official had not divested airline shares by the date an ethics agreement required, and asked DOT to act; the official said he would keep recusing (Reuters, E55). A complaint, not a finding; no outcome on file.
- SpaceX-related staff spared: according to The Guardian (2025-04-18), DOGE-era cuts spared DOT employees who support SpaceX and Starlink launches (E56). Single source.
- Expert panel disbanded: according to Fast Company, citing The Washington Post, a group of aviation experts commissioned in October 2024 to examine air traffic control learned weeks after the inauguration that it was being disbanded (E57). Single lineage.
- Starlink offer: the DOGE leader posted on 2026-11-16 that free Starlink terminals were offered to and declined by the Secretary before the ground stop; the FAA did not respond (research record). Attributed claim only.
- DOGE after February 2025 (updated 2026-11-17): reporting and records dated after February 2025 now exist and are in D4 and the Timeline of Actions (E67 to E72): the waivers and continuation, the 2025-03-27 testimony, the anonymous-sourced Starlink directive and “Project Lift” reports with the FAA’s denial, and the June 2025 revocation of access. The 2025-03-27 testimony is now read in the hearing print (E82). Still open: what the special government employees did on FAA systems, and any FOIA production. The CourtListener search returned FOIA dockets against the U.S. DOGE Service (D.D.C. 1:25-cv-01295 and 1:25-cv-00511) whose productions may touch FAA; not opened. FOIA, checked 2026-11-17 (updated): the FAA’s Electronic Reading Room, read as an archived copy of 2026-11-13, lists no item on DOGE, Starlink, special government employees, the waivers or the 2025 probationary terminations (an absence in a snapshot); DOT’s FOIA library returned HTTP 403 and was not reviewed (E91). American Oversight’s suit of 2025-07-16 names DOT among more than 20 agencies for DOGE-team records; its DOT docket was not found and no production is reported (E89). The waivers reached the press from DOT’s ethics office by a route not stated (E92). Correction to an earlier lead: this draft previously pointed to “the POGO and CREW FOIA dockets” as FAA sources. The only POGO case located, its suit against the President and the U.S. DOGE Service (D.D.C. 1:25-cv-00527-JEB, filed 2025-02-21; preservation injunction denied 2025-06-17), is about DOGE’s own records under the Federal Records Act and FOIA, not FAA’s (E88); the CREW DOGE suits found name CFPB, Education, SSA, VA and State, not DOT or FAA (E90). No FAA-specific FOIA suit by either group was located; the lead stays open only if a docket is produced.
- Requests to oversight bodies, no response found: the Senate Commerce Committee’s ranking member wrote the Secretary on 2025-02-06 that it is “a conflict of interest for someone whose company is regulated by the federal government to be involved in anything that affects his personal financial interest”, copying the Director of the Office of Government Ethics and the DOT acting Inspector General (E75); a senator wrote the acting Administrator on 2025-02-26 asking whether SpaceX engineers were serving as senior advisers and what role they had in the Starlink deployment, with answers requested by 2025-04-09 (E76); and the Campaign Legal Center asked the DOT acting Inspector General on 2025-03-13 to investigate whether the FAA’s Starlink decisions were improperly influenced (E77), an advocacy request, not an IG finding or acceptance. No reply to any of the three, and no DOT OIG or GAO product on DOGE or Starlink at FAA, was found; the absence is unverified (the OIG’s audit-announcement list was reached only through search).
- Two further D.D.C. dockets (1:25-cv-04206, filed 2025-12-03; 1:26-cv-01249, filed 2026-04-14) mention FAA in their text; whether either concerns FAA staff was not checked (a 2026-11-17 query for them timed out).
- The FAA-only split of DOT’s about 788 probationary terminations, 775 rescissions and 92 resignations, beyond the 132 PASS-represented employees and the at least 45 AFSCME Local 1653 members (E87). DOT’s two declarations in the Maryland case are now read (E80, E81) and give no FAA figure, nor does the 2025-04-08 compliance report (E93). Leads: DOT’s 2025-04-01 letter to a senator on the firings, cited in a 2025-07-21 senators’ letter and not retrieved (E85); a PACER pull of the government’s TRO opposition and its exhibit; any later MSPB or OSC record.
- The FAA’s analysis of the cuts’ effect on safety: at the 2025-05-14 Senate Commerce hearing the Office of Airports witness said that office had done an internal analysis, the Air Traffic Organization witness said ATO had not, and the Aviation Safety witness said final data were not available; none of the three could give the number of staff who took the buyout or were fired (E83). The nominee for Administrator wrote, in answers for his 2025-06-11 confirmation hearing, that he “would review the analysis” and, subject to factors he listed, was “committed to ensuring appropriate transparency” (E84). Twelve senators wrote on 2025-07-21 that it had not been provided and asked for the Office of Airports’ analysis (E85). No production was found. An FAA admission relevant to D1 and D8, not to D4’s score.
- American Federation of Government Employees, AFL-CIO v. United States Office of Personnel Management: the reinstatement order did not cover DOT, according to the FAA series research (E79); a docket check would confirm it.
- Ground stop root cause: the Secretary said on 2026-11-15 “We think it was the installation or the router that was the bad actor”; the router maker says its equipment worked as configured; the analysis is at the contractor’s laboratory with FAA staff (E51; research record). Revisit when a root-cause report or an IG review appears.
History
- 2026-11-16, stub: created. All dimensions unscored. Primary records: OPM unit TD:TD03 (E1), USAspending DOT context (E3), the stub-source map (E4). Research: 10 Tavily searches, page extracts, 3 CourtListener requests.
- 2026-11-17, stub update: refreshed OPM (through 202609) and OMB (
DOT/FAA) records; IT-4039 and IT-4040 scope notes. - 2026-11-17, scored (methodology v0.2.0): on Peter’s instruction to complete the assessment (superseding the IT-4040 outcome “FAA stays a stub”). D1 1, D2 1, D3 1, D4 1, D5 null, D6 0, D7 null, D8 1; composite 21, Strained, coverage 80 percent, Medium confidence; D9 1, no binding constraint. New evidence: OPM raw files tallied by occupational series and pay plan (E36); FAA key-officials captures 2024-12 to 2026-10 (E35); the Fourth Circuit opinion (E40); the FAA budget justification, financial report and commercial space forecast (E42 to E44); the wave-1 FAA series research. Corrections to the stub: the Administrator’s departure was announced on 2024-12-12, not unannounced on 2025-01-20 (E52); the Maryland injunction was vacated on 2025-09-08 (E40); the EV accession count is under 10 and is now reported that way; the Tier-1 list swaps the chief information officer (not on the FAA page) for Security and Hazardous Materials Safety. Peak recorded, not scored (Rule 6-a): 3 of 10 Tier-1 posts were over 180 days vacant or acting during 2025–2026 (D2 would be 2 on the peak). Claims-integrity gate (§12) run 2026-11-17: items 1 to 12 checked; open items are listed in the run’s results file.
