The FAA under Trump was mid-rebuild when a router problem halted US flights
Last updated: November 17, 2026
DRAFT — research draft, 2026-11-17. Not for publication until editor review.
The Brief
The FAA runs air traffic control and checks that planes are safe. President Trump’s second term began on January 20, 2025, with no confirmed FAA chief. Nine days later, a jet and an Army helicopter collided near Washington, and 67 people died. Safety investigators said the risks were years old. Congress then gave the FAA $12.5 billion to replace old equipment. The FAA hired more trainees in 2026 than ever before, but fully trained controllers stayed near 11,000. Elon Musk’s DOGE team came in February 2025. On November 13, 2026, a flood of data from routers being replaced swamped an old FAA network, and flights at every U.S. airport were held for over four hours. Why the routers flooded it is still under review.
Why It Matters
Every airline flight in the United States depends on the FAA’s air traffic system. This term has seen the worst U.S. air accident since 2001, a 43-day funding lapse in which controllers worked unpaid, flight caps at Newark and the first nationwide ground stop since 2023, along with $12.5 billion for new equipment and record trainee hiring in 2026. Both parties now blame each other for the failures, and readers need the dated record to judge those claims. This is Part 3 of a three-part series that grades each term on the same scorecard; this term is still under way, so it is a mid-term reading with evidence to November 17, 2026.
The Facts
A note on terms used throughout. A Certified Professional Controller (CPC) is a controller fully certified to work every position at a facility; trainees are CPCs-in-training (CPC-IT, certified elsewhere and retraining) plus developmental controllers. A TRACON is a radar facility that handles planes near busy airports. F&E (Facilities and Equipment) is the FAA’s capital account. The FAA Telecommunications Infrastructure (FTI) is the network, run by the contractor L3Harris since 2002, that carries radar and radio data between FAA sites. DOGE is the Department of Government Efficiency, the cost-cutting team Elon Musk led in 2025. Fiscal years (FY) end on September 30. Dollar figures are nominal (not adjusted for inflation) unless labelled “FY2026 dollars, CPI-U.” Real figures use the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers averaged over each fiscal year, the deflator this series uses throughout; the GDP price index is the usual alternative for federal spending.
The FAA on day one (2025-01-20)
- No confirmed Administrator. Mike Whitaker, confirmed in October 2023 to a five-year term, told employees on 2024-12-12 that he would step down on 2025-01-20, and did. (Source: FAA General Statements, entry of 2024-12-12; CNBC, 2024-12-12) Chris Rocheleau, a 22-year FAA veteran, led the agency as acting Administrator from 2025-01-20; President Trump formally named him acting Administrator by memo on 2025-01-30. The FAA’s own officials page lists him as acting Administrator, with Chief Counsel Liam McKenna as acting Deputy, by 2025-03-19. (Source: CBS News, January 2025; DroneLife, 2025-01-30; FAA Key Officials page, captures 2024-12-20 to 2025-03-19)
- A new Secretary. The Senate confirmed Sean Duffy as Secretary of Transportation 77 to 22 on 2025-01-28. (Source: DOT, “Sean Duffy Sworn In as Secretary,” 2025-01-28)
- Controllers (end FY2024, counted 2024-09-21). 13,774 controllers at facilities: 10,730 CPCs, 953 CPC-ITs and 2,091 developmentals, plus 487 students at the FAA Academy. The FAA hired 1,811 in FY2024 against a goal of 1,800 and lost 1,400. The CPC target the FAA and the controllers’ union had set together was 14,633, so CPCs were 3,903 short of it (computed). (Source: FAA, Air Traffic Controller Workforce Plan 2025-2028, posted 2025-08-21)
- Workforce. The Office of Personnel Management (OPM) counted 46,461 FAA employees in December 2024 and 46,366 in January 2025 (people, not full-time equivalents). (Source: OPM federal workforce data, FAA unit TD:TD03, retrieved 2026-11-17)
- Equipment. GAO had found 51 of the FAA’s 138 air traffic control systems (37 percent) unsustainable and 54 more potentially unsustainable, with action “urgently needed.” (Source: GAO-24-107001, 2024-09-23) DOT later described the FTI network as relying on 1960s-era time-division multiplexing (TDM, an older way of carrying voice and data over copper lines) across more than 30,000 services at 4,600 sites; a major carrier’s July 2024 notice put 33 percent of the airspace system’s services at risk of early discontinuance. (Source: DOT/FAA, Brand New Air Traffic Control System Plan, May 2025) Verizon held a 2023 contract, valued at $2.4 billion over 15 years, to build the FTI’s replacement. (Source: Reuters via Yahoo Finance, 2025-03-11; Part 2 of this series)
- Money. FY2025 was running on continuing resolutions. The FY2024 enacted level, the last full fiscal year before the term, was $20,083.3 million nominal ($21,320.4 million in FY2026 dollars, CPI-U) across Operations, F&E, Research, Engineering and Development (RE&D) and the Airport Improvement Program. The FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024 authorized programs through FY2028. (Source: FAA FY2027 Congressional Justification, Ten-Year Tables, 2026-04-03; CRS IF12791, 2024-10-23, as recorded in Part 2)
- Safety. FY2024 ended with 1,758 runway incursions, 9 of them serious (Category A or B), and a commercial air carrier fatality rate of 0.01 per 100 million persons on board. (Source: DOT OIG AV2025026, 2025-03-12; FAA FY2024 Performance and Accountability Report, as recorded in Part 2)
- Open problems. The FAA had capped Boeing 737 MAX production after the 2024 Alaska Airlines door-plug blowout (38 a month, per CNBC), with 16 inspector general recommendations on Boeing oversight open. (Source: CNBC, 2024-11-07; DOT OIG AV2025002, 2024-10-09) Staffing relief was in force at Reagan National (DCA), JFK and LaGuardia since 2023, and control of Newark’s approach airspace had moved from New York TRACON to Philadelphia in July 2024. (Source: Federal Register 2026-12593, 2026-06-23; CNBC (Reuters), 2025-08-08) GAO’s list of priority open recommendations to DOT as a whole stood at 20 in June 2024. (Source: GAO-25-108054, as recorded in Part 2) GAO’s later count of 50 open recommendations to the FAA is dated 2025-05-15, four months into the term. (Source: GAO-25-108502, 2025-05-15)
Leadership and management
| Role | Person | Dates | How held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Secretary of Transportation | Sean Duffy | 2025-01-28 to present | Confirmed 77-22 |
| Administrator | Chris Rocheleau | 2025-01-20 to 2025-07-09 (named by memo 2025-01-30) | Acting |
| Administrator | Bryan Bedford, former Republic Airways chief executive | Confirmed 2025-07-09; the FAA lists him from 2025-07-10 | Confirmed 53-43 |
| Deputy Administrator | Liam McKenna (Chief Counsel) | listed 2025-03-19, while Rocheleau was acting Administrator | Acting |
| Deputy Administrator | Chris Rocheleau | listed by 2025-08-20 to 2026-07-30 (departure date single-source) | Appointment type not documented |
| Deputy Administrator | Liam McKenna | listed by 2026-10-22 | Acting |
| Chief Operating Officer, Air Traffic Organization | Tim Arel; then Franklin McIntosh | Arel to 2025 (early retirement announced 2025-04-09); McIntosh acting by 2025-08-20, permanent by 2026-04-14 | Arel: four decades at the agency (CBS); McIntosh: not documented |
| Associate Administrator, Commercial Space | Kelvin Coleman; then vacant | Coleman left by deferred resignation (reported 2025-04-28); post vacant on every capture from 2025-08-20 to 2026-10-22 | — |
| Acting Chief Technology Officer | Rebecca Guy | in post by 2026-01-29 | Acting |
Sources: DOT, 2025-01-28; CBS News, January 2025; DroneLife, 2025-01-30; ABC News and Politico, 2025-07-09; FAA testimony of Bryan Bedford, 2026-05-19; FAA Key Officials page, captures 2024-12-20 to 2026-10-22; CBS News, 2025-04-09; SpaceNews, 2025-04-28; AeroCorner (Rocheleau’s departure date, single source); FAA ATO leadership page, updated 2026-01-29.
- 171 days without a Senate-confirmed Administrator in office (2025-01-20 to 2025-07-10), 25.7 percent of the 666 days from the start of the term to 2026-11-17 (computed). Parts 1 and 2 count to the day the confirmed Administrator took office; counted to the confirmation vote instead, it is 170 days (25.5 percent). The White House nominated Bedford 56 days into the term (2025-03-17), and the Senate confirmed him 114 days later (computed). At his hearing on 2025-06-11 he named budget predictability, staffing, aging facilities and obsolete telecommunications as the agency’s persistent problems. (Source: CNBC, 2025-03-17; S.Hrg. 119-254, 2025-06-11) Some Democrats opposed him over his refusal to commit to the 1,500-hour pilot training rule. (Source: Politico, 2025-07-09)
- Senior turnover. The FAA’s own officials page shows that 3 of 10 top posts were vacant or held by an acting official for more than 180 days at some point in 2025-2026 (Commercial Space; Security and Hazardous Materials Safety; Finance and Management). At the cutoff, one (Commercial Space) still was. The ATO and commercial space heads left through the department’s voluntary buyout programs. (Source: FAA Key Officials captures, as tabulated in the FAA Agency Damage Assessment draft, 2026-11-17)
- Reorganization. On 2026-01-26 Duffy and Bedford announced what DOT called “the largest in the agency’s history”: a new Aviation Safety Management System organization centralizing safety management formerly spread across five lines of business, an Airspace Modernization Office, an Office of Advanced Aviation Technologies, and finance, IT and HR consolidated under the Administrator. DOT said it “will not result in reductions in force.” (Source: DOT/FAA, 2026-01-27) On 2026-09-17 an FAA order let the new Safety Management Office build one agency-wide safety management system. (Source: FAA General Statements, entry of 2026-09-17) The Office of NextGen ended on 2025-12-31 under the 2024 Act. (Source: FAA, NextGen Final Report 2025)
- Vacancies at the cutoff. The FAA’s page of 2026-10-22 lists the Airspace Modernization assistant administrator, the Chief Administrative Officer and the Commercial Space associate administrator as “Vacant,” and the Deputy Administrator as acting. (Source: FAA Key Officials, last updated 2026-10-22)
- An ethics question. On 2026-02-05 Sens. Maria Cantwell, Tammy Duckworth and Ed Markey asked DOT whether Bedford had sold his Republic Airways shares; Bedford had said in December 2025 that he had not divested but would keep recusing himself from matters affecting the airline. Cantwell said his ethics agreement required divestment by 2025-10-07. This is a complaint by senators, not a finding; no outcome is on file. (Source: Reuters via Yahoo Finance, 2026-02-05)
Stated priorities
- Hiring. In February 2025 Duffy announced a campaign to “supercharge” controller hiring, followed by a hiring package on 2025-05-01 and updated workforce plans on 2025-08-07 that call for at least 8,900 new controllers through 2028. (Source: CBS News, 2025-02; FAA, 2025-05-01; FAA, 2025-08-07)
- A new system. On 2025-05-08 Duffy unveiled a plan to build a “brand new, state-of-the-art air traffic control system.” (Source: FAA, 2025-05-08) In May 2026 Bedford told senators the FAA would be “replacing all our obsolete equipment over the next three years.” (Source: FAA, testimony of Bryan Bedford, 2026-05-19)
- Hiring standards. A presidential memorandum of 2025-01-21, “Keeping Americans Safe in Aviation,” said the prior administration “sought to specifically recruit and hire individuals with serious infirmities.” FactCheck.org found the FAA disability-hiring page it relied on dated to at least 2013 and had stayed online through Trump’s first term. (Source: FactCheck.org, 2025-01-31)
- A smaller support staff. The department offered deferred resignation (“buyouts”) in 2025. According to Government Executive, Duffy called it “not a scalpel,” and Rocheleau told a town hall “we will be leaner in a year, in two years.” Controllers and systems technicians were not eligible. (Source: Government Executive, 2025-05-15)
- Transparency. On 2026-05-22 DOT launched a “Modern Skies” website tracking more than 10,000 modernization projects. Duffy: “One of the reasons past air traffic control modernization efforts failed was a lack of transparency.” (Source: DOT, 2026-05-22)
Budget requests and appropriations
All figures are $ million. “Total” is Operations, F&E, RE&D and the Airport Improvement Program obligation limit, plus any general-fund airport grants, on the FAA’s own basis. It excludes the infrastructure law’s advance appropriations and the 2025 reconciliation money, shown separately below. “Real” means FY2026 dollars, CPI-U (deflators: FY2024 1.0616, FY2025 1.0336, FY2026 1.0000).
| FY | Request (released) | Request total, nominal | Enacted (date, law) | Enacted total, nominal | Enacted total, real | F&E nominal | F&E real |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 (start-year) | 2023-03-09 (Biden) | 19,807.8 | 2024-03-09, P.L. 118-42 | 20,083.3 | 21,320.4 | 3,191.3 | 3,387.8 |
| 2025 | 2024-03-11 (Biden) | 20,803.4 | 2025-03-15, P.L. 119-4 (full-year continuing resolution) | 20,989.0 | 21,694.2 | 3,176.3 | 3,283.0 |
| 2026 (latest full year) | 2025-05 (overview early May, detail end May) | 22,007.0 | 2026-02-03, P.L. 119-75 | 22,208.7 (22,577.4 with an infrastructure-law transfer) | 22,208.7 | 4,000.0 | 4,000.0 |
| 2027 | 2026-04-03 | 22,356.6 | Not enacted; continuing resolution to 2026-12-11 (P.L. 119-103, signed 2026-09-02) | n/a | n/a | (CR rate 4,000.0) | n/a |
Operations, nominal: 12,729.6 (FY2024), 13,482.8 (FY2025), 13,710.0 (FY2026); RE&D 280.0, 280.0, 290.0. Source: FAA FY2027 Congressional Justification, Ten-Year Tables, 2026-04-03; CRS R48728; CRS R49341, 2026-09-03; CRS R49353, 2026-09-17; Congress.gov, H.R. 7148; real values computed with the series’ CPI-U fiscal-year deflator (BLS series CUUR0000SA0, extracted 2026-11-17).
- Annual funding rose, less after inflation. From FY2024 to FY2026 the enacted total rose 10.6 percent nominal and 4.2 percent real; F&E rose 25.3 percent nominal and 18.1 percent real; Operations rose 7.7 percent nominal and 1.5 percent real, and fell 1.6 percent in real terms from FY2025 to FY2026 (computed, FY2026 dollars, CPI-U). Congress enacted more than requested in both term years, by $185.6 million (FY2025, whose request was the previous administration’s) and $201.7 million (FY2026), nominal. (Source: FAA FY2027 Congressional Justification, as compiled in the series research)
- The FY2026 request sought a 26 percent rise in F&E and a 41 percent cut to RE&D against FY2025; Congress enacted RE&D at $290 million against the $165 million requested. (Source: CRS R48596; CRS R48728) The FY2027 request again proposes $165 million, 43 percent below the FY2026 enacted level (computed). (Source: FAA FY2027 Congressional Justification, 2026-04-03)
- The reconciliation law. P.L. 119-21, signed 2025-07-04 (called the “One Big Beautiful Bill Act” by CRS and the “Working Families Tax Cut Act” by DOT), appropriated $12.52 billion for air traffic control improvements, available to 2029-09-30: $4.75 billion for telecommunications, $3.0 billion for radar replacement, $0.5 billion for runway safety technology and other items. It also rescinded $233.9 million in unobligated research balances. The $12.52 billion is FY2025 money: about $12.94 billion in FY2026 dollars, CPI-U (computed). (Source: P.L. 119-21, 2025-07-04; FAA FY2027 Congressional Justification) With it, the FAA’s FY2025 financial report puts FY2025 enacted funding at $38.5 billion, up 53.5 percent on FY2024. (Source: FAA FY2025 Agency Financial Report)
- Other totals use other bases. CRS gives about $27.2 billion for FY2026 “enacted FAA funding,” which includes infrastructure-law money, and $18,577 million in another table that counts discretionary accounts only. (Source: CRS R48947; CRS R48728) Each is right on its own basis; they are not comparable with each other or with the table above.
