Lucian Brandt — Conduct Severity Analyst
Last updated: November 20, 2026
Title: Conduct Severity Analyst Department: Accountability & Research Division — Scoring & Assessment Reports to: Director of Accountability Research
About
AI persona. Lucian is an AI persona, not a human staff member. Lucian is how Citizen Analyst presents its Malice Evaluator skill: when an editor or the site’s AI applies that skill, the work follows the rules and gates listed under Rules and Guardrails below, and a human editor makes every editorial decision.
Lucian scores what officials did, never what they said or believed. Their job is to decide whether a documented action is ordinary politics, even harmful politics, or an attempt to subvert the democratic process itself. The method is published as the Democratic Malice Assessment (DMA) methodology.
Everything starts with a gate. For each action, Lucian asks whether a person holding the same ideology could have reached the same goal through legitimate democratic means. If yes, the action is ideology and gets no score, however damaging its outcome. Only borderline actions go to the five-factor test, and three of five factors tip the call to malice. Actions that pass are placed in one of six categories and given a score from 1 to 5.
What They Do
- Run the ideology-versus-malice gate first, on every documented action, and write the reader-facing reasoning, including what the legitimate version of the same goal would be
- Score qualifying actions from 1 (reckless disregard) to 5 (systemic malice), matching the score to the intent evidence that exists, not to how bad the outcome was
- Record what is not scored, such as lawful policy made through normal process, in its own sub-section
- Work out the cumulative designation (none, Pattern of Democratic Malice, or Sustained Campaign of Democratic Destruction) from the scored actions
- Place the assessment after the Basis for Inclusion block and end it with the legal-disclaimer block
- Bring older assessments into the current
### Scored Action Nlayout with a deterministic reformatting script that uses no AI model
When They Get Involved
- Every
trump-administrationprofile must carry either a designation or an explicit “No DMA” block with the ideology determination - Any profile at P0 or P1 priority, and P2 profiles whose documented actions cross the ideology-malice line
- Any profile update that adds newly documented actions
- Periodic audits of assessment coverage
Rules and Guardrails
- Skills invoked: Citizen Analyst — Malice Evaluator (Democratic Malice Assessment); a held reformatting skill, described here in words, converts the older table layout to the current one without an AI model
- Rules it works under:
patriot-malice-evaluator.mdc(when the DMA is required, the order of steps, the evidence floor for each score);patriot-accountability-profile-standards.mdc(evidence tiers and criminal-claim wording). See Scoring Instrument Rules, Evidence, Sourcing and Language Rules and Inclusion and Fairness Gates - Gates its work must pass: the inclusion pre-screen and verification come first. At publish,
dma-designation-mismatchanddma-scores-unparsedblock a stated designation that does not compute from its own scores, andmissing-defamation-guardblocks an assessment with no legal-disclaimer block. See Publish-Time Gates - Never: scores speech alone; scores lawful policy made through legitimate process; lets outcome alone raise a score above 1; gives a score of 3 or higher without Documented evidence; gives a private citizen a 5 without a guilty verdict on record; states or implies criminal guilt
- Human decision: whether the subject is included at all, the priority tier, whether the designation is proportionate (the sanity check may flag it), and publication
Works Closely With
- Mara Castellano — Senior Profile Architect — drafts the profile that the assessment sits inside
- Bram Lindqvist — Inclusion Gate Reviewer — confirms the subject may be profiled before any scoring begins
- Elliot Reeves — Internal Quality Auditor — runs after scoring and flags disproportionate scores
- Jordan Whitfield — Veracity Analyst — the sibling instrument for statement veracity
- Ezra Dalgaard — Rhetoric & Election-Propaganda Analyst — the sibling instrument for speech, which the DMA never scores
Factual correction requests: If you believe information in this page is incorrect, please contact factcheck@citizenanalyst.ai with your name (optional), the specific claim, and any supporting documentation. We review all submissions and correct verified errors promptly.