- 2026-11-17, fix pass (rulings and audit): Peter ruled that D2 counts vacancy spells across the period, not the state at the cutoff (decision D8 in
docs/faa-series-2026-11/README.md): D2 moved from 1 to 2, the composite from 21 to 24 (still Strained), and the binding constraint became leadership. The audit’s point that a D2 of 1 interpolated between anchors is moot at 2. D8 stays 1 by the same ruling; the methodology gap for rulings vacated for lack of standing is filed as IT-4069. D3 was re-examined under Rule 6-d after the audit: a bounded search found the 2025 Aeronautical Information Services charting notices (E62), a Documented output fact on which D3 stays 1; the unscored reading (coverage 63 percent, composite withheld) is recorded in D3 and Recoverability. Basis for Inclusion now states that scoring was admitted by editorial instruction with each §1 indicator qualified. Other corrections from the audit: FY2025 hiring was the most since 2008, not a record (FY2026 was the record); the end of the 2025 flight cuts (airline cuts 2025-11-17, all measures 2025-11-19); Bedford’s dates (confirmed 2025-07-09, listed by the FAA from 2025-07-10); the 2025-01-30 presidential memo naming the acting Administrator; the UPS 2976 fatality count on the NTSB’s 30-day definition; the 2026-10-16 pay increase recorded as announced, payment not documented; the four FAA series documents added torelated; E36 now cites the committed tally. - 2026-11-17, DOGE fold (w5-doge-ada, from
docs/faa-series-2026-11/research/g4-doge.md; no new research): row 002 carries the legal status and DOT’s sworn department-wide rescission of all 775 February 2025 probationary terminations with 92 resignations (status 2025-03-24; MSPB order of 2026-10-29), not netted for FAA (Rule 6-a); Politico’s 2,080 deferred-resignation acceptances sit beside row 003 as Credibly reported; the FAA’s ATSS plan supports row 015; D3 notes the 2025 DRP-exempt categories (OIG AV2026035) and the 1361 mechanism; D4’s “no activity after February 2025” is replaced by the dated record (waivers 2025-02-17 and 2025-02-21, testimony 2025-03-27, anonymous-sourced Starlink and “Project Lift” reports beside the FAA’s denial, access revoked June 2025), with no decision directed by DOGE or SpaceX personnel documented; Research Leads add the Cantwell, Markey and Campaign Legal Center requests. Special government employee appointments are D4 evidence and Timeline rows, not separations. Scores, composite (24, Strained) and band unchanged, per Peter’s rulings D9 and D10. New sources E66 to E79; E11 and E60 annotations updated. - 2026-11-17, w6 fold (w6-ada, from
docs/faa-series-2026-11/research/g5-doge2.md; no new research): Peter’s rulings D14 to D16 applied. D14: the four SpaceX engineers are named (Glantz, Malaska and Kiernan, Documented by the 2025-02-17 waivers; Smeal, Credibly reported, no waiver) in Basis for Inclusion, the Timeline, D4, Instruments and Reversal Pointers, replacing the role-only wording. D16: the first DOGE visit is dated 2025-02-17 (Reuters, confirmed by Politico, CNBC and Axios), replacing the “2025-02 (mid)” row, with the sequence notices (2025-02-14 evening to 2025-02-15), announcement (2025-02-16), visit and waivers (2025-02-17). D15: the 352 stays Claimed (the Timeline’s 2025-02-14 row now says so too). Row 002, D1, D8, Instruments and Litigation now take Anne Byrd’s two sworn declarations (ECF 52-1 and 103-1) as the primary source, with the MSPB order as the later disposition: about 788 terminated, 775 rescinded, 92 resigned by 2025-03-24, the other 13 itemised, no FAA split and no FAA netting (Rule 6-a); the earlier “all 775 probationary terminations” wording overstated the DOT-wide total and is corrected. D4 and the Timeline cite the hearing print S. Hrg. 119-130 for the 2025-03-27 testimony and flag Rocheleau’s “three” against four named people. Research Leads add the 2025-05-14 hearing, the 2025-06-11 confirmation record and the 2025-07-21 letter on the undelivered analysis, the FOIA reading-room checks and American Oversight’s suit, and correct the “POGO and CREW FOIA dockets” lead: no FAA-specific suit by either was located. New sources E80 to E93; E5, E66 and E71 annotations updated. Scores, composite (24, Strained) and band unchanged. - 2026-11-17, w7 citations: Peter approved the alternate-route citations from
docs/faa-series-2026-11/research/g6-alt-routes.md: E45, E65, E27, E80, E81, E93, E40, E44, E47 and E51 now cite the API record, mirror, archived or CourtListener copy actually read, and the DOT reorganization announcement is dated 2026-01-26 (DOT’s own date line), not 2026-01-27. No scores or ratings changed.
Open Questions
- Rule 2 partial baselines (audit open question 3). D1 lacks the trailing five-year separation rate and D2 the historical non-ordinary-exit rate. On a strict reading of “No baseline, no score” both would be unscored, coverage would fall to 52 percent and the composite would be withheld. Whether a partial baseline satisfies Rule 2 is a methodology ruling; D1 and D2 stay scored here pending it.
- D3 reading. Whether the 2025 charting-product discontinuations are degradation (D3 = 1) or rationalization (D3 unscored under Rule 6-d, composite withheld at 63 percent coverage) needs the reason for the discontinuations, which the notices do not give.
- D9 convention. Recoverability binds only on dimensions scored 2 or higher, so the H2 rebuild of the workforce losses scored 1 does not set D9.
Sources
Tiers: primary_official, research_institution, news, advocacy_org. “Snippet only” means the page was seen in a search result and not opened. “Research record” in the text refers to the FAA series research files of 2026-11-17 (docs/faa-series-2026-11/research/), which cite their own sources.