- Funding lapses. A government-wide lapse in appropriations, which takes both Congress and the President to end, ran 43 days, 2025-10-01 to 2025-11-12, then the longest on record; a second gap ran three days, 2026-01-31 to 2026-02-03. A 75-day lapse in 2026 covered only the Department of Homeland Security; it did not stop FAA operations, though it held up the $140 million controller raise carried in the DHS bill until 2026-04-30. (Source: CRS R49491, 2026-10-22; Government Executive, 2026-02; Duckworth and Durbin letter, 2026-09-04)
- The ask for more. Bedford, 2025-12-04: the reconciliation law “gave us a strong $12.5 billion down payment… we’re going to need another $20 billion.” (Source: FAA, 2025-12-04) An OMB-DOT letter dated 2026-11-12 asked appropriators for $30 billion more; Sen. Eric Schmitt’s Modern Skies Act (September 2026) carries the same figure. After the ground stop Duffy asked for $50 billion. (Source: CNN live coverage, 2026-11-14; ABC News, 2026-11-16) GAO says the program’s second phase alone needs about $10.2 billion more, excluding facilities. (Source: GAO-26-107992, 2026-09-14)
Modernization: programs, contracts, progress
- The Brand New Air Traffic Control System (BNATCS). Phase 1 replaces communications, surveillance, weather and training equipment and is due by December 2028; Phase 2, new automation, has no start date. (Source: GAO-26-107992, 2026-09-14)
- What GAO found. The FAA has no comprehensive life-cycle cost estimate (its June 2026 estimates were unsupported and left out government costs, most Phase 1 operating costs and all of Phase 2) and no integrated master schedule: it tracks 11,389 separate project schedules. “FAA is buying delivery speed at the risk of cost uncertainty.” Two recommendations; DOT partially concurred with both. (Source: GAO-26-107992, 2026-09-14)
- Pace of obligation. As of March 2026 the FAA had obligated $1,780 million of about $9,030 million in Phase 1 appropriations, 19.7 percent (computed from GAO’s Figure 4). (Source: GAO-26-107992, 2026-09-14) In November 2026 Reps. Rick Larsen and André Carson said $4.3 billion had been obligated and $1 billion spent; DOT says “every dollar of the $12.5 billion… is accounted for” and “will all be deployed by the end of 2028.” The two measure different things, and neither was checked against spending records. (Source: CNN live coverage, 2026-11-14; DOT, 2026-11-15)
- Copper to fiber. GAO counted 2,560 of 5,170 copper lines replaced with fiber as of May 2026 (49.5 percent, computed). The FAA’s Modern Skies dashboard showed 3,473 (67 percent) on 2026-09-30, with digital voice switches at 211 of 450 (47 percent) and radio sites at 451 of 1,581 (29 percent); analog protocol converters, at 186 of 2,696, were the one program behind plan. (Source: GAO-26-107992, 2026-09-14; FAA Modern Skies dashboard as read by California Today, 2026-11-13) DOT’s own list on 2026-11-15: 70 percent of copper lines replaced, surface awareness at 143 towers, electronic flight strips at 25 towers and nine new surface movement radars. These are agency self-reports, not audits. No count of fiber-converted lines at the start of the term was found, and L3Harris’s conversion work on its own network partly predates the 2025 money, so the share converted during this term is not established. (Source: DOT, 2026-11-15; Part 2 of this series)
- NOTAM. The replacement Notice to Air Missions system, built by CGI Federal, began operating on 2025-09-29. (Source: FAA, “Duffy Deploys Brand New ‘Notice to Airmen’ System,” 2025-09)
- Verizon and Starlink. See “DOGE and the FAA” below. In March 2025 Duffy said Verizon was “not moving fast enough”: “I can’t wait 10 years or 12 years to lay fiber.” (Source: Reuters via Yahoo Finance, 2025-03-11) In July 2025 Duffy said more than 90 percent of the telecom money would replace copper with fiber, and that carriers had agreed to stop charging about $800 million a year in copper obsolescence fees. (Source: Reuters via Yahoo Finance, 2025-07-16)
Major contracts and programs in the term
| Program | Award | Vendor | Value as reported | Status at the cutoff | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BNATCS prime integrator | Announced 2025-12-04 | Peraton | $1.5 billion ceiling; about $876 million negotiated price, per the FAA to GAO | Phase 1 under way | FAA, 2025-12-04; GAO-26-107992, 2026-09-14 |
| Radar System Replacement | 2026-01-05 | Collins Aerospace (RTX) | $438 million | Replaces up to 612 ground radars (FLYING) | RTX release, 2026-01-05; FLYING, 2026-03-04 |
| SMART traffic-flow tool | Signed 2026-06-23 | Air Space Intelligence | $875.95 million ceiling; about $23.3 million obligated | Live in Washington 2026-09-21; all 22 centers announced 2026-11-10 | Citizen Analyst, FAA SMART: What the AI Air Traffic Planning System Is, and What It Is Not, 2026-11-13; FAA General Statements, 2026-11-10 |
| NOTAM Management Service | Order 2025-09-30 | CGI Federal | $67.8 million order ceiling; IDIQ reported at $275 million (aggregator) | Operating since 2025-09-29 | GovTribe; Orange Slices, 2025-11-19 |
| Common Automation Platform | Proposals requested 2025-11 | not awarded as of 2026-03-04 | n/a | Duffy said in November 2025 the $12.5 billion does not cover it | FLYING, 2026-03-04 |
| FTI network (legacy) | 2002 | L3Harris (formerly Harris) | n/a | Converting sites to fiber; “more than 70%” done, per L3Harris | L3Harris, 2026-11-14 |
| FENS (FTI replacement) | 2023 | Verizon | $2.4 billion over 15 years | Not cancelled | Reuters via Yahoo Finance, 2025-07-16 |
Contract obligations by award could not be retrieved for this series (the USAspending query tool failed).
Staffing
| Date | CPCs | Staffing target (definition) | Trainees (CPC-IT + developmentals) | Hires in FY (goal) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| End FY2024 (2024-09-21; start-year) | 10,730 | 14,633 CPCs (joint FAA-union target) | 3,044 | 1,811 (1,800) | FAA Workforce Plan 2025-2028 |
| End FY2025 (latest full year) | 10,693 | 14,633 CPCs (until the 2026 plan) | 3,530 | 2,028 (2,000, set in 2024) | FAA Workforce Plan 2026-2028 |
| 2026-03-07 | almost 11,000 (of about 14,500 controllers) | n/a | n/a | n/a | DOT OIG AV2026031, 2026-06-24 |
| April 2026 | about 11,000 | 12,563 total staffing (new Controller Equivalent Workforce model; not a CPC count) | about 4,000 (about 1,000 of them already certified, retraining) | n/a | FAA, 2026-05-15 |
| FY2026 | n/a | 12,563 total staffing (as above) | n/a | 2,235 (2,200) | FAA, 2026-10-01 |
- Certified controllers were flat. From end FY2024 to end FY2025, CPCs fell by 37 (-0.3 percent), while controllers at facilities rose from 13,774 to 14,223 (+449, +3.3 percent) and trainees rose by 486 (+16.0 percent) (computed). The net gain was in trainees. (Source: FAA Controller Workforce Plans 2025-2028 and 2026-2028)
- Hiring rose: the most since 2008, then a record. The FAA hired 2,028 trainees in FY2025, the most since 2008 (GAO and DOT count 2,026), against a goal of 2,000 set in 2024; about the first 16 weeks of that fiscal year fell before the term. It hired 2,235 in FY2026, the first fiscal year wholly in the term and, by the FAA’s own series, “the most in FAA history” (FY2017 had 1,880), after a recruiting campaign drew more than 12,000 qualified applicants in 24 hours. More than 1,300 trainees graduated from the Academy in FY2026. (Source: FAA Workforce Plan 2026-2028; DOT, 2025-09-23; FAA, 2026-10-01) Academy starting pay rose nearly 30 percent and a retention bonus kept “nearly 400” retirement-eligible controllers. (Source: FAA Workforce Plan 2026-2028)
- The target was cut. The 2026-2028 plan sets a total staffing target of 12,563, down from the 14,633 joint target, after adopting a new staffing model (it lowered the controller availability factor from 2.14 to 1.87) following a Transportation Research Board review required by the 2024 Act. The FAA says it uses “modern staffing models and scheduling tools.” (Source: FAA Workforce Plan 2026-2028; CNN, 2026-05-15) The two targets measure different things: 14,633 counts CPCs only, while 12,563 is a total staffing target under a new metric. The CPC count cannot be compared with 12,563, and no shortfall against the new target is computed here.
- Overtime and time on position. FY2025 controller overtime was 7.3 percent of hours, the highest in decades (about 2.1 percent in 2008 to 2011); time on position per eight-hour shift fell from about 4.68 hours in 2008 to 4.01 in 2025. (Source: CRS R49491, 2026-10-22, citing the 2026-2028 plan) The plan aims to raise productive hours a shift from four to five. (Source: CBS News, September 2026)
- Training bottlenecks. DOT’s Inspector General found the FAA “still faces challenges” meeting on-the-job training goals: supplemental pay for trainers raised instruction costs 160 percent while training hours rose less than 20 percent, and most facilities missed their hourly targets. (Source: DOT OIG AV2026031, 2026-06-24) It opened an audit of the Academy on 2026-02-05, citing instructor shortages, capacity limits and high failure rates after the record class. (Source: DOT OIG, 2026-02-05) Contract towers still have “staffing shortages.” (Source: DOT OIG AV2026022, 2026-03-24) GAO found the FAA has no performance goals for recruiting, hiring or training. (Source: GAO-26-107320, 2025-12-17)
- The count dispute. GAO counted 13,164 controllers at facilities at end FY2025, “about 6 percent” fewer than the 14,007 of FY2015; the FAA’s own plan gives 14,223 for what appears to be the same definition. The gap is unexplained. This article uses the FAA’s series. (Source: GAO-26-107320, 2025-12-17; FAA Workforce Plan 2026-2028)
- Pay. A spring 2026 law provided $140 million for a 3.8 percent controller raise, conditioned on the FAA finding “improvements in workforce scheduling, staffing utilization, or other operational efficiencies.” Controllers first received only the 1 percent government-wide raise; on 2026-09-04 Sens. Duckworth and Dick Durbin wrote that Bedford had “failed to implement” it, and CBS reported they accused him of holding the raise “hostage.” The FAA said Congress had made it contingent. On 2026-10-16 the FAA and the National Air Traffic Controllers Association (NATCA) announced the release of the remaining 2.8 percent, retroactive to the start of the year, tied to badge-in timekeeping, workload-based shift guidelines and reassignment to the worst-short facilities. (Source: Duckworth and Durbin letter, 2026-09-04; CBS News, September 2026; FAA, 2026-10-16)
- The wider workforce. OPM counts the FAA at 44,549 people in September 2026, down 1,912 or 4.1 percent from 46,461 in December 2024. From January 2025 to September 2026 there were 8,197 separations (2,017 flagged as deferred resignations, 2,853 retirements, none coded as a reduction in force) and 6,471 accessions. By occupation, air traffic control positions rose 5.6 percent and transportation specialists (systems technicians) 6.0 percent; aviation safety staff fell 1.9 percent and engineers 12.0 percent; attorneys fell 30.5 percent, aeronautical-information staff 21.8 percent and the executive pay plan 29.2 percent (195 to 138). (Source: OPM data as tallied in the FAA Agency Damage Assessment draft, 2026-11-17)
- Probationary firings: who and how many. Probationary employees (people still in their first year or two of federal service) received dismissal notices from the evening of 2025-02-14 into 2025-02-15, from a non-.gov email address, according to the union PASS and an employee quoted by ABC News. (Source: PASS, 2025-02-15, updated 2025-02-18; ABC News, 2025-02-21) A second FAA union gave a sworn account of the same notices. Daniel Ronneberg, president of the FAA Employees Union, Local 1653 (AFSCME District Council 20), which represents over 2,000 non-supervisory FAA employees, mostly at headquarters, stated in a declaration filed on 2025-02-23 in AFGE v. OPM (N.D. Cal., 3:25-cv-01780) that members began telling him of the notices on Saturday 2025-02-15. He said the email arrived between midnight and 2:00 a.m., gave the termination as effective 2025-02-14 and said “based on your performance, you have not demonstrated that your further employment at the DOT FAA would be in the public interest”; that the union had no advance notice; and that “at least” 45 probationary members of his bargaining unit had been terminated, among them attorneys, economists, data scientists and management and program analysts. The 45 is a union count for a different bargaining unit from PASS’s 132, and the declaration is a plaintiff’s exhibit, not an FAA or DOT filing. (Source: Ronneberg declaration, AFGE v. OPM, ECF 18-17, 2025-02-23) On 2025-02-17 Duffy said “fewer than 400” had been let go and the White House press secretary said no air traffic controllers or “professionals who perform safety critical functions” were terminated. (Source: The Air Current, 2025-02-18) On 2025-02-24 Duffy put the FAA number at 352 of about 46,000 (0.8 percent, computed) and said “we kept all the critical safety positions.” These are the administration’s figures. (Source: The Hill, 2025-02-24) PASS said 132 of its members were dismissed (its own page says 132; MeriTalk and The Air Current say 133), in nine occupations including aviation safety assistants, maintenance mechanics, legal instruments examiners, aeronautical information specialists and telecommunications specialists; by its breakdown 59 worked in Technical Operations, 39 in Flight Standards, 19 in mission support and 15 in air traffic services. PASS estimated about 400 in all but said it had no firsthand data on employees outside its membership. (Source: PASS, 2025-02-18; The Air Current, 2025-02-18; MeriTalk, 2025-02) PASS also said 18 air traffic control facilities lost maintenance mechanics and 26 aviation safety assistants were cut, each typically supporting about 10 safety inspectors; that is the union’s characterization of the effect. (Source: Associated Press, 2025-02-19) The FAA’s own plan for its systems technicians (Airway Transportation Systems Specialists, ATSS) says none was terminated as a probationer and none was eligible for the deferred resignation program. (Source: FAA, ATSS Workforce Plan 2026-2030, 2026-05-15) The FAA says no probationary controllers were dismissed. (Source: FAA Workforce Plan 2026-2028) House Transportation and Oversight Democrats, led by Reps. Larsen and Connolly, wrote Duffy on 2025-03-03 that about 400 had been fired, asked for the policy memos, the definition of “safety critical” and counts by job by 2025-03-17, and said their understanding was that the firings reached Aviation Safety, Flight Standards, the Office of Airports and the Air Traffic Organization, among others. No reply was found. (Source: House T&I and Oversight Democrats, letter, 2025-03-03)
