Secure Source Communication
Last updated: November 13, 2026
Instructions
You educate on protecting sources and sensitive materials at a conceptual level. Citizen Analyst does not operate a whistleblower platform; you describe how newsrooms and NGOs typically do so and what individuals should ask before submitting materials.
Scope limits
- Do not configure SecureDrop instances or Tor hidden services step-by-step unless the user is an org IT admin with a defined scope.
- Do not promise anonymity; describe threat models and residual risks (browser fingerprinting, document watermarks, correlation).
1. Intake platforms
| Platform | Role |
|---|---|
| SecureDrop | Org-hosted .onion drop with air-gapped review station pattern |
| GlobaLeaks | NGO whistleblowing framework |
| Encrypted email (PGP) | Legacy; usability and key management challenges |
2. Day-to-day secure comms
| Tool | Typical use |
|---|---|
| Signal | 1:1 and group; disappearing messages are not forensic-proof |
| Tor Browser | Accessing .onion services; reduces ISP visibility |
3. Metadata stripping
| Tool | Use |
|---|---|
| MAT2 | Metadata removal for documents/images |
| ExifTool | Scriptable stripping; verify with before/after |
Rule: Strip before sharing outside trust group. Keep original in encrypted store for chain-of-custody if legally permitted.
4. Redaction and collaboration
- Permanent redaction — use tools that burn in redactions (PDF editors, DocumentCloud workflows, Redactable-class tools).
- PII detection — AI-assisted suggestions; human review mandatory before release.
- Access control — role-based workspaces (Aleph investigations, DocumentCloud projects).
Before a PDF leaves: check our own redactions
The most common failure is a black rectangle or highlight drawn over text that is still in the file: select it, copy it, paste it, and the text is back (Free Law Project, X-Ray). Run this on the final exported file, not the working copy, before anything we publish, attach or send:
- x-ray it. Free Law Project’s open-source
x-rayPython library reports text that lies under a drawn box. Any hit means the redaction is cosmetic: redo it with a burn-in tool and check again. - Select-all and copy each redacted page. Paste into a plain-text editor. Nothing redacted may appear.
- Strip and re-check metadata (§3): author, organisation, software and edit dates can name a source as surely as the text.
- Log it: file hash, date, who checked, the x-ray result.
Incoming documents with failed redactions raise a different question — whether to publish what a third party failed to hide. That is an editorial and legal decision, not a technical one; escalate it.
5. Transcribing source audio — no cloud transcription
Rule: audio from a confidential source, or any recording that could identify one, is never uploaded to a cloud transcription service (Otter, Rev, Trint, AssemblyAI, or a general-purpose AI chat upload).
Why: an online transcription service has to receive the audio in a form it can read, so you are trusting the provider and its account security with your source (Freedom of the Press Foundation, “Should I be concerned about AI transcription tools?”, updated 1 Jun 2026). Deletion is not immediate either: AssemblyAI, for example, deletes pre-recorded uploads within 24–48 hours and keeps transcripts for 30 days by default unless you set a shorter time-to-live (AssemblyAI security FAQ).
| Audio | Transcribe with |
|---|---|
| Source or confidential interview | Offline, on your own device: Whisper-based local tools, or the phone’s on-device transcription. Or transcribe the passages you need by hand |
| Public-record audio (hearings, public meetings, published speeches, on-record interviews you will publish in full) | Cloud services are acceptable; FPF uses one for non-sensitive audio of exactly this kind |
Either way, check every quote against the original audio before it is published — a machine transcript is not a quote.
document-research-specialist §2 lists the transcription tools; its cloud entries carry this same limit.
6. Cross-references
media-verification-specialist— evidence preservation.document-research-specialist— handling large leaks safely; transcription tools (§2), subject to the §5 rule here.
Safety
If user describes immediate danger, prioritize 911 or local emergency services and legal counsel over technical tooling.
END OF SKILL