- E1: U.S. Office of Personnel Management, Federal Workforce Data (EHRI status and dynamics), unit TD:TD03 (Federal Aviation Administration), snapshots 202412 to 202609 and separations and accessions 202501 to 202609, in
docs/ada-pilot/data/opm-workforce-subelements.json, retrieved 2026-11-17 — https://data.opm.gov/get-data/api-access — primary_official (people, not FTE; the latest months are the least complete) - E2: U.S. Office of Personnel Management, same dataset, agency TD (Department of Transportation), in
docs/ada-pilot/data/opm-workforce.json, retrieved 2026-11-17 — https://data.opm.gov/get-data/api-access — primary_official (department context only) - E3: USAspending.gov, budgetary resources, toptier agency 069 (Department of Transportation), in
docs/ada-pilot/data/usaspending-budgetary-resources.json, retrieved 2026-10-09 — https://api.usaspending.gov/api/v2/agency/069/budgetary_resources/ — primary_official (toptier only; never FAA’s own figure) - E4:
docs/ada-pilot/data/stub-source-map.json, rowfederal-aviation-administration(OPM unit TD:TD03 mapped; OMB bureau DOT/FAA mapped, 205 files FY2024 to FY2026; read 2026-11-17) — internal mapping record - E5: CNBC, “FAA fires fewer than 400 workers, transportation chief says,” 2025-02-17 — https://www.cnbc.com/2025/02/17/trump-begins-firings-of-faa-air-traffic-control-staff-just-weeks-after-fatal-dc-plane-crash.html — news (snippet only at scoring; full text, a Reuters copy published 2025-02-17 11:33 EST, read by the FAA series research, g5-doge2 #34, 2026-11-17: the Secretary’s figure came “on the same day” the DOGE team was visiting the command center)
- E6: The Hill (Tara Suter), “Duffy on cuts at FAA: ‘We kept all the critical safety positions’,” 2025-02-24 — https://thehill.com/policy/transportation/5161325-faa-workforce-cuts — news (read 2026-11-16; capture refused 2026-11-17, bot wall)
- E7: Associated Press, “Some of the 400 jobs that were cut at the FAA helped support air safety, a union says,” 2025-02 — https://apnews.com/article/faa-firings-trump-doge-safety-airlines-27390c6a7aac58063652302df5a243d3 — news (snippet only)
- E8: The Air Current, “FAA firings put definition of ‘safety-critical’ under scrutiny,” 2025-02-18 — https://theaircurrent.com/aviation-safety/doge-layoffs-faa-safety-critical-roles-scrutiny — news (snippet only)
- E9: Professional Aviation Safety Specialists (PASS), “PASS on Reinstatement of Probationary Employees at FAA,” statement of National President David Spero, March 2025 — https://passnational.org/news/875-pass-on-the-reinstatement-of-probationary-employees-at-faa — advocacy_org (the union’s own account; read in full; captured 2026-11-17)
- E10: Politico (Oriana Pawlyk, Chris Marquette), “Musk’s DOGE, SpaceX both land at FAA,” 2025-02-19, quoting the acting Administrator’s email to staff — https://www.politico.com/news/2025/02/19/doge-faa-solve-challenges-email-00204962 — news (read 2026-11-16; capture refused, robots)
- E11: ProPublica, “The Key Figures Working Alongside Elon Musk at DOGE and in the Trump Administration” (DOGE tracker), entries added 2025-03-13 — https://projects.propublica.org/elon-musk-doge-tracker — news (read in full by the FAA series research, g4-doge, 2026-11-17: four SpaceX staff listed at FAA, each with an FAA email address)
- E12: Reuters (David Shepardson) via Yahoo Finance, “Lawmakers question Musk influence over Verizon FAA contract,” 2025-02 — https://ca.finance.yahoo.com/news/lawmakers-musk-influence-over-verizon-220505495.html — news (snippet only)
- E13: Associated Press via Yahoo Finance, “As DOGE slashes budgets, FAA close to canceling $2.4b contract with Verizon and giving it to Musk’s Starlink,” 2025-02 — https://finance.yahoo.com/news/doge-slashes-budgets-faa-close-162656428.html — news (snippet only)
- E14: DroneLife, “Chris Rocheleau Appointed as Acting FAA Administrator,” 2025-01-30 — https://dronelife.com/2025/01/30/chris-rocheleau-appointed-as-acting-faa-administrator ; The Air Current, “Chris Rocheleau sworn in as FAA deputy administrator” — https://theaircurrent.com/feed/dispatches/chris-rocheleau-deputy-admin-sworn-in ; Skies Mag, “Chris Rocheleau named acting FAA administrator” — https://skiesmag.com/news/chris-rocheleau-named-acting-faa-administrator — news (snippets only; corroborated by E35)
- E15: CNBC, “Trump nominates Republic Airways CEO Bryan Bedford as US FAA head,” 2025-03-17 — https://www.cnbc.com/2025/03/17/trump-nominates-republic-airways-ceo-bryan-bedford-as-us-faa-head.html — news (snippet only)
- E16: Reuters, “US Senate votes to confirm long-time Republic CEO to head FAA,” 2025-07-09 — https://www.reuters.com/world/us/us-senate-votes-confirm-republic-ceo-head-federal-aviation-administration-2025-07-09/ ; Politico, “Airline CEO confirmed as next FAA chief,” 2025-07-09 — https://www.politico.com/news/2025/07/09/airline-ceo-faa-chief-00445100 — news
- E17: National Transportation Safety Board, “Systemic Failures Led to Midair Collision Over Potomac River in Washington,” news release dated 2026-01-28 on the 2026-01-27 board meeting — https://www.ntsb.gov/news/press-releases/Pages/NR20260127.aspx — primary_official (read)
- E18: National Transportation Safety Board, “Midair Collision over the Potomac River,” report AIR-26-02, findings 10, 11, 16 and 18 and probable cause — https://www.ntsb.gov/investigations/AccidentReports/Reports/AIR2602.pdf — primary_official (full text searched by the FAA series research, 2026-11-17; captured 2026-11-17)
- E19: Federal Aviation Administration, “FAA Statements on Newark Liberty International Airport” (entries 2025-04-28 to 2025-09-25) — https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/faa-statements-newark-liberty-international-airport — primary_official (read, archived copy)
- E20: CNN, “Newark airport delays: Air traffic controllers lost communication with planes after they took leave for trauma,” 2025-05-05 — https://www.cnn.com/2025/05/05/us/newark-airport-additional-flight-delays ; AeroTime, “Philadelphia ATC take stress leave after Newark flight chaos” — https://www.aerotime.aero/articles/philadelphia-atc-take-stress-leave-after-newark-flight-chaos — news (snippets only)
- E21: Federal Aviation Administration, “DOT & FAA Announce Temporary 10% Reduction in Flights at 40 Airports,” 2025-11-06 — https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/dot-faa-announce-temporary-10-reduction-flights-40-airports — primary_official (read, archived copy)
- E22: CBS News, “FAA lifts emergency order that slashed flights at 40 major U.S. airports,” 2025-11 — https://www.cbsnews.com/news/faa-lifts-emergency-order-slashing-flights ; CNN, “FAA ends shutdown-era flight cuts at 40 US airports,” 2025-11-16 — https://www.cnn.com/2025/11/16/us/faa-ends-shutdown-flight-cuts — news (snippets only)