- Probationary firings: what reversed them. PASS said the FAA was reinstating the 132 employees it represents, with back pay from 2025-02-15 and the dismissal letters expunged, with a return to duty on 2025-03-20, and that “the agency is complying with a Maryland court ruling.” A federal judge in Maryland had granted a temporary restraining order on 2025-03-13 in a suit by states; the Transportation Department was not among the agencies covered by a separate California order. (Source: PASS, 2025-03-17; Clearinghouse, Maryland v. USDA, 2025-03; Federal News Network, 2025-03) DOT’s own counts are in two sworn declarations by Anne Byrd, DOT’s Assistant Secretary for Administration and chief human capital officer, filed in Maryland v. USDA (D. Md., 1:25-cv-00748), where DOT and Duffy are named defendants: ECF 52-1 (2025-03-17) and ECF 103-1 (2025-03-25). Byrd swore that DOT terminated about 788 probationary employees between 2025-02-14 and 2025-02-24, and that 775 of them were “Affected Probationary Employees” covered by the court’s restraining order. On 2025-03-17 DOT told all 775 that it was rescinding their terminations, with back pay from 2025-02-15; they returned to duty on 2025-03-20. As of 2025-03-24, 92 of the 775 had resigned and the other 683 were on active duty or on voluntary leave. Of the other 13 of the 788, two were terminated on “individualized performance-based determinations,” eight had their terminations rescinded before the order, two resigned and one took the deferred resignation program. So “all 775” means all but 13 of about 788. Byrd took her post on 2025-02-25, so her counts come from records, not from the events of 02-14. Neither declaration gives an FAA-only figure, so the FAA’s share of the 788, the 775 and the 92 is not in the record. (Source: Byrd declarations, ECF 52-1 and ECF 103-1, D. Md., 2025-03-17 and 2025-03-25) A Merit Systems Protection Board final order of 2026-10-29 later recited the same account, saying DOT “rescinded all 775 probationary terminations effected in February 2025.” (Source: MSPB final order, CB-1205-25-0027-R-1, 2026-10-29) The court orders did not last: a Maryland injunction of 2025-04-01 was stayed by the Fourth Circuit on 2025-04-09, and on 2025-09-08 that court held the states lacked standing and sent the case back for dismissal. In 2026 the Board twice declined a regulation-review request for DOT probationers, the second time on 2026-10-29, because DOT had rescinded the terminations and paid back pay. No record was found that the FAA fired anyone again. (Source: Federal News Network, 2025-04-09; Justia, State of Maryland v. USDA, 4th Cir., 2025-09-08; MSPB final order, 2026-10-29)
- “Safety-critical” has no single definition. DOT’s Inspector General found on 2026-09-16 that the FAA has no uniform, agency-wide definition of “safety-critical”; definitions vary by office. The FAA uses four classes (Safety-Critical, Mission Critical, Public Safety and Mission Support), and the Public Safety and Mission Support classes “were introduced in 2025 to identify positions that would be exempt from the Deferred Resignation Program.” It also found that 10,808 employees (nearly a quarter of 44,979, as of 2025-12-27) in the Mission Critical or Public Safety classes are covered by no mandated workforce plan. The finding answers the question the House Democrats asked in March 2025, and it means the Secretary’s statement that safety positions were kept and the union’s statement that “all of these employees are critical” each use a label the agency does not define uniformly. (Source: DOT OIG, AV2026035, 2026-09-16; PASS, 2025-02-15)
- Did the FAA analyse what the cuts did to safety? At a Senate Commerce hearing on 2025-05-14 (S. Hrg. 119-144), Sen. Markey asked three FAA officials how many people in their offices had taken the buyout or been fired as probationers. None gave a number: Jodi Baker (aviation safety), “I do not have those numbers at this time”; Franklin McIntosh (deputy chief operating officer, Air Traffic Organization, ATO), “We will not have that number until after everyone has time to either accept or decline.” Asked whether they had done an internal analysis of the effect on safety, Wayne Heibeck, deputy associate administrator for Airports, said: “Yes. We have done an internal analysis.” McIntosh said: “No, sir. We have not done an internal analysis. … the largest number of our individuals are safety-exempt employees.” Baker said: “At this point we do not have final data.” The FAA’s written answers said staff in critical safety-related positions, including air traffic controllers and NAS technicians, were not eligible for the deferred resignation program. At Bedford’s confirmation hearing on 2025-06-11, Markey asked him to commit to sharing the analysis FAA officials had promised the committee; he answered that he “would review the analysis” and was “committed to ensuring appropriate transparency.” A letter of 2025-07-21 from Markey, Kaine and ten other senators to Bedford says the analysis had still not been provided and asks for the Office of Airports’ analysis. No later production of any analysis was found. These are the officials’ and senators’ own statements. (Source: S. Hrg. 119-144, 2025-05-14; S. Hrg. 119-254, 2025-06-11; Markey, Kaine and ten other senators, letter to Bedford, 2025-07-21)
What the overseers found
| Date | Body | Finding | Recommendations |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2025-03-04 | GAO (GAO-25-108162, testimony) | 2 modernization recommendations fully addressed; risk-mitigation recommendations still open | 9 open |
| 2025-03-11 | NTSB | Urgent: permanently bar helicopter traffic near DCA when runways 15 and 33 are in use, “an intolerable risk” | Urgent recommendations |
| 2025-03-12 | DOT OIG (AV2025026) | FAA “lacks an integrated approach for analyzing runway incursion data” | 5 (0 closed when read) |
| 2025-06-24 | NTSB (AIR-25-04, Alaska 1282) | FAA “was ineffective in ensuring Boeing addressed ‘repetitive and systemic’ nonconformance issues” | New, to FAA and Boeing |
| 2025-07-23 | DOT OIG (AV2025036) | FAA has not tested how sensitive NextGen benefit and cost projections are to outside factors | 1 |
| 2025-07-28 | DOT OIG | Audit opened of the Newark airspace move to Philadelphia | pending |
| 2025-09-29 | DOT OIG (capstone memo) | Two decades of NextGen lessons, for the new system | none |
| 2025-12-17 | GAO (GAO-26-107320) | No goals for controller recruiting, hiring, training | DOT concurred (2026-05-28) |
| 2026-01-27 | NTSB (AIR-26-02, DCA collision) | 74 findings; FAA route design, failure to act on recommendations, safety management | 50 (33 to FAA) |
| 2026-03-24 | DOT OIG (AV2026022) | Contract-tower staffing shortages remain | — |
| 2026-06-24 | DOT OIG (AV2026031) | On-the-job training goals missed | — |
| 2026-07-27 | NTSB chair | DCA recommendations not yet implemented in many respects | — |
| 2026-09-14 | GAO (GAO-26-107992) | Modernization lacks cost estimate and master schedule | 2 open |
| 2026-09-21 | GAO (GAO-26-108439) | Gaps in protecting aircraft communications from spoofing and jamming | 9, all open |
Sources: each body’s report or release on the date shown; DOT OIG library list for the Newark audit; NTSB release dated 2026-01-28 on the 2026-01-27 meeting; NTSB statement, 2026-07-27.
- The DCA report and hiring policy. The NTSB’s probable cause names “the Federal Aviation Administration’s (FAA) placement of a helicopter route in close proximity to a runway approach path,” its failure to review routes and act on recommendations, and the system’s “overreliance on visual separation”; contributing factors include an “unsustainable airport arrival rate” and the FAA’s failure to implement earlier recommendations, including ADS-B In (cockpit traffic display). Finding 10: the tower “was not staffed to its target level,” but the staff on duty “was adequate and in accordance with” FAA directives; finding 11: combining the helicopter and local positions “was not the result of insufficient staffing.” The series research searched the full report text: no finding, cause or recommendation addresses hiring policy, diversity programs, the 2025 hiring freeze or the probationary firings. (Source: NTSB AIR-26-02, adopted 2026-01-27) The chair said “the conditions for this tragedy were in place long before the night of Jan. 29.” (Source: NTSB, 2026-01-27)
- Congress. At a House hearing on 2025-12-16, Ranking Member Larsen said FAA and DOT employment “decreased due to buyouts and pushed safety-critical employees to depart”; Rep. Carson cited “mass firings and forced buyouts that have hollowed out the Agency’s ranks.” The committee majority said it would oversee the $12.5 billion “to ensure we avoid the absolute disaster that was NextGen.” (Source: House T&I Democrats, 2025-12-16; House T&I Committee, 2025-12-16) At a Senate hearing the next day Sen. Duckworth backed at least $20 billion more but said the FAA had not produced “a comprehensive plan with measurable outcomes and concrete milestones.” (Source: S.Hrg. 119-409, 2025-12-17)
- Priority recommendations. GAO’s open priority recommendations to DOT as a whole numbered 20 in June 2024 (before the term), 21 in June 2025 and 22 in June 2026, with 204 open recommendations to DOT in June 2026. An FAA-only count at the cutoff was not found. (Source: GAO-25-108054; GAO-26-109050)
Safety and performance over the term
Fatal accidents involving U.S. airspace and the FAA
| Date | Event | Deaths | Status at the cutoff |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2025-01-29 | American Eagle 5342 (PSA CRJ700) and an Army UH-60L collide over the Potomac near DCA | 67 | NTSB final report adopted 2026-01-27 |
| 2025-11-04 | UPS 2976, an MD-11F cargo jet, crashes after takeoff at Louisville | 14 fatal injuries under the NTSB’s 30-day definition (3 crew, 11 on the ground); one more person died 51 days later | Investigation open; NTSB hearing 2026-05-19 and 20 |
| 2026-03-22 | Air Canada Express 8646 (a Jazz CRJ-900) strikes a fire truck after landing at LaGuardia | 2 (both pilots) | Investigation open |
Sources: NTSB, 2026-01-27; NTSB DCA26MA024 investigative update; NTSB, 2026-05-12; FAA statements on accidents and incidents; Reuters via Investing.com, 2026-03-23.
- DCA was the deadliest U.S. aviation accident since November 2001. The FAA’s FY2025 financial report says its commercial fatality target “was not met due to” it. (Source: NTSB, 2026-01-27; FAA FY2025 Agency Financial Report) After it the FAA restricted helicopter flights near DCA, closed part of the helicopter route and in January 2026 issued an interim final rule limiting two runways when helicopters operate. (Source: Eno Center for Transportation, 2026-01-30) In May 2025 the FAA halted Army helicopter flights around the Pentagon after a close call forced two airliners to abort landings. (Source: CNBC (Reuters), 2025-07-30)
- Louisville. The left engine and pylon separated after rotation; a bearing race had fatigue cracking. The same part design was the subject of a 2011 Boeing service letter on four earlier failures, which Boeing judged not a safety-of-flight condition. The NTSB is reviewing correspondence between Boeing and the FAA about that letter. The FAA grounded MD-11s by emergency directive on 2025-11-08, four days after the crash. (Source: NTSB DCA26MA024 investigative update; CBS News, 2025-11)
- LaGuardia. Two controllers were on duty; the NTSB chair said that is typical for the late shift but “has long been a concern for the NTSB,” and warned against “pointing fingers at controllers.” The NTSB said runway-collision warning technology did not work during the collision. Current and former controllers told Reuters more staff should have been brought in; the NTSB has made no staffing finding. (Source: Reuters via Investing.com, 2026-03-23; Reuters, 2026-03-24; Reuters, 2026-03-27)
- No annual accident table. The NTSB’s calendar-year Part 121 (airline) accident tables for 2025 and 2026 are published as spreadsheets the series could not read. The table above lists the fatal accidents the research found; it is not a census. The safety rating in Team’s Take therefore rests on the FAA’s own fatality-rate result for FY2025 and the documented accidents, not on NTSB annual counts.
- Boeing. The research for this series found no record, either way, of a change in 2025-2026 to the FAA’s 737 MAX production cap or to the status of the 16 Inspector General recommendations on Boeing oversight. The certification rating does not rest on either.
Runway incursions (fiscal years)
| FY | Total | Serious (A+B) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 1,760 | 22 | DOT OIG AV2025026 |
| 2024 | 1,758 | 9 | DOT OIG AV2025026 |
| 2025 | “just over 1,600” | not available from a primary source | The Air Current, 2026 |
| 2026 (through January) | 498 | n/a | The Air Current, 2026 |
Total incursions in FY2025 fell about 9 percent against FY2024 (computed from “just over 1,600”). The Air Current found no sustained improvement since FY2023. (Source: The Air Current, 2026) A reprint of an AvWeb item reports a 44 percent rise in serious incursions in 2025, which would imply about 13. It relays an FAA notice the series did not read, does not say whether it counts fiscal or calendar years, and falls below this series’ source floor, so it is not used. (Source: Bellanca Aircraft reprint of AvWeb, 2026-08-10) The FAA’s own surface-safety measure, its Commercial Surface Safety Risk Index, was 0.07 in FY2025 against a target of no more than 0.38; no FY2024 value was found, so the index shows the level, not the direction. (Source: FAA FY2025 Agency Financial Report)
Capacity caps and outages
| Date | Event | Source |
|---|---|---|
| 2025-04-28 to 2025-05-19 | Telecommunications and radar outages at Philadelphia TRACON, which handles Newark; controllers took trauma leave | FAA Newark statements; CNN, 2025-05-05 |
| 2025-05-20 / 2025-06-06 | Newark capped at 28 arrivals and 28 departures an hour during runway work, then confirmed through 2025-12-31 | FAA Newark statements |
| 2025-09-25 | Newark limit extended to 2026-10-24 and raised to 72 operations an hour | FAA, 2025-09-25 |
| 2025-11-07 to 2025-11-19 | Emergency order cuts flights at 40 airports during the lapse in appropriations, in steps from 4 percent. Airline cuts ended 2025-11-17; a replacement order kept general-aviation limits until all measures were cancelled 2025-11-19 | FAA, 2025-11-06; CRS R49491 |
| 2026-06-23 | Newark limit extended to 2027-10-30: Area C staffing will “remain level and will not increase significantly” | Federal Register 2026-12589, 2026-06-23 |
| 2026-09-21 | East Coast ground stops after a clipped fiber cable and frequency problems | Futurism, 2026-09-21 |
| 2026-11-13 | Nationwide ground stop, 4 hours 23 minutes | See below |
- During the 2025 lapse in appropriations controllers missed their first full paycheck on 2025-10-28; Duffy said on 2025-11-09 there had been 81 staffing triggers (traffic slowed for lack of controllers) the previous day. Hollywood Burbank’s tower went unstaffed for part of 2025-10-06. (Source: Business Insider, 2025-11; CRS R49491) Airlines for America told senators its members had more than 15,600 staffing-related delays and more than 7,100 staffing-related cancellations, an industry figure. (Source: CRS R49491, quoting S.Hrg. 119-318) Larsen said the flight cuts were made “without adequate coordination with key aviation stakeholders.” (Source: House T&I Democrats, 2025-12-16)
- Airline performance. In 2024 airlines arrived on time 78.10 percent of the time and cancelled 1.4 percent of flights. (Source: BTS, December 2024 Air Travel Consumer Report, as recorded in Part 2) BTS’s full-year 2025 report could not be read for this series, and the 2025 national figures found came only from an advocacy group’s analysis, so they are not used. The system-performance rating in Team’s Take does not rest on BTS. In August 2026, one month, on-time arrivals were 71.53 percent, cancellations 2.00 percent, and delays attributed to the National Aviation System (the FAA’s part) 7.45 percent of flights. (Source: BTS, airline on-time statistics, August 2026) A single month cannot be compared with a full year.