- E23: U.S. Government Accountability Office, GAO-26-107320, “Air Traffic Control Workforce: FAA Should Establish Goals and Better Assess Its Hiring Processes,” 2025-12-17, with recommendation status as of 2026-05-28 — https://files.gao.gov/reports/GAO-26-107320/index.html ; https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-26-107320 — primary_official (read; captured 2026-11-17)
- E24: DOT Office of Inspector General, “Audit Initiated of Air Traffic Controller Training at the FAA Academy,” with its related-items list — https://www.oig.dot.gov/library-item/47116 — primary_official (read)
- E25: DOT Office of Inspector General, Fiscal Year 2027 Top Management Challenges — https://www.oig.dot.gov/sites/default/files/library-items/DOT%20FY%2027%20Top%20Management%20Challenges%20Final%20Report.pdf — primary_official (snippet only)
- E26: DOT Office of Inspector General, AV2026022, “FAA Took Action To Improve Monitoring and Increase Staffing Levels at Contract Towers, but Staffing Shortages Remain,” 2026-03-24 — https://www.oig.dot.gov/sites/default/files/library-items/FAA%20Contract%20Tower%20Workforce%20Needs–Final%20Report%203.24.26.pdf — primary_official (snippet only)
- E27: CourtListener, docket 69714275, D. Md. 1:25-cv-00748, read 2026-11-16 — https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/69714275/state-of-maryland-v-united-states-department-of-agriculture/ — research_institution (docket metadata only; read through the CourtListener API 2026-11-17: id 69714275, filed 2025-03-06, terminated 2025-10-31)
- E28: CourtListener, RECAP search for FAA-related dockets filed after 2025-01-20, run 2026-11-16 (112 results, 20 read by caption) — https://www.courtlistener.com/ — research_institution
- E29: Citizen Analyst, backgrounder FAA SMART: What the AI Air Traffic Planning System Is, and What It Is Not (2026-11-13), and the primary records it cites: FAA SMART award release (https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/modern-skies-trumps-transportation-secretary-sean-p-duffy-selects-air-space-intelligence), USAspending award 693KA726C00064 (https://www.usaspending.gov/award/CONT_AWD_693KA726C00064_6920_-NONE-_-NONE-/), FAA ATCSCC Advisory 111 (https://www.fly.faa.gov/adv/adv_otherdis?adv_date=11132026&advn=111) — primary_official via the backgrounder (not re-read)
- E30: Los Angeles Times, “Trump fires heads of TSA, Coast Guard and guts key aviation safety advisory committee,” 2025-01-22 — https://www.latimes.com/world-nation/story/2025-01-22/trump-fires-heads-of-tsa-coast-guard-guts-aviation-safety-advisory-committee ; The New Republic — https://newrepublic.com/post/190934/trump-aviation-safety-committee-dc-plane-crash — news (snippets only; scope note, not FAA)
- E31: Sens. Adam Schiff and Tammy Duckworth, letter to NASA and FAA on contract awards to Musk’s companies, 2025, quoting the DOGE leader’s 2025-02-24 post and the FAA’s statement on Starlink — https://www.schiff.senate.gov/news/press-releases/news-sens-schiff-duckworth-demand-answers-in-letter-to-nasa-faa-over-conflict-of-interest-in-federal-contract-awards-to-musks-private-companies/ ; https://www.duckworth.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/letter_to_nasa_faa_on_musk_conflicts_of_interest.pdf — primary_official (congressional letter making allegations; snippet)
- E32: Syndicated report via Yahoo News, “FAA Administrator Quit on Jan. 20 After Elon Musk Told Him to Resign” — https://www.yahoo.com/news/faa-administrator-quit-jan-20-045322293.html — news (headline and snippet only; Research Lead)
- E33: Office of Management and Budget, public apportionment files, bureau DOT/FAA, FY2024 to FY2026 (205 files), summarised in
docs/ada-pilot/data/omb-apportionment.json, retrieved 2026-11-17 — https://apportionment-public.max.gov/ — primary_official - E34: U.S. Office of Personnel Management, Federal Workforce Data raw files, unit TD:TD03, tallied by pay plan on 2026-11-17 from the cached files behind E1 — https://data.opm.gov/get-data/api-access — primary_official (computed; not in the committed summary)
- E35: Federal Aviation Administration, “Key Officials,” captures with the page’s own “last updated” dates 2024-12-20, 2025-03-19, 2025-08-20, 2026-01-26, 2026-04-14 and 2026-06-23 (read through the Wayback Machine on 2026-11-17), and the page last updated 2026-10-22 (read through an archive copy by the FAA series research) — https://www.faa.gov/about/key_officials ; https://web.archive.org/web/20250105000000/https://www.faa.gov/about/key_officials ; https://web.archive.org/web/20250415000000/https://www.faa.gov/about/key_officials ; https://web.archive.org/web/20250901000000/https://www.faa.gov/about/key_officials ; https://web.archive.org/web/20260315000000/https://www.faa.gov/about/key_officials ; https://web.archive.org/web/20260601000000/https://www.faa.gov/about/key_officials ; https://web.archive.org/web/20260801000000/https://www.faa.gov/about/key_officials — primary_official (archived; the live page refused capture, robots); the Deputy Administrator’s 2026-07-30 departure date is from AeroCorner, https://aerocorner.com/news/faa-deputy-administrator-rocheleau-departure — news (single source)
- E36: U.S. Office of Personnel Management, Federal Workforce Data raw files (employment 202412 to 202609; separations and accessions 202501 to 202609), unit TD:TD03, tallied by occupational series, pay plan and deferred-resignation flag on 2026-11-17 from the cached parquet files behind E1; the tally is committed at
docs/faa-series-2026-11/ada-occupational-tally.json— https://data.opm.gov/get-data/api-access — primary_official (computed) - E37: CBS News (Kris Van Cleave), “FAA’s head of air traffic retiring early as agency replaces senior managers at Reagan National Airport,” 2025-04-09 — https://www.cbsnews.com/news/tim-arel-faa-air-traffic-chief-retires-faa-replacing-dca-managers — news (read; captured 2026-11-17)
- E38: SpaceNews (Jeff Foust), “Head of FAA’s commercial space office takes buyout,” 2025-04-28 — https://spacenews.com/head-of-faas-commercial-space-office-takes-buyout — news (lede read; paywall; captured 2026-11-17)
- E39: Government Executive (Eric Katz), “The Trump administration is staffing up parts of FAA, it’s also incentivizing thousands of departures and threatening layoffs,” 2025-05-15 — https://www.govexec.com/management/2025/05/trump-administration-staffing-parts-faa-its-also-incentivizing-thousands-departures-and-threatening-layoffs/405347 — news (read; captured 2026-11-17)
- E40: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, opinion in No. 25-1248 (appeal from D. Md. 1:25-cv-00748), argued 2025-05-06, decided 2025-09-08, vacated with directions to dismiss — https://www.ca4.uscourts.gov/opinions/251248.P.pdf (captured 2026-11-17); also on CourtListener, opinion id 10668626 (4th Cir. No. 25-1248, 2025-09-08; no reporter citation given by the API record) — https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/10668626/state-of-maryland-v-usda/ — primary_official
- E41: Federal Aviation Administration, The Air Traffic Controller Workforce Plan 2026–2028 (FY2025 actuals, appendix tables) and the FY2025 plan (FY2024 actuals) — https://www.faa.gov/sites/faa.gov/files/Air-Traffic-Controller-Workforce-Plan-2026-2028_0.pdf ; https://www.faa.gov/sites/faa.gov/files/fy25-air-traffic-controller-workforce-plan_0.pdf ; Aviation Safety Workforce Plan FY2025 — https://www.faa.gov/sites/faa.gov/files/fy25-aviation-safety-workforce-plan.pdf — primary_official (read by the FAA series research; not re-read)
- E42: Federal Aviation Administration, “New Record for FAA-Licensed Commercial Space Operations…,” 2024-11-14 (148 licensed operations in FY2024) — https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/new-record-faa-licensed-commercial-space-operations-aerospace-rulemaking-committee ; “The FAA’s 2026 commercial-space forecast” (204 launch and reentry operations in FY2025) — https://www.faa.gov/data_research/aviation/aerospace_forecasts/2026_Commercial_Space_2.pdf — primary_official (search-result text from faa.gov; pages not opened)
- E43: Federal Aviation Administration, FY 2025 Agency Financial Report — https://www.faa.gov/about/office_org/headquarters_offices/afn/offices/finance/offices/financial_management/ar/fy25-faa-agency-financial-report.pdf — primary_official (read by the FAA series research)
- E44: Federal Aviation Administration, FY 2027 President’s Budget Submission (Congressional Justification), Section 6 ten-year tables and Exhibit II-1 — https://www.transportation.gov/sites/dot.gov/files/FAA_FY_2027_Budget_Estimates_CJ.pdf (copy: https://web.archive.org/web/20261116210757id_/https://www.transportation.gov/sites/dot.gov/files/FAA_FY_2027_Budget_Estimates_CJ.pdf) ; P.L. 119-21 — https://www.congress.gov/119/plaws/publ21/PLAW-119publ21.pdf — primary_official (budget document read through the Wayback Machine, capture 2026-11-16; totals computed)
- E45: Congressional Research Service, R48728, “Transportation, HUD and Related Agencies Appropriations for FY2026” — https://www.everycrsreport.com/reports/R48728.html ; Congress.gov, H.R. 7148 (P.L. 119-75, signed 2026-02-03) — https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-bill/7148/all-info (record read through the Congress.gov API 2026-11-17: sponsor Rep. Tom Cole, introduced 2026-01-20, became Public Law 119-75 on 2026-02-03; the web page refuses automated capture) — primary_official
- E46: U.S. Government Accountability Office, GAO-26-107992, “Air Traffic Control Systems: Ambitious New Modernization Effort Needs to Improve Cost and Schedule Planning,” 2026-09 — https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-26-107992 ; https://www.gao.gov/assets/gao-26-107992.pdf — primary_official (read by the FAA series research; captured 2026-11-17)
- E47: U.S. Department of Transportation / FAA, “Trump’s Transportation Secretary Sean P. Duffy & FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford Unveil New Agency Structure…,” 2026-01-26 (the page’s own date line: Monday, January 26, 2026) — https://www.transportation.gov/briefing-room/trumps-transportation-secretary-sean-p-duffy-faa-administrator-bryan-bedford-unveil (archived copy: https://web.archive.org/web/20260906084653id_/https://www.transportation.gov/briefing-room/trumps-transportation-secretary-sean-p-duffy-faa-administrator-bryan-bedford-unveil; live page refuses automated capture) — primary_official (read through the archived copy)
- E48: Federal Aviation Administration, NextGen Final Report 2025 (“the Office of NextGen concluded its mission on December 31, 2025”) — https://www.faa.gov/nextgen/NextGen-Final-Report-2025.pdf — primary_official (read by the FAA series research)
- E49: Federal Aviation Administration, “Trump’s Transportation Department, Air Traffic Controller Union Announce 2.8% Pay Increase Deal,” 2026-10-16 — https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/trumps-transportation-department-air-traffic-controller-union-announce-28-pay-increase ; Sens. Duckworth and Durbin, letter to the FAA on the controller pay increase, 2026-09-04 — https://www.duckworth.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/duckworth_durbin_letter_to_faa_re_atc_pay_increase.pdf ; CBS News, “Illinois senators blast FAA administrator for holding air traffic controller raises ‘hostage'” — https://www.cbsnews.com/news/illinois-senators-faa-air-traffic-controller-pay-raises — primary_official; primary_official (partisan letter); news
- E50: Federal Register, 2026-12589, “Operating Limitations at Newark Liberty International Airport,” 2026-06-23 — https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/06/23/2026-12589/operating-limitations-at-newark-liberty-international-airport (captured 2026-11-17) ; 2026-12593, “Staffing-Related Relief Concerning Operations at Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport, John F. Kennedy International Airport, and LaGuardia Airport…,” 2026-06-23 — https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/06/23/2026-12593/staffing-related-relief-concerning-operations-at-ronald-reagan-washington-national-airport-john-f — primary_official
- E51: Federal Aviation Administration, “Nationwide Ground Stop: Questions and Answers,” 2026-11-15 — https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/nationwide-ground-stop-questions-and-answers ; U.S. Department of Transportation, ICYMI releases of 2026-11-14 and 2026-11-15 — https://www.transportation.gov/briefing-room/icymi-us-transportation-secretary-sean-p-duffy-provides-update-restoration-airspace (archived copy: https://web.archive.org/web/20261116173101id_/https://www.transportation.gov/briefing-room/icymi-us-transportation-secretary-sean-p-duffy-provides-update-restoration-airspace) ; https://www.transportation.gov/briefing-room/icymi-trumps-transportation-secretary-sean-p-duffy-provides-update-across-sunday (archived copy: https://web.archive.org/web/20261116113838id_/https://www.transportation.gov/briefing-room/icymi-trumps-transportation-secretary-sean-p-duffy-provides-update-across-sunday) — primary_official (DOT pages read through archived copies; live pages refuse automated capture)