DOGE and the FAA
What is documented or credibly reported
- Arrival. About a week after the DCA collision, Duffy posted that he had “enlisted the brightest minds, including SpaceX engineers” to upgrade air traffic control; Musk wrote that “the @DOGE team will aim to make rapid safety upgrades to the air traffic control system.” (Source: Fox News, 2025-02; The Hill, 2025-02) Musk is SpaceX’s chief executive, and the FAA licenses SpaceX launches.
- Conflict-of-interest objections. Sen. Cantwell, the ranking Democrat on the committee that oversees the FAA, said on 2025-02-06: “It’s a clear conflict of interest.” (Source: CNBC, 2025-02-06) Her letter to Duffy that day, copied to the director of the Office of Government Ethics (OGE) and DOT’s acting inspector general, objected to anyone whose company the government regulates being “involved in anything that affects his personal financial interest.” It did not mention DOGE by name. (Source: Sen. Cantwell, letter to Duffy, 2025-02-06)
- The SpaceX engineers: appointments on the record. DOT’s designated ethics official signed waivers under 18 U.S.C. § 208(b)(1) (a federal conflict-of-interest law; a waiver lets an employee act despite a financial interest) dated 2025-02-17 for three SpaceX senior engineers, Brady Glantz, Theodore Malaska and Thomas Kiernan, each hired as a temporary “special government employee” (SGE, a part-time or short-term federal appointee) “for four days,” unpaid, reporting to the acting Administrator, to “conduct a review of FAA technology including … air traffic control systems.” The waivers say they were “expected to access confidential information regarding the FAA’s Air Traffic Control systems and other systems,” bar them from decisions on federal funding or contracts for SpaceX and from the systems of the FAA’s commercial space office, and cite “the review required by the President.” DOT did not formally consult OGE (“not practicable” given “the exigency”); it notified OGE staff. A continuation dated 2025-02-21 for Malaska says the FAA “has identified a plan to address improvements in its air traffic control systems which necessitates your continued service.” These three appointments are documented in agency memoranda as published by the New York Times; the series did not retrieve them from DOT. A fourth SpaceX engineer, Samuel Smeal, is named by Wired, ProPublica and the Washington Post as holding the same adviser title. His appointment is credibly reported, not documented: no waiver for him is in the record. (Source: DOT Office of General Counsel waivers, 2025-02-17 and 2025-02-21, as published by The New York Times; WIRED, 2025-02-19; The Washington Post, 2025-06-08)
- Access. The first visit was on Monday 2025-02-17. Duffy announced late on Sunday 2025-02-16 that SpaceX employees would go the next day to the FAA’s Air Traffic Control System Command Center in Warrenton, Virginia, to “get a firsthand look at the current system” and learn what controllers like and dislike about their tools; he called such visits by outside companies “routine.” Reuters, Politico and Axios reported the plan on 2025-02-17, and CNBC, carrying Reuters, said that same day that the DOGE team was visiting, according to Duffy. (Source: Politico, 2025-02-17; Reuters, 2025-02-17; CNBC (Reuters), 2025-02-17; Axios, 2025-02-17) On 2025-02-19 acting Administrator Rocheleau told staff that DOGE and teams of “special government employees” would work to “keep the airspace open and safe”; Wired, which viewed the email, reported it said the SGEs had visited the Command Center and the Potomac TRACON. (Source: Politico, 2025-02-19; WIRED, 2025-02-19) Building and account access is on the record. In the week of 2025-06-02, according to the Washington Post, FAA leadership revoked the group’s access to FAA buildings, including a command center in Warrenton, Virginia and the Air Traffic Academy in Oklahoma City, and removed four staffers’ credentials and user accounts in the FAA’s internal computer systems; the four no longer carried the title “senior adviser to the administrator.” (Source: The Washington Post, 2025-06-08, syndicated copy) What data they reached on those systems, and what they changed, is not documented in any source read.
- The sequence. Dismissal notices went out from the evening of 2025-02-14 into 2025-02-15. Duffy announced the SpaceX visit late on Sunday 2025-02-16. The visit to the Command Center took place on Monday 2025-02-17, the day the three waivers were signed and three days after the first notices. Wired, citing anonymous sources, reported that the engineers were “already being onboarded” before the paperwork and that none was fully vetted by the start date; that is a claim about paperwork, not a dated visit. (Source: PASS, 2025-02-15; Politico, 2025-02-17; CNBC (Reuters), 2025-02-17; DOT waivers, 2025-02-17; Politico, 2025-03-03; WIRED, 2025-02-19)
- The firings. The probationary notices began on the evening of 2025-02-14, before the first visit on 2025-02-17 and the DOGE email of 2025-02-19. The administration called the firings part of its efficiency drive; Rocheleau’s email said: “In alignment with the Administration’s goal to make government more efficient, we regrettably had to let go some of our probationary employees.” (Source: Politico, 2025-02-19) No source read shows DOGE choosing which FAA employees were dismissed. A Philadelphia Inquirer headline on 2025-02-27 said firings at the William J. Hughes Technical Center in New Jersey came “at recommendation of Musk’s DOGE”; the part of the article read names no source for that. (Source: The Philadelphia Inquirer, 2025-02-27)
- Were they “DOGE employees”? Rocheleau’s email of 2025-02-19 welcomed “DOGE and the teams of special government employees.” An FAA spokesperson told Rolling Stone on 2025-04-25: “DOGE is not spearheading anything at the FAA, nor are there any DOGE employees at FAA.” Wired, ProPublica and the Washington Post call the SpaceX staff DOGE-linked; the FAA draws a line. The record shows four SpaceX engineers (Glantz, Malaska, Kiernan and Smeal) holding FAA senior-adviser titles for about three and a half months. Whether the label “DOGE employees” fits is a dispute over the word, since the waivers describe a review “required by the President.” (Source: Politico, 2025-02-19; Rolling Stone, 2025-04-25; The Washington Post, 2025-06-08; DOT waivers, 2025-02-17)
- Starlink and Verizon. On 2025-02-24 Musk posted that “The Verizon system is not working and so is putting air travelers at serious risk.” (Source: Sens. Schiff and Duckworth, letter to NASA and FAA, 2025) Bloomberg reported that Musk approved a shipment of 4,000 Starlink terminals to the FAA. The FAA said it “has been considering the use of Starlink since the prior administration to increase reliability at remote sites” and was testing one terminal in Atlantic City and two at “non-safety critical sites” in Alaska. (Source: Fortune, 2025-02-25; CNBC, 2025-02-27) The Washington Post and AP reported the FAA was close to cancelling Verizon’s contract in favor of Starlink; the FAA told CBS News that “no decisions have been made” about a long-term contract. (Source: AP via Yahoo Finance, 2025-02; CBS News, 2025-02) SpaceX said it supplied the kits free. A watchdog, the Campaign Legal Center, asked the Inspector General to investigate. (Source: The Hill, 2025-03)
- The Starlink directive, as reported. Bloomberg reported on 2025-03-05, from two unnamed sources, that Malaska arrived at FAA headquarters with “a directive from his boss Elon Musk”: the agency would start a program to deploy thousands of Starlink terminals, with up to 18 months to get it running, and anyone who impeded it “risked losing their jobs.” This is anonymous sourcing from a single outlet, read in a syndicated copy. (Source: Bloomberg News via TNS, 2025-03-09; Bloomberg, 2025-03-05)
- What the acting Administrator told the Senate (2025-03-27). At a Senate Commerce aviation subcommittee hearing on the NTSB’s preliminary report on the DCA collision (S. Hrg. 119-130; the print does not say whether he was sworn), Sen. Markey asked Rocheleau whether any SpaceX employees were serving as special government employees. Rocheleau: “We had three special government employees from SpaceX. We are only in contact with one at this point. I would make it very clear they did not do any air traffic – they did not plug into any of the equipment. They came in to observe our operations and provided expertise along the lines of software and computer systems.” Asked whether any DOGE employees were involved in the decision to deploy Starlink terminals: “There were no DOGE employees in that decision. Starlink is being tested at a number of our facilities, only tested and not plugged into any air traffic systems.” Asked whether any were involved in deciding on more terminals: “No, sir.” Markey also quoted Musk’s post warning of “single-digit months to catastrophic failure”; Rocheleau did not endorse it: “The existing system is safe.” These are the administration’s statements. His count of three matches the three waivers; Wired, ProPublica and the Washington Post name four, and the record does not say whether Smeal was a special government employee. The printed hearing and its written questions contain no question on the probationary firings. (Source: S. Hrg. 119-130, 2025-03-27)
- “Project Lift.” Rolling Stone reported on 2025-04-25, from three anonymous sources, that DOGE staffers “who are now FAA employees” directed FAA funds to a communications project called “Project Lift,” that employees were made to sign nondisclosure agreements, and that “DOGE staffers … are calling the shots.” The FAA’s spokesperson denied it: “Project Lift was conceived and is managed by federal employees.” The FAA confirmed the project exists “to modernize the FAA’s telecommunications network,” that “current contractors are part of the discussion,” and that “employees routinely sign non-disclosure agreements to avoid conflicts of interest.” Both accounts are claims; neither is documented. (Source: Rolling Stone, 2025-04-25)
- The written denial. On 2025-07-15 Bedford wrote lawmakers that the FAA “is not aware of any effort by SpaceX to assume” the L3Harris or Verizon contracts, had not considered replacing them with SpaceX, and would not use satellite service as the sole communications for safety-critical services. (Source: Reuters via Yahoo Finance, 2025-07-16) The Verizon contract was not cancelled.
- After the ground stop. On 2026-11-16 Musk posted that free Starlinks “were offered to Sec. Duffy, but he said they were not needed. As it turns out, they were.” The FAA had not responded. (Source: Benzinga via Yahoo Finance, 2026-11-16) This is Musk’s claim; the offer is not documented elsewhere.
What is not established
- No source read documents DOGE or SpaceX personnel directing an FAA decision. Activity after February 2025 is dated in the record (the Bloomberg report of 2025-03-05, Rocheleau’s Senate statement of 2025-03-27, the Rolling Stone report of 2025-04-25, the revocation of access in early June 2025), but the Starlink directive and “Project Lift” rest on anonymous sources and the FAA denies both, and the waivers bar the three engineers from SpaceX funding and contract decisions.
- No Inspector General or GAO finding on DOGE’s work at the FAA, or on the Starlink testing, was found. Requests exist: Sen. Cantwell’s letter of 2025-02-06 (copied to OGE and DOT’s acting inspector general); a letter of 2025-02-26 from Sen. Markey to Rocheleau asking whether SpaceX engineers were serving as senior advisers, whether Musk had access to FAA offices or staff, and whether Musk or SpaceX engineers had any role in the Starlink deployment, with answers requested by 2025-04-09; and the Campaign Legal Center’s request of 2025-03-13 that DOT’s acting inspector general investigate whether the FAA’s Starlink decisions were improperly influenced. No response to any of the three was found. The DOT inspector general’s audit list was searched, not browsed page by page, so this is an absence in the record read, not proof that no review exists. (Source: Sen. Cantwell, letter, 2025-02-06; Sen. Markey, press release, 2025-02-26; Campaign Legal Center, 2025-03-13)
- Smeal’s status and the legal basis for the engineers’ service are not documented. No waiver, appointment document, end date or statement by Smeal was found, and none for Glantz or Kiernan beyond the four-day waivers (ProPublica says their appointments were “limited to four days” and that Malaska’s waiver stayed in force for the duration of his tenure). The Washington Post’s account puts all four in adviser titles until about 2025-06-02, and no document read shows the authority for service past four days. (Source: ProPublica DOGE tracker, entries of 2025-03-13; The Washington Post, 2025-06-08; DOT waivers, 2025-02-17 and 2025-02-21)
- Nothing in any document read ties the 2026-11-13 ground stop, the Newark outages of 2025 or the FAA’s discontinuation of five charting products in 2025 to the probationary firings, the deferred resignations or DOGE. Critics have suggested a link for Newark; the causes given by NATCA and Duffy for the 2025-04-28 outage were aging copper telecommunications and a burnt wire. PASS’s statement on the ground stop does not tie it to the 2025 firings. (Source: The Fulcrum, 2025-05-07; PASS, 2026-11-14; charting notices of 2025-05-30 and 2025-08-13 as recorded in Federal Aviation Administration — Agency Damage Assessment, 2026-11-17)
- The deferred resignation program was an administration-wide buyout run by the department, not a DOGE action at the FAA; the series did not find which, if any, FAA departures DOGE shaped.
- Single-source items, kept as leads: The Guardian reported on 2025-04-18 that cuts spared DOT staff who support SpaceX launches; Fast Company, citing The Washington Post, reported that an outside expert panel on air traffic control, commissioned in October 2024, was disbanded weeks after the inauguration. (Source: The Guardian, 2025-04-18; Fast Company, 2026-11)
The FAA Agency Damage Assessment draft scores this record as documented pressure without a documented act. (Source: Federal Aviation Administration — Agency Damage Assessment, D4, 2026-11-17)
The 2026-11-13 ground stop and the competing explanations
What happened, by the official record
- The stop. The FAA’s Command Center stopped departures at all U.S. airports at 3:53 p.m. ET on Friday 2026-11-13 (Advisory 111) and cancelled the stop at 8:16 p.m. ET; the FAA gives 8:15 p.m. That is 4 hours 23 minutes by advisory times. Advisory 120 gave the reason as “communications failure.” (Source: California Today, 2026-11-13, listing the advisories; FAA Q&A, 2026-11-15) It was the first nationwide stop since the January 2023 NOTAM failure, which lasted about two hours. (Source: Fast Company, 2026-11)
- The FAA’s first word named no cause: “communication issues impacting multiple Air Route Traffic Control Centers.” (Source: FAA, 2026-11-13)
- The FAA’s account two days later. Legacy equipment became unstable when data began flooding the FTI network at “1,000 connection attempts every 4 to 5 seconds.” Two possible origins were found: a radio site in El Dorado, Arkansas, where L3Harris was deploying a new router, and a radar site in Amarillo, Texas. L3Harris blocked both and the network stabilized. The broadcasting function was then disabled on all new routers and on more than 60 similar ones. Instability hit 17 of the 22 en route centers and spread to several TRACONs. It was “not a full outage.” About 3,500 aircraft aloft landed safely. (Source: FAA, “Nationwide Ground Stop: Questions and Answers,” 2026-11-15)
- What the FAA ruled out. “No indication that this was a cyberattack.” SMART, the traffic-flow tool, is “not related” and “does not feed information into the air traffic control system.” The stop “is due to the legacy TDM system,” and none of the towers upgraded with the $12.5 billion “went down.” (Source: FAA Q&A, 2026-11-15) Bedford said there was “zero evidence of anything nefarious or AI-related.” (Source: Aviation Week, 2026-11)
- Why it took four hours. Bedford: “Because of our lack of identifying the root cause, we were unwilling to take any risk that this propagation could actually result in a sensor losing connectivity with aircraft.” Technicians took about 45 minutes to identify the source. (Source: CNBC, 2026-11-14; The New York Times, 2026-11-14)
- Size. The FAA says operators cancelled about 12,462 flights on 2026-11-13, 9,082 by major airlines, and that “not all cancellations were directly caused by the nationwide ground stop.” Other counts cover other spans: about 9,159 for Friday (FlightAware, via BankInfoSecurity) and more than 6,000 on Saturday alone (CNN). (Source: FAA Q&A, 2026-11-15; BankInfoSecurity, 2026-11; CNN live coverage, 2026-11-14) They should not be added together.
The competing explanations
| Account | Who says it | What supports it | What is not established |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. A contractor’s router change flooded an old network | FAA; Duffy (“Either through contractor error or a faulty piece of equipment, the router that was being replaced… started flooding other routers”; on 2026-11-15, “We think it was the installation or the router that was the bad actor”) | FAA Q&A; DOT releases of 2026-11-14 and 11-15 | Whether installation, configuration or the device was at fault. The suspect router is being examined at L3Harris’s Florida laboratory with FAA staff; the FBI offered help. No outside review was found |
| 2. The contractor is to blame | Duffy: “What did L3Harris do? Did they make mistakes yesterday?… we’re going to hold people accountable”; Rep. Greg Stanton: the project is behind schedule and “they probably chose the wrong contractor” | L3Harris owns and operates the FTI equipment; a 2009 outage on the same network followed Harris maintenance errors during an earlier fiber change, as a CNN analyst and BankInfoSecurity recount | L3Harris says it is “supporting the FAA in its investigation” and does not say its work caused the stop. Hewlett Packard Enterprise, owner of the router maker Juniper: “our equipment was working as configured.” No root cause is documented |
| 3. Old equipment inherited from past administrations | Trump, 2026-11-16: “Buttigieg ruined the system”; “I don’t take any responsibility.” Duffy: the routers “were purchased in 2001, they were obsolete in 2006”; “I take responsibility for what was given to me by prior administrations” | The FTI dates to 2002; GAO’s 2024 count of unsustainable systems; the FAA calls the failed layer “legacy” | Part 2 of this series tests the claims against Pete Buttigieg. Its verdicts: that the system was “old, known to be failing and slow to modernize on his watch,” supported; that he “ruined” it or made “zero progress,” not supported. The replacement of the FTI was awarded in 2023. Sen. Duckworth’s reply to the administration’s blame: “You’ve literally controlled Congress for the past two years” |
| 4. This administration’s execution of the upgrade | Buttigieg, 2026-11-16: the administration “failed to explain why their execution of it triggered the worst FAA communications breakdown this century”; NY Gov. Kathy Hochul: “serious lapses in our aviation system have become a pattern on Sean Duffy’s watch,” and called for Duffy to resign or be removed | The failing work was part of copper-to-fiber conversion that GAO counts inside the funded rebuild; it took place in the term | The FAA says routine maintenance is distinct from “the FAA’s broader modernization effort.” Both statements fit only if “modernization” means new automation, which the sources do not say. Cause undetermined. A White House spokesperson called Hochul’s demand “a desperate attempt to score political points” |
| 5. Cyberattack or the new AI tool | Online speculation; questions noted by AP | none | Ruled out on the record so far: the FAA, Bedford and DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin (“no indication yet that this was a nefarious attack”) |
| 6. Staff cuts and DOGE | No named proponent found in the sources read | The FAA says its technician workforce is understaffed (Fast Company) | Fast Company: “no evidence yet that any of them caused Friday’s failure.” Nothing in the record ties the stop to DOGE, the 2025 firings or buyouts |
| 7. Not enough money | Duffy: “I have no money for a new network”; requests of $30 billion, then $50 billion | The $12.5 billion was earmarked for radars, radios and other equipment; its $4.75 billion telecommunications line pays to move existing lines to fiber (more than 90 percent of it replaces copper, Duffy said in July 2025), not to build a new network | Larsen and Carson: $4.3 billion obligated and $1 billion spent; DOT: every dollar “accounted for.” These measure different things |
Sources: FAA Q&A, 2026-11-15; DOT, 2026-11-14 and 2026-11-15; Aviation Week, 2026-11; The New York Times, 2026-11-14; The Hill, 2026-11-15; L3Harris, 2026-11-14; Fast Company, 2026-11; CNN live coverage, 2026-11-14; BankInfoSecurity, 2026-11; ABC News, 2026-11-13; The Hill, 2026-11-16; Buttigieg on X, 2026-11-16; Yahoo News live coverage, 2026-11-14.
- Confirmed: a nationwide stop of about 4 hours 20 minutes; a flood of connection attempts on the contractor-run FTI network, traced to two remote sites where L3Harris had changed equipment; partial, widespread loss of radio and radar at 17 of 22 en route centers; no sign of a cyberattack; SMART not involved, by the FAA’s account.
- Not confirmed: the root cause; whether the new router, its installation or the old equipment around it failed; exactly how many routers had the function switched off (the FAA says “more than 60”); and how many cancellations the stop itself caused. No root-cause update after 2026-11-15 was found.
- Oversight so far. Sen. Cantwell said the Commerce Committee will review “technology issues related to how planes communicate through primary frequencies, backup frequencies.” House T&I Chair Sam Graves and Larsen issued a joint statement the same day. No hearing, Inspector General review or GAO review of the stop was found by 2026-11-17. (Source: ABC Audio via Stillwater Radio, 2026-11-13; House T&I, 2026-11-13)
The FAA at the evidence cutoff (2026-11-17; term in progress)
- Leadership. A confirmed Administrator since July 2025; an acting Deputy; Commercial Space, Airspace Modernization and the Chief Administrative Officer posts vacant; a reorganized safety structure. (Source: FAA Key Officials, 2026-10-22)
- Controllers. About 11,000 CPCs, against the new plan’s total-staffing target of 12,563, a different measure from the CPC count; trainee hiring the highest since 2008 in FY2025 and a record in FY2026; overtime at its highest in decades; Newark capped through October 2027. (Source: FAA, 2026-05-15 and 2026-10-01; CRS R49491; Federal Register 2026-12589)
- Equipment. $12.52 billion enacted; about two-thirds of copper lines now replaced by the FAA’s count (no start-of-term count found); no life-cycle cost estimate or master schedule, per GAO; the legacy FTI still carrying traffic. (Source: GAO-26-107992; FAA dashboard via California Today)
- Money. FY2026 enacted 4.2 percent above FY2024 in FY2026 dollars (CPI-U), 10.6 percent nominal; FY2027 on a continuing resolution to 2026-12-11; a request for $30 billion to $50 billion more before Congress. (Source: CRS R49353; ABC News, 2026-11-16)
- Safety. The DCA recommendations partly implemented; Louisville and LaGuardia investigations open; the ground stop’s cause undetermined. (Source: NTSB, 2026-07-27; NTSB, 2026-05-12)
Team’s Take
Team’s Take: The scorecard applies the series’ common instrument from the start of the term (2025-01-20) to the evidence cutoff (2026-11-17), under the rulings that bind all three parts. The start-year is FY2024, the last full fiscal year before the term; the end-year is the latest available, FY2025 for most indicators and FY2026 for the budget. The term is in progress, so every rating is provisional. Indicators this part could read on both ends: the FAA’s fatality-rate result, CPCs and trainees, enacted budgets, capacity caps and outages. It could not read the NTSB’s annual accident tables, a primary serious-incursion count for FY2025, BTS full-year 2025 performance or a near-collision series on a common basis.
| Dimension | Start of term | At the cutoff | Rating | Confidence | Attribution note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Safety outcomes | FY2024: commercial fatality rate 0.01 per 100M persons on board; 9 serious runway incursions | FY2025: the FAA’s fatality target (at or below 4.4 per 100M) “was not met” because of the DCA collision; fatal accidents in the term: 2 Part 121 (DCA 67, Louisville 14) and a foreign-carrier collision at LaGuardia (2); total incursions down about 9%; serious count not available from a primary source | Declined | Medium | The NTSB places DCA’s conditions years before the term and finds no hiring-policy cause; Louisville and LaGuardia are open. A decline on this watch, not shown to be this administration’s doing. Near-collision reporting: not available on a common basis |
| 2. ATC staffing | FY2024: 10,730 CPCs against a CPC target of 14,633; 3,044 trainees; 1,811 hires | FY2025: 10,693 CPCs; 3,530 trainees; 2,028 hires (most since 2008); FY2026: 2,235 hires (a record); overtime 7.3% of hours in FY2025, highest in decades | Mixed | High | Pipeline up, certified controllers flat. FY2025’s hiring goal was set in 2024 and its first 16 weeks fell before the term; FY2026 is wholly this term’s. The 2026 target of 12,563 counts total staffing on a new model and is not comparable with the CPC count |
| 3. Modernization delivery | 51 of 138 systems unsustainable (GAO, 2024); legacy NOTAM; FTI on copper (no start count of converted lines) | $12.52B enacted; about two-thirds of copper lines replaced by 2026-09-30 (FAA count); new NOTAM live 2025-09-29; no cost estimate or master schedule (GAO); equipment-related outages at Philadelphia (2025) and a nationwide stop on the legacy network (2026) | Mixed | Medium | Delivery up, much of it self-reported; planning gaps found by GAO; no program slip re-baselined in the term was sourced. The outages fell on decades-old equipment, and the stop’s cause is undetermined |
| 4. Certification and manufacturer oversight | Boeing cap and 16 OIG recommendations open | In-term action: MD-11 fleet grounded by emergency directive 4 days after Louisville; in-term findings on in-term oversight: none found; inspectors -1.9%, engineers -12.0% (OPM, capacity only) | Insufficient evidence | Low | The NTSB’s 2025 Alaska 1282 finding concerns oversight before the term and is counted in Part 2. The MD-11 design issue dates to a 2011 Boeing service letter. No record either way on the Boeing cap |
| 5. Leadership stability | No confirmed Administrator in office on day one; at least 2 top posts acting (Administrator, Chief Counsel) | 171 of 666 days (25.7%) with no Senate-confirmed Administrator in office (170 days, 25.5%, counted to confirmation); at the cutoff an acting Deputy and three vacant top posts | Mixed | High | 10-30% of the term is Mixed by rule. Not Improved, because the term so far ends with more acting or vacant top posts than it began. The top vacancy was inherited; nomination took 56 days and confirmation 114 more. Turnover below the top came largely through voluntary buyouts the administration offered |
| 6. Budget and funding | FY2024 enacted $20,083.3M nominal ($21,320.4M in FY2026 dollars, CPI-U); F&E $3,191.3M ($3,387.8M real); no lapse in FY2024 | FY2026 $22,208.7M (+10.6% nominal, +4.2% real); F&E $4,000M (+25.3% nominal, +18.1% real); plus $12.52B one-time ($12.94B real); 46 days of lapse in appropriations (43 + 3) | Mixed | High | Funding rose in real terms, and the administration backed the $12.52B; Congress enacted more than requested and refused the RE&D cuts requested. Against that, two lapses in appropriations, which take both Congress and the President to end, forced flight cuts. Operations fell 1.6% in real terms from FY2025 to FY2026 |
| 7. System performance | 2024: on-time 78.10%, cancelled 1.4% (BTS); staffing relief at DCA, JFK, LGA; no Newark cap | Newark capped since May 2025 and through October 2027 (its hourly limit later raised from 68 to 72); 40-airport cuts in Nov 2025; nationwide stop of 4h23m; BTS full-year 2025 not obtained | Mixed | Low | Volume-shock rule: the 2025 lapse in appropriations cut flights and no per-operation rate was readable, so the rating is Mixed, naming the shock. Caps and ATC-zero events moved the wrong way; the Newark limit eased within its cap. Newark’s cap rests on staffing shortfalls dating before 2025; the stop’s cause is undetermined |
| 8. Oversight responsiveness | DOT priority open recommendations: 20 (June 2024) | 21 (June 2025), 22 (June 2026); GAO’s 50 open to the FAA dated 2025-05-15; GAO’s 2026 modernization recommendations partially concurred; NTSB says DCA fixes lag; some DCA actions taken | Insufficient evidence | Low | No FAA-only count on the same basis at both ends; most new recommendations were issued during the term |
Net assessment. Not yet, on outcomes. The term added money, a $12.5 billion rebuild and record hiring in 2026, but fatal accidents, flight caps and a nationwide ground stop went the other way, and the count of fully trained controllers did not grow. Most of those failures go back to before January 2025, so the final answer will turn on three open questions: will the trainees certify, will the rebuild stay on time, and what will the ground-stop inquiry find?
How this differs from the Agency Damage Assessment. Citizen Analyst’s Agency Damage Assessment of the FAA (Federal Aviation Administration — Agency Damage Assessment, draft) is a different instrument that scores damage to the institution attributable to actions since 2025-01-20, leaves the 2026-11-13 stop, whose cause is undetermined, unattributed, and has a composite score pending an editor ruling; the two are cross-referenced, not combined.
On DOGE and the firings. The record supports more than “no DOGE activity after February” and less than “DOGE ran the FAA.” It records four SpaceX engineers (Glantz, Malaska, Kiernan and Smeal) with FAA senior-adviser titles for about three and a half months in the Washington Post’s account, three of them (Glantz, Malaska and Kiernan) under ethics waivers dated 2025-02-17 that are documented, while Smeal’s place rests on press reports alone, and the later revocation of their building and account access. The acting Administrator told the Senate on 2025-03-27 that the FAA had had three SGEs and that no DOGE employee took part in the Starlink decision; that is the administration’s statement. The record documents no FAA decision they directed; the two reports that say they did (the Starlink directive, “Project Lift”) come from anonymous sources and the FAA denies both. On the firings, DOT’s own sworn account is that it rescinded 775 of its roughly 788 probationary terminations on 2025-03-17, so the claimed loss of safety support staff was reversed within about five weeks for those reinstated (the declarations give no FAA-only count), and no measurement of lost output in the interval was found. What cannot be tested either way is the Secretary’s “we kept all the critical safety positions” or the union’s “all of these employees are critical,” because the FAA has no uniform definition of the term. None of this reaches the ground stop of 2026-11-13: no document ties it to DOGE, the firings or the buyouts.
(Analysis developed with AI assistance; reviewed by [editor name])
The Counterfactual
The Counterfactual: Two serious arguments cut against the net assessment, from opposite directions.
The first is that it is too harsh. The administration took office with no confirmed FAA chief. It inherited a controller shortage a decade old and a network built in 2002 on 1960s technology. The NTSB says the risks behind the DCA collision were in place long before January 29. Within 18 months the administration won $12.52 billion for new equipment. The FAA hired more trainees in a year than it ever had. About two-thirds of its copper lines are now replaced, though how many were done before the term is not known, and a new NOTAM system is in service. On this view, results lag spending by years. Grading 22 months on accidents and outages grades the decade before. On staffing, the same view notes that DOT told 775 of its roughly 788 probationary employees within five weeks that their February 2025 terminations were rescinded, by its sworn account, that OPM shows no separation coded as a reduction in force, and that departures outside the core controller and technician series were voluntary buyouts and retirements.