- E52: Federal Aviation Administration, “FAA General Statements,” entry of 2024-12-12 (the Administrator’s letter to employees announcing he would step down on 2025-01-20) — https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/statements/general-statements ; CNBC, “Federal Aviation Administration head Michael Whitaker to step down,” 2024-12-12 — https://www.cnbc.com/amp/2024/12/12/federal-aviation-administration-head-michael-whitaker-to-step-down-jan-20.html — primary_official; news
- E53: Reuters (David Shepardson) via Yahoo Finance, “US FAA not considering replacing L3Harris, Verizon contracts with Musk’s Starlink,” 2025-07-16, on the Administrator’s letter dated 2025-07-15 — https://ca.finance.yahoo.com/news/us-faa-not-considering-replacing-161335429.html — news (read; captured 2026-11-17)
- E54: Fox News, “Elon Musk’s SpaceX engineers part of DOGE team at FAA,” 2025-02 — https://www.foxnews.com/politics/elon-musks-spacex-engineers-deployed-faa-help-modernize-air-traffic-control ; MeriTalk, “DOGE Will Team Up With FAA…” — https://www.meritalk.com/articles/doge-will-team-up-with-faa-to-fix-americas-aging-air-traffic-systems — news (snippets only)
- E55: Reuters via Yahoo Finance, “Senators ask US to disclose if FAA administrator sold stake in airline,” 2026-02-05 — https://finance.yahoo.com/news/senators-ask-us-disclose-faa-160526491.html — news (Research Lead; complaint, not a finding)
- E56: The Guardian, “Doge cuts spark questions as employees supporting Musk space launches spared,” 2025-04-18 — https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/apr/18/trump-space-employees-musk — news (snippet only; Research Lead)
- E57: Fast Company (Alex Pasternack), “The FAA’s ground stop has a simple culprit. Its causes may not,” 2026-11, citing The Washington Post — https://www.fastcompany.com/91643272/the-faa-was-warned-about-its-telecom-upgrade — news (Research Lead)
- E58: Federal Aviation Administration, “FAA Breaks All-Time Record for Air Traffic Controller Trainee Hiring,” 2026-10-01 — https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/faa-breaks-all-time-record-air-traffic-controller-trainee-hiring — primary_official (read by the FAA series research)
- E59: DOT Office of Inspector General, AV2026031, “Despite Implementing the National Training Initiative and Increasing Supplemental Pay, FAA Still Faces Challenges Meeting Air Traffic Controller On-the-Job Training Goals,” 2026-06-24 — https://www.oig.dot.gov/sites/default/files/library-items/Final%20Report_%20FAAs%20Implementation%20of%20ATC%20OJT%20Initiatives%20.pdf — primary_official (read by the FAA series research)
- E60: DOT Office of Inspector General, AV2026035, “FAA Completes Workforce Plans That Are Mandated by Law, but Some Safety-Critical Workforces and Key Information Are Not Included in the Plans,” 2026-09-16 (workforce data as of 2025-12-27) — https://www.oig.dot.gov/sites/default/files/library-items/Final%20Report%20-%20FAA%20Aviation%20Safety%20Workforce.pdf — primary_official (snippet only at scoring; read by the FAA series research, g4-doge, 2026-11-17, for the 2025 position categories and the “safety-critical” definition)
- E61: U.S. PIRG Education Fund, “New report: On-time flight arrivals in 2025 hit worst level since 2014” — https://pirg.org/edfund/media-center/new-report-on-time-flight-arrivals-in-2025-hit-worst-level-since-2014 — advocacy_org (snippet; not used for a score)
- E62: Federal Aviation Administration, Aeronautical Information Services (AJV-A), Charting Notice VIS 25-03, “Discontinuation of selected charting products and services beginning August 7, 2025,” 2025-05-30 — https://www.faa.gov/air_traffic/flight_info/aeronav/safety_alerts/media/VIS_25-03_CN_Product_Terminations_eff_Aug_2025.pdf ; Charting Notice VIS 25-05, “Aeronautical Chart Users Guide – Change in Publication Schedule,” 2025-08-13 — https://www.faa.gov/air_traffic/flight_info/aeronav/safety_alerts/media/VIS_25-05_CN_CUG_Chart_Publication_Schedule.pdf — primary_official (both read in full 2026-11-17 through archive copies; capture of faa.gov refused, robots)
- E63: CBS News, on the 2025-01-30 presidential memo appointing Christopher Rocheleau acting FAA Administrator — https://www.cbsnews.com/news/plane-crash-dc-faa-administrator-trump-appointment — news (via the FAA series research, r2 #95)
- E64: Federal Aviation Administration, Testimony of Bryan Bedford, Senate Commerce Aviation Subcommittee, 2026-05-19 (the FAA lists him as Administrator since 2025-07-10) — https://www.faa.gov/testimony/testimony-bryan-bedford-faa-administrator-hearing-us-senate-committee-commerce-science — primary_official (via the FAA series research, g2 #48)
- E65: Congressional Research Service, R49491, on the November 2025 emergency orders (90 FR 50884, 90 FR 51426 replacement order with general-aviation limits, 90 FR 52132 cancellation of all measures on 2025-11-19) — https://www.everycrsreport.com/reports/R49491.html (CRS R49491, “Federal Government Shutdowns and the Impact on Civil Aviation,” 2026-10-22; the Congress.gov product page https://www.congress.gov/crs-product/R49491 refuses automated capture; capture record
page-ae19fae05fa4-2026-11-17-ed40b3aa) — primary_official (CRS text read on the EveryCRSReport mirror; its footnotes 54-56 give the three Federal Register page ranges and dates, 2025-11-12, 2025-11-17 and 2025-11-19, which are the dates attributed here; Register pages themselves not fetched) - E66: U.S. Merit Systems Protection Board, Final Order, docket CB-1205-25-0027-R-1 (regulation-review request for terminated DOT probationary employees, respondent OPM), 2026-10-29, pp. 5–7, reciting DOT’s sworn declaration of its Assistant Secretary for Administration (in the Board’s words, all 775 February 2025 probationary terminations rescinded; 92 resignations as of 2025-03-24; DOT-wide, no FAA split. The declarations themselves show the 775 were those covered by the TRO, of about 788 terminated, E80, E81) — https://www.mspb.gov/decisions/nonprecedential/DOT_Interested_Terminated_Probationary_Employee_-_CB-1205-25-0027-R-1_4187721.pdf — primary_official (read by the FAA series research, g4-doge #01, #14, #17; the declaration it recites is Byrd’s ECF 103-1, now E81, and the order is cited as the later disposition)
- E67: U.S. Department of Transportation, Office of General Counsel (Deputy General Counsel and Designated Agency Ethics Official), “Approval of Waiver Pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 208(b)(1)”, three waivers dated 2025-02-17 and a “Continuation of Waiver” dated 2025-02-21, as published by The New York Times — https://static01.nyt.com/newsgraphics/documenttools/145907425b2509be/191a2276-full.pdf — primary_official (agency memoranda read through the newspaper’s copy, not retrieved from DOT; g4-doge #20, #21)