The second is that it is too generous. In 21 months the FAA lost about 30 percent of its executives and of its lawyers, mostly through buyouts and retirements. The top commercial space post sat empty for more than a year. The FAA cut its controller target instead of meeting the old one. Congress funded a controller raise in April 2026, but most of it was released only in October, after senators complained. GAO found billions being spent without a cost estimate or master schedule. One security news site traced the official story of the ground stop changing three times in about 20 hours. On this view, speed without planning is the risk GAO named, and the stop came inside the very upgrade the term promoted. Critics add that the buyouts cost the agency its support, legal and executive ranks, and that SpaceX staff held FAA advisory posts while Starlink terminals were tested at FAA sites. They add that FAA officials could not give senators buyout or firing counts on 2025-05-14 and, by the senators’ account, had not delivered a promised analysis of the cuts’ effect on safety by 2025-07-21.
Both arguments rest on documented facts. They differ on how soon a term can be judged, before its investments pay off. The record at 2026-11-17 cannot settle that. Neither side’s staffing argument reaches the ground stop: no document ties it to the firings, the buyouts or DOGE.
Connections
Connections:
→ This article is Part 3 of a three-part series. Part 1: The FAA ended Trump’s first term with fewer certified controllers. Part 2: The FAA under Biden hired more controllers as its systems aged. Master chronology: The FAA, 2016–2026: A Timeline. → Federal Aviation Administration → Agency Damage Assessment (separate instrument) → Federal Aviation Administration — Agency Damage Assessment (Source: Citizen Analyst knowledge base, draft) → FAA SMART traffic-flow tool → ruled out as a cause of the 2026-11-13 stop by the FAA → FAA SMART: What the AI Air Traffic Planning System Is, and What It Is Not → Sean Duffy → Secretary of Transportation since 2025-01-28 → Sean Duffy – Secretary of Transportation → Bryan Bedford → FAA Administrator since 2025-07-09 → bryan-bedford-profile → Elon Musk → led DOGE; Starlink and Verizon dispute, February 2025 → Elon Musk — Political Accountability Profile → DOGE → special government employees at the FAA, February 2025 → DOGE — Department of Government Efficiency Policy Tracker → Donald Trump → 2025 hiring-policy claim about DCA; 2026 “ruined the system” claim → Donald Trump — 45th and 47th President of the United States → Pete Buttigieg → former Secretary; claims tested in Part 2 → Pete Buttigieg — Secretary of Transportation (Biden Fitness Voucher) → Markwayne Mullin → DHS Secretary at the 2026-11-13 briefing → Markwayne Mullin — DHS Secretary → Russell Vought → OMB Director; co-signed the 2026-11-12 request for $30 billion → Russell Vought – Director, Office of Management and Budget → Eric Schmitt → sponsor of the $30 billion Modern Skies Act → Eric Schmitt — U.S. Senator (R-MO); Former Missouri Attorney General
(AI-surfaced, human verification required before publication)
Civic Action
Civic Action:
→ Check the modernization claims. GAO-26-107992 lists its two open recommendations and the FAA’s response at gao.gov. The FAA’s Modern Skies dashboard reports progress monthly; it is the agency’s own count, not an audit. → Follow the ground-stop investigation. The FAA’s “Nationwide Ground Stop: Questions and Answers” page is the official account. Senate Commerce has said it will review the communications failure; hearings and statements are posted at commerce.senate.gov and transportation.house.gov. → Read the safety record. NTSB dockets for the DCA collision (AIR-26-02), UPS 2976 (DCA26MA024) and the LaGuardia collision are public at ntsb.gov, with the status of each recommendation. → Track staffing. The annual Air Traffic Controller Workforce Plan on faa.gov carries the controller tables; the DOT Inspector General’s recommendation dashboard at oig.dot.gov tracks the training and contract-tower audits. → Ask for records. The FAA accepts Freedom of Information Act requests. The DOT ethics waivers of 2025-02-17 for the SpaceX engineers have been published (by the New York Times); what the special government employees accessed at the FAA in 2025, and the Starlink testing records, have not been. → Oversight requests already made. Sen. Cantwell (2025-02-06), Sen. Markey (2025-02-26) and the Campaign Legal Center (2025-03-13, to DOT’s acting inspector general) each asked for review of DOGE’s or SpaceX’s role at the FAA; no response was found. Readers can ask the DOT Office of Inspector General (oig.dot.gov) and those offices for the status.
Evidence Trail
→ Primary source: FAA, Nationwide Ground Stop: Questions and Answers, 2026-11-15 → Primary source: NTSB, Midair Collision over the Potomac River, AIR-26-02, adopted 2026-01-27 → Primary source: DOT OIG, AV2026035 (2026-09-16), on the lack of a uniform “safety-critical” definition and the 2025 deferred-resignation exempt classes → Primary source: Anne Byrd, declarations in Maryland v. USDA, D. Md. 1:25-cv-00748, ECF 52-1 (2025-03-17) and ECF 103-1 (2025-03-25), on DOT’s 788 terminations, 775 rescissions and 92 resignations → Primary source: Merit Systems Protection Board final order CB-1205-25-0027-R-1 (2026-10-29), reciting DOT’s rescission of the 775 probationary terminations covered by the court order → Primary source: S. Hrg. 119-130 (2025-03-27), S. Hrg. 119-144 (2025-05-14) and S. Hrg. 119-254 (2025-06-11), the Senate records of the acting Administrator’s, FAA officials’ and Bedford’s answers on the engineers and on the analysis of the cuts → Primary source: GAO-26-107992, Air Traffic Control Systems: Ambitious New Modernization Effort Needs to Improve Cost and Schedule Planning, 2026-09-14 → Primary source: FAA, The Air Traffic Controller Workforce Plan 2026-2028 (appendix tables) → Citizen Analyst Knowledge Base: Federal Aviation Administration — Agency Damage Assessment, the FAA Agency Damage Assessment, which scores the same period on a different instrument → External verification: FAA FY2027 Congressional Justification (ten-year budget tables) and the FAA Key Officials page
Sources
Every source below is cited in the text. Dates are publication dates; where the source does not carry one, the entry says so. Research for this article was drawn from the series research files (docs/faa-series-2026-11/research/, waves r1 to r7, g1 to g3 and the FAA Agency Damage Assessment draft) and three searches on 2026-11-17.
Government: FAA and DOT
- FAA. “FAA Statement on Nationwide Ground Stop.” 2026-11-13. https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/faa-statement-nationwide-ground-stop
- FAA. “Nationwide Ground Stop: Questions and Answers.” 2026-11-15. https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/nationwide-ground-stop-questions-and-answers
- DOT. “ICYMI: Secretary Duffy Announces Lifting of Nationwide Ground Stop.” 2026-11-13. https://www.transportation.gov/briefing-room/icymi-us-transportation-secretary-sean-p-duffy-announces-lifting-nationwide-ground
- DOT. “ICYMI: Secretary Duffy Provides Update on Restoration of Airspace.” 2026-11-14. https://www.transportation.gov/briefing-room/icymi-us-transportation-secretary-sean-p-duffy-provides-update-restoration-airspace
- DOT. “ICYMI: Trump’s Transportation Secretary Sean P. Duffy Provides Update Across Sunday Shows.” 2026-11-15. https://www.transportation.gov/briefing-room/icymi-trumps-transportation-secretary-sean-p-duffy-provides-update-across-sunday
- FAA. “FAA General Statements” (entries of 2024-12-12, 2026-09-17, 2026-11-10 and 2026-11-13). [rolling page; entry dates as given]. https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/statements/general-statements
- FAA. “FAA Statements on Newark Liberty International Airport” (entries 2025-04-28 to 2025-07-03). [rolling page; entry dates as given]. https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/faa-statements-newark-liberty-international-airport
- FAA. “FAA Extends Order Limiting Operations at Newark Liberty International Airport.” 2025-09-25. https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/faa-extends-order-limiting-operations-newark-liberty-international-airport
- FAA. “DOT & FAA Announce Temporary 10% Reduction in Flights at 40 Airports.” 2025-11-06. https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/dot-faa-announce-temporary-10-reduction-flights-40-airports
- FAA. The Air Traffic Controller Workforce Plan 2025-2028. 2025-08-21 (page posting date). https://www.faa.gov/sites/faa.gov/files/fy25-air-traffic-controller-workforce-plan_0.pdf
- FAA. The Air Traffic Controller Workforce Plan 2026-2028. [May or June 2026; sources disagree on the date]. https://www.faa.gov/sites/faa.gov/files/Air-Traffic-Controller-Workforce-Plan-2026-2028_0.pdf
- FAA. “FAA Releases Bold, New Air Traffic Controller Hiring Plan.” 2026-05-15. https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/faa-releases-bold-new-air-traffic-controller-hiring-plan
- FAA. “FAA Breaks All-Time Record for Air Traffic Controller Trainee Hiring.” 2026-10-01. https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/faa-breaks-all-time-record-air-traffic-controller-trainee-hiring
- DOT. “Trump’s Transportation Secretary Sean P. Duffy Hits Air Traffic Controller Hiring Goal for FY25.” 2025-09-23. https://www.transportation.gov/briefing-room/trumps-transportation-secretary-sean-p-duffy-hits-air-traffic-controller-hiring-goal
- FAA. “U.S. Transportation Secretary Sean P. Duffy Unveils New Package to Boost Air Traffic Controller Workforce.” 2025-05-01. https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/us-transportation-secretary-sean-p-duffy-unveils-new-package-boost-air-traffic-controller
- FAA. “FAA Releases Updated Air Traffic Controller, Safety Inspector Hiring Plans.” 2025-08-07. https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/faa-releases-updated-air-traffic-controller-safety-inspector-hiring-plans
- FAA. “Trump’s Transportation Department, Air Traffic Controller Union Announce 2.8% Pay Increase Deal.” 2026-10-16. https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/trumps-transportation-department-air-traffic-controller-union-announce-28-pay-increase
- FAA. “U.S. Transportation Secretary Sean P. Duffy Unveils Plan to Build Brand New, State-of-the-Art Air Traffic Control System.” 2025-05-08. https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/us-transportation-secretary-sean-p-duffy-unveils-plan-build-brand-new-state-art-air
- DOT/FAA. Brand New Air Traffic Control System Plan. [publication date not available; May 2025]. https://www.transportation.gov/briefing-room/us-transportation-secretary-sean-p-duffy-unveils-plan-build-brand-new-state-art-air
- FAA. “Trump’s Transportation Secretary Duffy & FAA Administrator Bedford Announce Prime Integrator for Brand New Air Traffic Control System.” 2025-12-04. https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/trumps-transportation-secretary-duffy-faa-administrator-bedford-announce-prime-integrator
- DOT/FAA. “Trump’s Transportation Secretary Sean P. Duffy & FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford Unveil New Agency Structure to Enhance Safety, Embrace Innovation, & Increase Transparency.” 2026-01-26. https://www.transportation.gov/briefing-room/trumps-transportation-secretary-sean-p-duffy-faa-administrator-bryan-bedford-unveil
- DOT. “NOW BOARDING: … Deliver Radical Transparency with New ‘Modern Skies’ Website.” 2026-05-22. https://www.transportation.gov/briefing-room/now-boarding-trumps-transportation-secretary-sean-p-duffy-faa-administrator-bedford
- FAA. “U.S. Transportation Secretary Sean P. Duffy Deploys Brand New ‘Notice to Airmen’ System.” [publication date not available; September 2025]. https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/us-transportation-secretary-sean-p-duffy-deploys-brand-new-notice-airmen-system-provide
- DOT. “Sean Duffy Sworn In as Secretary of U.S. Department of Transportation.” 2025-01-28. https://www.transportation.gov/briefing-room/sean-duffy-sworn-secretary-us-department-transportation-and-takes-immediate-action
- FAA. Testimony of Bryan Bedford, Senate Commerce Aviation Subcommittee, “FAA Response to the NTSB Final Report on the DCA Accident.” 2026-05-19. https://www.faa.gov/testimony/testimony-bryan-bedford-faa-administrator-hearing-us-senate-committee-commerce-science
- FAA. FY 2025 Agency Financial Report. [publication date not available; FY2025 report]. https://www.faa.gov/about/office_org/headquarters_offices/afn/offices/finance/offices/financial_management/ar/fy25-faa-agency-financial-report.pdf
- FAA. FY 2027 President’s Budget Submission (Congressional Justification), Exhibits II-1, II-2 and Ten-Year Tables. 2026-04-03 (budget release date per CRS). https://www.transportation.gov/sites/dot.gov/files/FAA_FY_2027_Budget_Estimates_CJ.pdf
- FAA. “Key Officials.” Captures last updated 2024-12-20, 2025-03-19, 2025-08-20, 2026-01-26, 2026-04-14, 2026-06-23 and 2026-10-22. https://www.faa.gov/about/key_officials
- FAA. “Rebecca Guy” (ATO leadership). Last updated 2026-01-29. https://www.faa.gov/about/office_org/headquarters_offices/ato/leadership/guy
- FAA. NextGen Final Report 2025. [publication date not available]. https://www.faa.gov/nextgen/NextGen-Final-Report-2025.pdf
- FAA. “FAA Statements on Aviation Accidents and Incidents.” [rolling page]. https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/statements/accident_incidents
- FAA. Modern Skies dashboard, as read and reported by California Today (item 104). [rolling page; figures as of 2026-09-30]. https://modernskies.faa.gov/
- Federal Register. 2026-12589, “Operating Limitations at Newark Liberty International Airport.” 2026-06-23. https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/06/23/2026-12589/operating-limitations-at-newark-liberty-international-airport
- Federal Register. 2026-12593, “Staffing-Related Relief Concerning Operations at Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport, John F. Kennedy International Airport, and LaGuardia Airport.” 2026-06-23. https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/06/23/2026-12593/staffing-related-relief-concerning-operations-at-ronald-reagan-washington-national-airport-john-f
- Office of Personnel Management. Federal Workforce Data, FAA unit TD:TD03, snapshots 202412 to 202609, as tallied in the FAA Agency Damage Assessment draft. Retrieved 2026-11-17. https://data.opm.gov/get-data/api-access
- Bureau of Transportation Statistics. Airline On-Time Statistics and Delay Causes, August 2026. [rolling page]. https://www.transtats.bts.gov/ot_delay/ot_delaycause1.asp
Oversight: GAO, DOT OIG, NTSB
- GAO. GAO-26-107992, Air Traffic Control Systems: Ambitious New Modernization Effort Needs to Improve Cost and Schedule Planning. 2026-09-14. https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-26-107992
- GAO. GAO-26-107320, Air Traffic Control Workforce: FAA Should Establish Goals and Better Assess Its Hiring Processes. 2025-12-17. https://files.gao.gov/reports/GAO-26-107320/index.html
- GAO. GAO-24-107001, Air Traffic Control: FAA Actions Are Urgently Needed to Modernize Aging Systems. 2024-09-23. https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-24-107001
- GAO. GAO-25-108162 (testimony). 2025-03-04. https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-25-108162
- GAO. GAO-25-108502, Federal Aviation Administration: Key Provisions in the 2024 Reauthorization Act and Related GAO Work. 2025-05-15 (date as recorded in the series research and Part 2’s fix pass). https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-25-108502
- GAO. Priority open recommendations to DOT, GAO-25-108054 (June 2025, counting 20 as of June 2024 and 21 in June 2025) and GAO-26-109050 (June 2026). [day not available]. https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-26-109050
- GAO. GAO-26-108439, Aviation Cybersecurity: Enhanced Air Safety Requires FAA to Better Mitigate Threats to Aircraft Communications. 2026-09-21. https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-26-108439
- DOT OIG. AV2025026, runway incursions. 2025-03-12. https://www.oig.dot.gov/library-item/46745
- DOT OIG. AV2025036, NextGen benefit and cost projections. 2025-07-23. https://www.oig.dot.gov/library-item/46878
- DOT OIG. Capstone Memorandum on NextGen (CC2025010). 2025-09-29. https://www.oig.dot.gov/library-item/46974
- DOT OIG. “Audit Initiated of Air Traffic Controller Training at the FAA Academy,” with related items (Newark relocation audit initiated 2025-07-28). 2026-02-05. https://www.oig.dot.gov/library-item/47116
- DOT OIG. AV2026022, contract tower staffing. 2026-03-24. https://www.oig.dot.gov/library-item/47229
- DOT OIG. AV2026031, “Despite Implementing the National Training Initiative and Increasing Supplemental Pay, FAA Still Faces Challenges Meeting Air Traffic Controller On-the-Job Training Goals.” 2026-06-24. https://www.oig.dot.gov/sites/default/files/library-items/Final%20Report_%20FAAs%20Implementation%20of%20ATC%20OJT%20Initiatives%20.pdf
- DOT OIG. AV2025002, Boeing production oversight. 2024-10-09. (as recorded in Part 2)
- NTSB. “NTSB Makes Urgent Recommendations on Helicopter Traffic Near Reagan National Airport.” 2025-03-11. https://www.ntsb.gov/news/press-releases/Pages/NR20250311.aspx
- NTSB. “Systemic Failures Led to Midair Collision Over Potomac River in Washington.” Release dated 2026-01-28 on the 2026-01-27 board meeting. https://www.ntsb.gov/news/press-releases/Pages/NR20260127.aspx
- NTSB. Midair Collision over the Potomac River, AIR-26-02 (probable cause; findings 10, 11). Adopted 2026-01-27. https://www.ntsb.gov/investigations/AccidentReports/Reports/AIR2602.pdf
- NTSB. Statement from Chairwoman Jennifer Homendy on the open DCA recommendations. 2026-07-27. https://www.ntsb.gov/news/press-releases/Pages/NR202607027.aspx
- NTSB. Aircraft Accident Investigative Update, DCA26MA024 (UPS 2976). 2026-01-14 (date as recorded in the series timeline). https://www.ntsb.gov/investigations/Documents/DCA26MA024%20Investigative%20Update.pdf
- NTSB. UPS Flight 2976 investigative hearing announcement. 2026-05-12. https://www.ntsb.gov/news/press-releases/Pages/nr20260512.aspx
- NTSB. “Boeing’s Inadequate ‘Training, Guidance and Oversight’ Led to Mid-Exit Door Plug Blowout.” 2025-06-24. https://www.ntsb.gov/news/press-releases/Pages/NR20250624.aspx
Congress and CRS
- CRS. R49491, on the 2025 lapse in appropriations and aviation. 2026-10-22. https://www.congress.gov/crs-product/R49491
- CRS. R48728, Transportation, HUD and Related Agencies Appropriations for FY2026. [publication date not available; updated after 2026-02-03]. https://www.everycrsreport.com/reports/R48728.html
- CRS. R48596, Department of Transportation Funding: FY2021-FY2025 Enacted and FY2026 Requested. [publication date not available; 2025]. https://www.congress.gov/crs_external_products/R/HTML/R48596.html
- CRS. R48947, Department of Transportation FY2027 Funding Request. [publication date not available; 2026]. https://www.congress.gov/crs-product/R48947
- CRS. R49341, THUD Appropriations for FY2027. 2026-09-03. https://www.everycrsreport.com/reports/R49341.html
- CRS. R49353, Overview of Continuing Appropriations for FY2027. 2026-09-17. https://www.congress.gov/crs-product/R49353
- Congress.gov. H.R. 7148, Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2026 (P.L. 119-75, signed 2026-02-03). https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-bill/7148/all-info
- Public Law 119-21. Enacted 2025-07-04. https://www.congress.gov/119/plaws/publ21/PLAW-119publ21.pdf
- Senate Commerce. S.Hrg. 119-254, Nomination of Bryan Bedford. 2025-06-11. https://www.congress.gov/event/119th-congress/senate-event/LC74982/text
- Senate Commerce. S.Hrg. 119-409, “FAA’s Plan for ATC Modernization.” 2025-12-17. https://www.congress.gov/event/119th-congress/senate-event/LC75575/text
- House T&I Committee. “The State of American Aviation” (Bedford testimony and committee remarks). 2025-12-16. https://transportation.house.gov/calendar/eventsingle.aspx?EventID=409150
- House T&I Democrats. “Ranking Members Larsen, Carson Statements from Hearing with FAA Administrator Bedford.” 2025-12-16. https://democrats-transportation.house.gov/news/press-releases/ranking-members-larsen-carson-statements-from-hearing-with-faa-administrator-bedford
- House T&I Committee. “Graves and Larsen Joint Statement on Today’s FAA Ground Stop” (title and date only). 2026-11-13. http://transportation.house.gov/news/documentsingle.aspx?DocumentID=408932
- Sens. Tammy Duckworth and Dick Durbin. Letter to the FAA on the controller pay increase. 2026-09-04. https://www.duckworth.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/duckworth_durbin_letter_to_faa_re_atc_pay_increase.pdf
- Sens. Adam Schiff and Tammy Duckworth. Letter to NASA and FAA on Musk conflicts of interest. [publication date not available; 2025]. https://www.duckworth.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/letter_to_nasa_faa_on_musk_conflicts_of_interest.pdf
- Sen. Maria Cantwell, statement on the ground stop, as quoted by ABC Audio via Stillwater Radio. 2026-11-13. https://stillwaterradio.net/abc-national-news
News and analysis
- CNBC. “Federal Aviation Administration head Michael Whitaker to step down.” 2024-12-12. https://www.cnbc.com/amp/2024/12/12/federal-aviation-administration-head-michael-whitaker-to-step-down-jan-20.html
- CNBC. “FAA to strengthen oversight as Boeing set to resume 737 MAX production.” 2024-11-07. https://www.cnbc.com/2024/11/07/faa-to-strengthen-oversight-as-boeing-set-to-resume-737-max-production.html
- FactCheck.org. “No Evidence for the Political Finger-Pointing Over D.C. Plane Crash.” 2025-01-31. https://www.factcheck.org/2025/01/no-evidence-for-the-political-finger-pointing-over-d-c-plane-crash
- Fox News. “Elon Musk’s SpaceX engineers part of DOGE team at FAA.” [publication date not available; February 2025]. https://www.foxnews.com/politics/elon-musks-spacex-engineers-deployed-faa-help-modernize-air-traffic-control
- The Hill. “Musk says DOGE will make ‘rapid safety upgrades’ to air traffic control system.” [publication date not available; February 2025]. https://thehill.com/policy/technology/5129134-el-musk-urges-quick-safety-upgrades-faa
- CNBC. Cantwell on Musk and air traffic control reform. 2025-02-06. https://www.cnbc.com/2025/02/06/elon-musk-airspace-reform-conflict-senate-cantwell-duffy.html
- CBS News. Duffy’s campaign to “supercharge” controller hiring. [publication date not available; February 2025]. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/elon-musk-retired-air-traffic-controllers-return-to-work/
- The Hill (Tara Suter). “Duffy on cuts at FAA: ‘We kept all the critical safety positions’.” 2025-02-24. https://thehill.com/policy/transportation/5161325-faa-workforce-cuts ; archived copy (live page refuses capture): https://web.archive.org/web/20250227190444/https://thehill.com/policy/transportation/5161325-faa-workforce-cuts/
- Professional Aviation Safety Specialists (PASS). “PASS on Reinstatement of Probationary Employees at FAA.” [publication date not available; March 2025]. https://passnational.org/news/875-pass-on-the-reinstatement-of-probationary-employees-at-faa
- Reuters. “Musk’s DOGE team to visit US FAA command center on Monday.” 2025-02-17 (search summary only; page refused; the 2025-02-17 visit is confirmed by items 170 to 172). https://www.reuters.com/world/us/musks-doge-team-visit-us-faa-air-traffic-control-command-center-monday-2025-02-17
- Politico. “Musk’s DOGE, SpaceX both land at FAA.” 2025-02-19. https://www.politico.com/news/2025/02/19/doge-faa-solve-challenges-email-00204962 ; archived copy (live page refuses capture): https://web.archive.org/web/20250220001147/https://www.politico.com/news/2025/02/19/doge-faa-solve-challenges-email-00204962
- Fortune. “Elon Musk begins testing his Starlink terminals in the U.S. airspace system.” 2025-02-25. https://fortune.com/2025/02/25/elon-musk-begins-testing-his-starlink-terminals-in-the-u-s-airspace-system
- CNBC. Musk’s Starlink safety claims and the FAA’s statement. 2025-02-27. https://www.cnbc.com/2025/02/27/elon-musk-starlink-faa-safety-claims.html
- Associated Press via Yahoo Finance. “As DOGE slashes budgets, FAA close to canceling $2.4b contract with Verizon and giving it to Musk’s Starlink.” [publication date not available; February 2025]. https://finance.yahoo.com/news/doge-slashes-budgets-faa-close-162656428.html
- Reuters via Yahoo Finance. “USDOT says Verizon not moving fast enough on $2.4 billion FAA contract.” 2025-03-11. https://finance.yahoo.com/news/usdot-says-verizon-not-moving-205606307.html
- The Hill. “Watchdog requests probe into FAA business with Musk’s Starlink.” [publication date not available; March 2025]. https://thehill.com/policy/technology/5193227-faa-starlink-investigation-conflict
- Reuters (David Shepardson) via Yahoo Finance. “US FAA not considering replacing L3Harris, Verizon contracts with Musk’s Starlink.” 2025-07-16. https://ca.finance.yahoo.com/news/us-faa-not-considering-replacing-161335429.html
- The Guardian. “Doge cuts spark questions as employees supporting Musk space launches spared.” 2025-04-18. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/apr/18/trump-space-employees-musk
- CNBC. “Trump nominates Republic Airways CEO Bryan Bedford as US FAA head.” 2025-03-17. https://www.cnbc.com/2025/03/17/trump-nominates-republic-airways-ceo-bryan-bedford-as-us-faa-head.html
- Politico. “Airline CEO confirmed as next FAA chief.” 2025-07-09. https://www.politico.com/news/2025/07/09/airline-ceo-faa-chief-00445100 ; ABC News, “Senate confirms Bryan Bedford as FAA administrator,” 2025-07-09, https://abcnews.com/Politics/senate-confirms-bryan-bedford-faa-administrator/story?id=123550778
- CBS News (Kris Van Cleave). “FAA’s head of air traffic retiring early as agency replaces senior managers at Reagan National Airport.” 2025-04-09. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/tim-arel-faa-air-traffic-chief-retires-faa-replacing-dca-managers
- SpaceNews (Jeff Foust). “Head of FAA’s commercial space office takes buyout.” 2025-04-28. https://spacenews.com/head-of-faas-commercial-space-office-takes-buyout
- Government Executive (Eric Katz). “The Trump administration is staffing up parts of FAA, it’s also incentivizing thousands of departures and threatening layoffs.” 2025-05-15. https://www.govexec.com/management/2025/05/trump-administration-staffing-parts-faa-its-also-incentivizing-thousands-departures-and-threatening-layoffs/405347
- AeroCorner. “FAA Deputy Administrator Rocheleau Is Leaving for NBAA.” [publication date not available; reports a 2026-07-30 announcement; single source]. https://aerocorner.com/news/faa-deputy-administrator-rocheleau-departure
- Reuters via Yahoo Finance. “Senators ask US to disclose if FAA administrator sold stake in airline.” 2026-02-05. https://finance.yahoo.com/news/senators-ask-us-disclose-faa-160526491.html
- CNN. “FAA slashes hiring target, saying it can keep the skies safe with fewer air traffic controllers than it thought.” 2026-05-15. https://www.cnn.com/2026/05/15/us/faa-slashes-hiring-target
- CBS News. “Illinois senators blast FAA administrator for holding air traffic controller raises ‘hostage’.” [publication date not available; on or after 2026-09-04]. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/illinois-senators-faa-air-traffic-controller-pay-raises
- Business Insider. “Trump Wants $10K Bonus for Air Traffic Controllers Who Didn’t Call Out.” [publication date not available; November 2025]. https://www.businessinsider.com/trump-bonus-air-traffic-controllers-shutdown-2025-11
- CNBC (Reuters). “NTSB criticizes FAA for failing to act before fatal Army helicopter collision.” 2025-07-30. https://www.cnbc.com/2025/07/30/us-probes-army-helicopter-altitude-data-in-fatal-january-crash-with-jet.html
- Eno Center for Transportation. “NTSB Unveils Findings, Probable Cause and Recommendations from DCA Mid-air Collision Investigation.” 2026-01-30. https://enotrans.org/article/ntsb-unveils-findings-probable-cause-and-recommendations-from-dca-mid-air-collision-investigation
- California Today. “The FAA’s nationwide ground stop lasted 4 hours and 23 minutes…” 2026-11-13 (updated). https://californiatoday.com/news/transportation/faa-nationwide-ground-stop-november-13-2026
- CBS News/AP. “FAA grounds MD-11 planes after deadly Kentucky crash.” [publication date not available; November 2025]. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/kentucky-ups-crash-planes-grounded-md-11-boeing-fedex
- Reuters via Investing.com. “NTSB probes controller as part of broader investigation into LaGuardia airport collision.” 2026-03-23. https://ca.investing.com/news/stock-market-news/ntsb-probes-controller-as-part-of-broader-investigation-into-laguardia-airport-collision-4528940
- Reuters. “Tracking technologies failed to prevent deadly LaGuardia collision, NTSB says.” 2026-03-24 (search summary only). https://www.reuters.com/world/us-safety-agency-says-tracking-system-failed-laguardia-during-jet-collision-2026-03-24
- Reuters. “Controllers say LaGuardia needed more staff on busy night of Air Canada collision.” 2026-03-27 (search summary only). https://www.reuters.com/world/controllers-say-laguardia-needed-more-staff-busy-night-air-canada-collision-2026-03-27
- The Air Current. “Decades of aircraft and ground vehicle near misses at LGA preceded fatal crash.” [publication date not available; 2026] (search summary only). https://theaircurrent.com/feed/dispatches/aircraft-ground-vehicle-near-misses-runway-incursions-lga-preceded-fatal-crash
- Bellanca Aircraft (reprint of AvWeb). “Severe runway incursions jump 44% in 2025.” 2026-08-10 (unverified; the FAA notice itself was not read). https://bellancaaircraft.com/severe-runway-incursions-jump-44-in-2025