- E68: WIRED, “These Are the SpaceX Engineers Already Working Inside the FAA,” 2025-02-19 (anonymous sources; quotes the acting Administrator’s 2025-02-19 email) — https://www.wired.com/story/faa-doge-elon-musk-space-x — news (via the FAA series research, g4-doge #19)
- E69: Bloomberg News, “How Elon Musk muscled his way into the FAA” (feature of 2025-03-05, two unnamed sources), syndicated copy read — https://www.thelcn.com/news/how-elon-musk-muscled-his-way-into-the-faa/article_af64c663-f9e8-51da-8b44-1ed2d3e55989.html ; original https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2025-03-05/after-elon-musk-lands-at-faa-his-starlink-business-stands-to-gain-business — news (single outlet, anonymous sources; g4-doge #23)
- E70: Rolling Stone, “Musk Allies Made FAA Staff Sign NDAs to Keep New Project Secret,” 2025-04-25 (three unnamed sources; FAA spokesperson’s denial quoted) — https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-features/trump-musk-doge-faa-nda-secret-project-lift-1235325667 — news (g4-doge #28)
- E71: Reuters, “DOGE team is not involved in FAA decision regarding Starlink terminals, acting FAA administrator says,” 2025-03-27 — https://www.reuters.com/world/us/doge-team-is-not-involved-faa-decision-regarding-starlink-terminals-acting-faa-2025-03-27 ; as relayed by AeroTime, “FAA: Musk’s team not involved in Starlink terminal decisions,” 2025-03-28 — https://www.aerotime.aero/articles/faa-musks-team-not-involved-in-starlink-terminal-decisions — news (Reuters snippet only; AeroTime read; g4-doge #27; the hearing print is now E82, which is the primary source for the testimony)
- E72: The Washington Post, “A diminished DOGE reels from the departure of the ‘Dogefather,’ Elon Musk,” 2025-06-08 (records obtained by the Post) — https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2025/06/08/doge-elon-musk-exit-trump ; syndicated copy read in full — https://www.postguam.com/business/world/a-diminished-doge-reels-from-the-departure-of-the-dogefather-elon-musk/article_791bb35b-affe-4c6b-956a-d61294058e77.html — news (g4-doge #29)
- E73: Federal Aviation Administration, Airway Transportation System Specialist Workforce Plan 2026–2030, 2026-05-15, chapter 2 — https://www.faa.gov/sites/faa.gov/files/Airway-Transportation-Systems-Specialist-Workforce-Plan-2026-2030.pdf (posted at https://www.faa.gov/about/plansreports/congress/airway-transportation-systems-specialist-workforce-plan-2026-2030) — primary_official (read by the FAA series research, g4-doge #08, #43)
- E74: POLITICO, “7 percent of DOT staff taking early-buyout offers,” 2025-07-17 (one anonymous source, DOT data as of 2025-07-07) — https://www.politico.com/news/2025/07/17/7-percent-of-dot-staff-taking-early-buyout-offers-00460550 — news (g4-doge #36)
- E75: Sen. Maria Cantwell, letter to Secretary Duffy on conflicts of interest, 2025-02-06, copying the OGE Director and the DOT acting Inspector General — https://www.commerce.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/media/doc/2.6.25%20Letter%20to%20Sec%20Duffy%20re%20Musk%20Conflict%20of%20Interest_FINAL.pdf — primary_official (congressional letter; g4-doge #18)
- E76: Sen. Edward J. Markey, “Senator Markey Raises Concerns Over Conflict of Interest with FAA Deployment of Elon Musk’s Starlink Terminals,” 2025-02-26 (letter to the acting Administrator) — https://www.markey.senate.gov/news/press-releases/senator-markey-raises-concerns-over-conflict-of-interest-with-faa-deployment-of-elon-musks-starlink-terminals — primary_official (congressional letter; g4-doge #25)
- E77: Campaign Legal Center, “Is Musk Using the FAA to Benefit Himself and His SpaceX Subsidiary, Starlink?,” 2025-03-13 (request to the DOT acting Inspector General) — https://campaignlegal.org/update/musk-using-faa-benefit-himself-and-his-spacex-subsidiary-starlink — advocacy_org (a request, not a finding; g4-doge #26)
- E78: CNN Business, on the FAA’s 2025-02-24 post about Starlink terminal testing (one at Atlantic City, two at non-safety-critical sites in Alaska), 2025-02-25 — https://www.cnn.com/2025/02/25/business/musk-faa-starlink-contract — news (snippet only; g4-doge #24)
- E79: Federal News Network, “25,000 fired feds reinstated after courts find probationary terminations illegal,” 2025-03 — https://federalnewsnetwork.com/workforce/2025/03/25000-fired-feds-reinstated-after-courts-find-probationary-terminations-illegal ; Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse, case 46203 (D. Md. 1:25-cv-00748) — https://clearinghouse.net/case/46203 — news; research_institution (via the FAA series research, g4-doge #12)
- E80: U.S. Department of Transportation, Declaration of Anne Byrd, Assistant Secretary for Administration and Chief Human Capital Officer (in post since 2025-02-25; Senior Advisor to the Secretary from 2025-02-03), under 28 U.S.C. § 1746, dated 2025-03-17, Exhibit 1 to the defendants’ status report, ECF 52-1, D. Md. 1:25-cv-00748 (about 788 probationers terminated 2025-02-14 to 2025-02-24; 775 “Affected Probationary Employees” told of rescission 2025-03-17; the other 13 itemised; no FAA split) — https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/69714275/52/1/state-of-maryland-v-united-states-department-of-agriculture/ — primary_official (sworn declaration, read in full through a Wayback copy of the RECAP page by the FAA series research, g5-doge2 #09, 2026-11-17; docket metadata read via the CourtListener API 2026-11-17: id 69714275, filed 2025-03-06, terminated 2025-10-31)
- E81: U.S. Department of Transportation, second Declaration of Anne Byrd, Exhibit 1 to ECF 103, filed 2025-03-25, D. Md. 1:25-cv-00748 (all 775 contacted and returned to active duty 2025-03-20; as of 2025-03-24, 92 resigned and 683 on duty or voluntary leave; no FAA split). This is the declaration the MSPB recites (E66) — https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/69714275/103/1/state-of-maryland-v-united-states-department-of-agriculture/ — primary_official (sworn declaration, read in full through a Wayback copy, g5-doge2 #10; docket metadata read via the CourtListener API 2026-11-17: id 69714275, filed 2025-03-06, terminated 2025-10-31)
- E82: U.S. Senate, Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation, Subcommittee on Aviation, Space, and Innovation, “NTSB Preliminary Report: The DCA Midair Collision,” hearing of 2025-03-27, S. Hrg. 119-130 (GPO print dated 2025-08-13), with the acting Administrator’s answers to Sen. Markey and the written questions for the record — https://www.congress.gov/119/chrg/CHRG-119shrg61288/CHRG-119shrg61288.pdf — primary_official (official hearing print, read by the FAA series research, g5-doge2 #15 to #18, #25, #26; the statements are the administration’s claims)