- CNN. “Newark airport delays: Air traffic controllers lost communication with planes after they took leave for trauma.” 2025-05-05. https://www.cnn.com/2025/05/05/us/newark-airport-additional-flight-delays
- CNBC (Reuters). “U.S. proposes to extend Newark airport flight cuts through October 2026.” 2025-08-08. https://www.cnbc.com/2025/08/08/us-proposes-to-extend-newark-airport-flight-cuts-through-october-2026.html
- Futurism. “Hundreds of Flights Grounded Across the Eastern Seaboard as Government Rolls Out AI Air Traffic Control System.” 2026-09-21 (as cited in item 137). https://futurism.com/advanced-transport/flights-grounded-east-coast-government-faa-ai-air-traffic-control
- RTX. “RTX awarded FAA contract to deploy next-generation surveillance radars.” 2026-01-05. https://www.rtx.com/news/news-center/2026/01/05/rtx-awarded-faa-contract-to-deploy-next-generation-surveillance-radars-for-nation
- FLYING Magazine (reprint). “RTX Seeks Larger Role in FAA’s $12.5B ATC Overhaul.” 2026-03-04. https://bellancaaircraft.com/rtx-seeks-larger-role-in-faas-12-5b-atc-overhaul
- GovTribe, NOTAM Modernization IDIQ 693KA725D00001 [rolling record]; Orange Slices, “CGI wins $275M FAA NOTAM Modernization IDIQ,” 2025-11-19. https://govtribe.com/award/federal-idv-award/indefinite-delivery-contract-693ka725d00001 ; https://orangeslices.ai/cgi-wins-275m-faa-notam-modernization-notam-management-service-nms-idiq
- Aviation Week. “FAA says router malfunction led to ground stop.” [publication date not available; November 2026]. https://aviationweek.com/air-transport/safety-ops-regulation/faa-says-router-malfunction-led-ground-stop
- The New York Times. “Defense Contractor L3Harris Was Behind Upgrade That Led to Ground Stop.” 2026-11-14. https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/14/us/l3harris-ground-stop.html
- CNBC. “‘Root cause’ of nationwide ground stop is unknown, FAA says.” 2026-11-14 (search summary only). https://www.cnbc.com/2026/11/14/root-cause-of-nationwide-ground-stop-is-unknown-faa-says.html
- The Hill. “Duffy says he ‘can’t cancel’ contract with firm behind FAA outage.” [publication date not available; 2026-11-15 or 16]. https://thehill.com/policy/transportation/6221409-duffy-cannot-cancel-l3harris
- L3Harris. “L3Harris Statement on the Nov. 13 Ground Stop.” 2026-11-14. https://www.l3harris.com/newsroom/press-release/2026/11/l3harris-statement-nov-13-ground-stop
- ABC News. “Transportation Secretary Duffy says ATC routers’ ability to broadcast data turned off, being investigated.” 2026-11-13. https://abcnews.com/Politics/transportation-secretary-duffy-atc-routers-ability-broadcast-data/story?id=138155545
- CNN. Live coverage, “Key questions about FAA ground stop still unanswered.” 2026-11-14. https://www.cnn.com/2026/11/14/us/live-news/us-ground-stop-flights
- Yahoo News. Live coverage of the ground stop. 2026-11-14. https://www.yahoo.com/news/us/live/faa-ground-stop-latest-updates-duffy-blames-contractor-l3harris-thousands-more-flights-canceled-saturday-no-sign-of-cyberattack-161329174.html
- Fast Company (Alex Pasternack). “The FAA’s ground stop has a simple culprit. Its causes may not.” [publication date not available; after 2026-11-15]. https://www.fastcompany.com/91643272/the-faa-was-warned-about-its-telecom-upgrade
- BankInfoSecurity. “Anatomy of the FAA Ground Stop: One Backbone, One Bad Change.” [publication date not available; on or after 2026-11-16]. https://www.bankinfosecurity.com/anatomy-faa-ground-stop-one-backbone-one-bad-change-a-33396
- ABC News. “Duffy asked for $50B for air traffic control after ground stop, a marked increase.” 2026-11-16. https://abcnews.com/Politics/duffy-asked-50b-air-traffic-control-after-ground/story?id=138183456
- The Hill. Buttigieg and Trump on the FAA ground stop. 2026-11-16. https://thehill.com/policy/transportation/6223723-buttigieg-trump-faa-groundstop
- Pete Buttigieg on X. Statement on the ground stop. 2026-11-16. https://x.com/PeteButtigieg/status/2122401936720695318
- Benzinga via Yahoo Finance. “Elon Musk Says Sean Duffy Turned Down Free Starlink for FAA.” 2026-11-16. https://finance.yahoo.com/technology/articles/elon-musk-says-sean-duffy-014354751.html
- CBS News. “Trump appoints new FAA administrator after vacancy during deadly plane crash.” [publication date not available; late January 2025]. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/plane-crash-dc-faa-administrator-trump-appointment
- DroneLife. “Chris Rocheleau Appointed as Acting FAA Administrator.” 2025-01-30. https://dronelife.com/2025/01/30/chris-rocheleau-appointed-as-acting-faa-administrator
- CBS News. Starlink, the FAA and Musk’s conflicts of interest (the FAA’s “no decisions have been made” statement). [publication date not available; February 2025] (search summary only). https://www.cbsnews.com/news/starlink-faa-contract-elon-musk-conflict-of-interest
- Government Executive. “Air traffic controller pay raise stalled by DHS shutdown.” [publication date not available; February 2026] (search summary only). https://www.govexec.com/pay-benefits/2026/02/air-traffic-controller-pay-raise-stalled-dhs-shutdown/411472
- Bureau of Labor Statistics. CPI for All Urban Consumers, U.S. city average, all items (series CUUR0000SA0), averaged by fiscal year in the series’ deflator table. Data extracted 2026-11-17. https://data.bls.gov/timeseries/CUUR0000SA0
Citizen Analyst
- Citizen Analyst. Federal Aviation Administration — Agency Damage Assessment, FAA Agency Damage Assessment (draft; composite pending an editor ruling).
- Citizen Analyst. FAA SMART: What the AI Air Traffic Planning System Is, and What It Is Not. 2026-11-13.
- Citizen Analyst. The FAA under Biden hired more controllers as its systems aged (Part 2, draft), for the 2024 baseline figures it records with their sources.
Added 2026-11-17: DOGE, special government employees and the probationary firings (from the series research file g4-doge; items 139 to 163)
- Merit Systems Protection Board. “Interested Terminated Probationary Employee – DOT,” regulation-review docket CB-1205-25-0027-R-1, Final Order (nonprecedential). 2026-10-29. https://www.mspb.gov/decisions/nonprecedential/DOT_Interested_Terminated_Probationary_Employee_-_CB-1205-25-0027-R-1_4187721.pdf
- DOT OIG. AV2026035, “FAA Completes Workforce Plans That Are Mandated by Law, but Some Safety-Critical Workforces and Key Information Are Not Included in the Plans.” 2026-09-16. https://www.oig.dot.gov/sites/default/files/library-items/Final%20Report%20-%20FAA%20Aviation%20Safety%20Workforce.pdf
- FAA. Airway Transportation Systems Specialist Workforce Plan 2026-2030, chapter 2. 2026-05-15. https://www.faa.gov/sites/faa.gov/files/Airway-Transportation-Systems-Specialist-Workforce-Plan-2026-2030.pdf
- DOT Office of General Counsel. “Approval of Waiver Pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 208(b)(1)” (three waivers dated 2025-02-17 and a continuation dated 2025-02-21), as published by The New York Times; the series did not retrieve them from DOT. [posting date not shown]. https://static01.nyt.com/newsgraphics/documenttools/145907425b2509be/191a2276-full.pdf
- Sen. Maria Cantwell. Letter to Secretary Duffy on Musk conflict of interest. 2025-02-06. https://www.commerce.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/media/doc/2.6.25%20Letter%20to%20Sec%20Duffy%20re%20Musk%20Conflict%20of%20Interest_FINAL.pdf
- Sen. Edward Markey. “Senator Markey Raises Concerns Over Conflict of Interest with FAA Deployment of Elon Musk’s Starlink Terminals.” 2025-02-26. https://www.markey.senate.gov/news/press-releases/senator-markey-raises-concerns-over-conflict-of-interest-with-faa-deployment-of-elon-musks-starlink-terminals
- Campaign Legal Center. “Is Musk Using the FAA to Benefit Himself and His SpaceX Subsidiary, Starlink?” 2025-03-13. https://campaignlegal.org/update/musk-using-faa-benefit-himself-and-his-spacex-subsidiary-starlink
- WIRED. “These Are the SpaceX Engineers Already Working Inside the FAA.” 2025-02-19. https://www.wired.com/story/faa-doge-elon-musk-space-x
- ProPublica. “The Key Figures Working Alongside Elon Musk at DOGE and in the Trump Administration” (tracker entries for the FAA added 2025-03-13; page read 2026-11-17). https://projects.propublica.org/elon-musk-doge-tracker
- Bloomberg News. “How Elon Musk muscled his way into the FAA.” Feature dated 2025-03-05; syndicated copy via TNS 2025-03-09 (the copy was read; the original was not fetched). https://www.thelcn.com/news/how-elon-musk-muscled-his-way-into-the-faa/article_af64c663-f9e8-51da-8b44-1ed2d3e55989.html ; https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2025-03-05/after-elon-musk-lands-at-faa-his-starlink-business-stands-to-gain-business
- AeroTime. “FAA: Musk’s team not involved in Starlink terminal decisions” (citing Reuters, 2025-03-27). 2025-03-28. https://www.aerotime.aero/articles/faa-musks-team-not-involved-in-starlink-terminal-decisions
- Rolling Stone. “Musk Allies Made FAA Staff Sign NDAs to Keep New Project Secret.” 2025-04-25. https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-features/trump-musk-doge-faa-nda-secret-project-lift-1235325667
- The Washington Post. “A diminished DOGE reels from the departure of the ‘Dogefather,’ Elon Musk.” 2025-06-08 (syndicated copy read in full; the original did not fetch). https://www.postguam.com/business/world/a-diminished-doge-reels-from-the-departure-of-the-dogefather-elon-musk/article_791bb35b-affe-4c6b-956a-d61294058e77.html ; https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2025/06/08/doge-elon-musk-exit-trump
- The Air Current. “FAA firings put definition of ‘safety-critical’ under scrutiny.” 2025-02-18. https://theaircurrent.com/aviation-safety/doge-layoffs-faa-safety-critical-roles-scrutiny
- Professional Aviation Safety Specialists. “PASS on Firing of Probationary Employees at FAA.” Dated 2025-02-15, updated 2025-02-18. https://passnational.org/news/873-pass-statement-on-firing-of-probationary-employees-at-faa
- ABC News. “Layoffs hit FAA, including employees tasked with producing air traffic navigation maps.” 2025-02-21. https://abcnews.com/Politics/layoffs-hit-faa-including-employees-tasked-producing-air/story?id=119060253
- MeriTalk. “Union Chief Calls FAA Layoffs ‘Dangerous’.” [February 2025; day not shown]. https://www.meritalk.com/articles/union-chief-calls-faa-layoffs-dangerous
- Associated Press. “Some of the 400 jobs that were cut at the FAA helped support air safety, a union says.” 2025-02-19 (date inferred from the article’s “Wednesday”). https://apnews.com/article/faa-firings-trump-doge-safety-airlines-27390c6a7aac58063652302df5a243d3
- House Transportation and Infrastructure and Oversight Committee Democrats. Letter to Secretary Duffy on FAA probationary firings. 2025-03-03. https://democrats-transportation.house.gov/imo/media/doc/ti_and_oversight_letter_to_faa.pdf
- Clearinghouse. Maryland v. USDA, 1:25-cv-00748 (D. Md.), case summary. [March 2025; summary dated 2025-03-16]. https://clearinghouse.net/case/46203
- Federal News Network. “25,000 fired feds reinstated after courts find probationary terminations illegal.” [March 2025; day not shown, about 2025-03-25]. https://federalnewsnetwork.com/workforce/2025/03/25000-fired-feds-reinstated-after-courts-find-probationary-terminations-illegal ; and “Appeals court blocks another ruling that ordered reinstatement of probationary workers,” 2025-04-09. https://federalnewsnetwork.com/litigation/2025/04/appeals-court-blocks-another-ruling-that-ordered-reinstatement-of-probationary-workers
- Justia. State of Maryland v. USDA, No. 25-1248 (4th Cir.). 2025-09-08. https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca4/25-1248/25-1248-2025-09-08.html
- The Philadelphia Inquirer. “South Jersey FAA workers fired at recommendation of Musk’s DOGE.” 2025-02-27. https://www.inquirer.com/politics/new-jersey/elon-musk-firings-antennas-faa-hughes-20250227.html
- The Fulcrum. “Are FAA Staff Cuts Causing Current Airport Delays?” 2025-05-07. https://thefulcrum.us/governance-legislation/federal-aviation-administration-airport-delays
- Professional Aviation Safety Specialists. “PASS On the Nationwide Ground Stop.” 2026-11-14 (date inferred from “Yesterday”). https://passnational.org/news/pass-on-the-nationwide-ground-stop
Added 2026-11-17: names, the 2025-02-17 visit and the court and hearing records (from the series research file g5-doge2; items 164 to 173)
- Anne Byrd, Declaration (28 U.S.C. § 1746), Exhibit 1 to the Status Report, Maryland v. USDA, No. 1:25-cv-00748 (D. Md.), ECF 52-1. 2025-03-17. https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/69714275/52/1/state-of-maryland-v-united-states-department-of-agriculture/
- Anne Byrd, second declaration, Maryland v. USDA, ECF 103-1. 2025-03-25. https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/69714275/103/1/state-of-maryland-v-united-states-department-of-agriculture/
- Daniel T. Ronneberg, Declaration, President, FAA Employees Union, Local 1653 (AFSCME District Council 20), AFGE v. OPM, No. 3:25-cv-01780-WHA (N.D. Cal.), ECF 18-17. Filed 2025-02-23. https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/69655364/18/17/american-federation-of-government-employees-afl-cio-v-united-states/
- Senate Commerce Subcommittee on Aviation, Space, and Innovation. S. Hrg. 119-130, “NTSB Preliminary Report: The DCA Midair Collision.” Hearing 2025-03-27; GPO print 2025-08-13. https://www.congress.gov/119/chrg/CHRG-119shrg61288/CHRG-119shrg61288.pdf
- Senate Commerce. S. Hrg. 119-144, “FAA Reauthorization One Year Later: Aviation Safety, Air Traffic and Next Generation Technology.” 2025-05-14. https://www.congress.gov/119/chrg/CHRG-119shrg61427/CHRG-119shrg61427.pdf
- Sens. Edward Markey, Tim Kaine and ten other senators. Letter to Bedford, “FAA staffing cuts and safety.” 2025-07-21. https://www.markey.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/senate_letter_on_faa_staffing_cuts_and_safety_7212025.pdf
- Politico. “Musk’s SpaceX team visiting key FAA command center – despite past frictions.” 2025-02-17. https://www.politico.com/news/2025/02/17/elon-musk-spacex-faa-visit-00204577
- CNBC (Reuters). “FAA fires fewer than 400 workers, transportation chief says.” 2025-02-17. https://www.cnbc.com/2025/02/17/trump-begins-firings-of-faa-air-traffic-control-staff-just-weeks-after-fatal-dc-plane-crash.html
- Axios. “Musk’s SpaceX personnel visiting FAA to suggest improvements.” 2025-02-17. https://www.axios.com/2025/02/17/elon-musk-space-x-doge-faa-air-traffic-control
- Politico Weekly Transportation. “Details emerge on SpaceX engineers at the FAA” (Wayback copy read). 2025-03-03. https://www.politico.com/newsletters/weekly-transportation/2025/03/03/details-emerge-on-spacex-engineers-at-the-faa-00206882
Initial research and drafting assisted by AI; all facts independently verified by [editor name].