- E83: U.S. Senate, Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation, “FAA Reauthorization One Year Later: Aviation Safety, Air Traffic and Next Generation Technology,” hearing of 2025-05-14, S. Hrg. 119-144 (FAA witnesses from Aviation Safety, the Air Traffic Organization and Airports; the Markey exchange on buyouts, firings and internal analysis; written answers on deferred-resignation eligibility) — https://www.congress.gov/119/chrg/CHRG-119shrg61427/CHRG-119shrg61427.pdf — primary_official (official hearing print; the relevant exchange, statements and staffing answers read, not every page; g5-doge2 #23)
- E84: U.S. Senate, Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation, “Nomination of Bryan Bedford,” hearing of 2025-06-11, S. Hrg. 119-254, written answers to Sen. Markey — https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CHRG-119shrg62325/html/CHRG-119shrg62325.htm — primary_official (official hearing print; g5-doge2 #24)
- E85: Sens. Edward J. Markey, Tim Kaine and ten other senators, letter to Administrator Bedford, “FAA staffing cuts and safety,” 2025-07-21 (the promised analysis not provided; asks for the Office of Airports’ analysis; cites DOT’s 2025-04-01 letter to Sen. Markey and an FAA management presentation quoted by the Wall Street Journal) — https://www.markey.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/senate_letter_on_faa_staffing_cuts_and_safety_7212025.pdf — primary_official (congressional letter making requests and allegations; the letters it cites not retrieved; g5-doge2 #14)
- E86: Reuters, “Musk’s DOGE team to visit US FAA command center on Monday,” 2025-02-17 — https://www.reuters.com/world/us/musks-doge-team-visit-us-faa-air-traffic-control-command-center-monday-2025-02-17 ; POLITICO, “Musk’s SpaceX team visiting key FAA command center – despite past frictions,” 2025-02-17 (the Secretary’s announcement late on 2025-02-16; the Warrenton visit on Monday) — https://www.politico.com/news/2025/02/17/elon-musk-spacex-faa-visit-00204577 ; Axios, “Musk’s SpaceX personnel visiting FAA to suggest improvements,” 2025-02-17 — https://www.axios.com/2025/02/17/elon-musk-space-x-doge-faa-air-traffic-control — news (Reuters lead paragraph only, fetch blocked; Politico read in full; Axios read; g5-doge2 #32 to #34. A Politico piece of 2025-02-19 (E10) says the visit was “over the weekend”; no source places a visit before 2025-02-16)
- E87: Daniel T. Ronneberg, President, FAA Employees Union, AFSCME Local 1653, sworn declaration, ECF 18-17, N.D. Cal. 3:25-cv-01780 (filed 2025-02-23; notices “between midnight and 2:00 a.m.” on 2025-02-15, effective 2025-02-14; “at least … forty-five (45)” bargaining-unit members terminated) — https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/69655364/18/17/american-federation-of-government-employees-afl-cio-v-united-states/ — primary_official (a plaintiff-side sworn declaration; the 45 is a union count; read through a Wayback copy, g5-doge2 #12)
- E88: Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse, case 46151, the Project on Government Oversight’s Federal Records Act and FOIA suit against the President, the U.S. DOGE Service and its temporary organization, D.D.C. 1:25-cv-00527-JEB, filed 2025-02-21 — https://clearinghouse.net/case/46151 ; CourtListener, ECF 23 (2025-06-17, preservation injunction denied) — https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/69661712/23/project-on-government-oversight-inc-v-trump — research_institution (docket summary and opinion header; no FAA content found; g5-doge2 #04)
- E89: American Oversight, “American Oversight Sues More Than 20 Federal Agencies for Withholding Records on Secretive DOGE Teams,” 2025-07-16 (DOT among the defendants) — https://americanoversight.org/press-release/american-oversight-sues-more-than-20-federal-agencies-for-withholding-records-on-secretive-doge-teams — advocacy_org (the group’s own account of its filing; DOT docket not found; g5-doge2 #03)
- E90: Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington, “CREW sues multiple departments for records on DOGE” — https://www.citizensforethics.org/legal-action/lawsuits/crew-sues-multiple-departments-for-records-on-doge ; “Judge grants CREW discovery in DOGE FOIA suit” — https://www.citizensforethics.org/news/press-releases/judge-grants-crew-discovery-in-doge-foia-suit — advocacy_org (search snippets; none names DOT or FAA; g5-doge2 #05)
- E91: Federal Aviation Administration, Electronic Reading Room, archived copy of 2026-11-13 — https://www.faa.gov/foia/electronic_reading_room (copy: https://web.archive.org/web/20261113221822id_/https://www.faa.gov/foia/electronic_reading_room) ; U.S. Department of Transportation, “The Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) at DOT,” archived copy of 2026-11-15 — https://www.transportation.gov/foia (copy: https://web.archive.org/web/20261115113354id_/https://www.transportation.gov/foia) — primary_official (snapshots; the absence of a DOGE item is in the snapshot only; DOT’s FOIA library returned 403; g5-doge2 #01, #02)
- E92: POLITICO Weekly Transportation, “Details emerge on SpaceX engineers at the FAA,” 2025-03-03 (waivers obtained from DOT’s ethics office; signed the day after the Secretary’s announcement; Malaska’s employment and waiver later extended) — https://www.politico.com/newsletters/weekly-transportation/2025/03/03/details-emerge-on-spacex-engineers-at-the-faa-00206882 — news (archived copy read; g5-doge2 #06, #27, #35)
- E93: The enjoined federal defendants, compliance status report of 2025-04-08, ECF 136-1, D. Md. 1:25-cv-00748 (declarations from about ten agencies’ human-capital officials; none from DOT; no FAA figure) — https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/69714275/136/1/state-of-maryland-v-united-states-department-of-agriculture/ — primary_official (read through a Wayback copy; absence within the document; g5-doge2 #11; docket metadata read via the CourtListener API 2026-11-17: id 69714275, filed 2025-03-06, terminated 2025-10-31)
Factual correction requests: If you believe information in this profile is incorrect, please contact factcheck@citizenanalyst.ai with your name (optional), the specific claim, and any supporting documentation. We review all submissions and correct verified errors promptly.
Cross-References
- bryan-bedford-profile (Administrator since 2025-07-09; draft profile)
- Sean Duffy – Secretary of Transportation (Secretary of Transportation)
- Elon Musk — Political Accountability Profile and DOGE — Department of Government Efficiency Policy Tracker (DOGE; actor profiles, scored by the DMA, not here)
- FAA SMART: What the AI Air Traffic Planning System Is, and What It Is Not (the 2026 SMART traffic-flow tool and the 2026-11-13 ground stop)
- Parent agency profile
department-of-transportation: not yet created, so not wikilinked
